News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by thiht on Thursday September 21, 2023 @05:31PM (#37604668)
Why are there so many loopholes in every single US law?

Everytime there’s a major health issue or anything extremely anti consumer it’s because of a loophole in the formulation of a US law.

Are US lawmakers that bad? Or is it judges who interpret laws literally instead of using the intent?

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by ip26 on Thursday September 21, 2023 @05:40PM (#37604779)
There are often fairly sensible reasons or good intent behind many of them. People don't normally drink hot water; it's not a great idea, as it has higher levels of dissolved solids and higher risk of contamination by organisms (like legionnaires). Meanwhile, lead helps make metals and solders more resilient to high temperatures and fatigue at low cost. Banning lead from the hot side could therefore decrease reliability and increase cost, for arguably little to no health benefit.

I don't have a vested interest in the lead industry, but it's pretty clearly not simple maleficence.

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by CyberDildonics on Thursday September 21, 2023 @06:50PM (#37605518)
Basically nothing you said here is true.

People don't normally drink hot water

People drink hot water all the time not to mention cooking, tea, instant coffee and more.

legionnaires

That's from water being stagnant for long periods of time.

lead helps make metals and solders more resilient to high temperatures

Not only is this not true, but water is never going to go above boiling. Propane torches (used for soldering pipes) burns at 1,980C

Banning lead from the hot side could therefore decrease reliability

This is ridiculous. Soldered pipes have been in use for over 70 years. Where are getting this idea?

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by wkat4242 on Thursday September 21, 2023 @07:14PM (#37605738)
> People drink hot water all the time not to mention cooking, tea, instant coffee and more.

I always use cold water and then boil it in a kettle. Even in Europe with our copper pipes the heat will dissolve more crap apparently. It's always advised to do this.

> That's from water being stagnant for long periods of time.

Yeah stagnant under optimal bacterial growth temperatures like 30C. And it enters the body through the lungs, from vapors in the shower. Not drinking it doesn't prevent legionnaire disease.

In fact what does prevent it is heating the water significantly, like around 60C. And chlorinating. It's also why the water here in Spain it's almost undrinkable from all the chlorine here in summer. They just have to put that much in it to prevent outdoor pipes growing bacteria. Yet in summer the water is still hot and brown when I open the tap after it's been outside in the pipe all day. I drink a lot of bottled water, lol.

> Not only is this not true, but water is never going to go above boiling. Propane torches (used for soldering pipes) burns at 1,980C

Yeah lead solder actually melts at a much lower temperature. I still use it for that reason because lead free is a bitch to work with. I only solder micro electronics though.

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by CyberDildonics on Thursday September 21, 2023 @07:34PM (#37605903)
I always use cold water and then boil it in a kettle.

That's great for you. This has nothing to do with how absurd the idea of using lead in 'hot pipes' would be.

Not drinking it doesn't prevent legionnaire disease.

I didn't say anything about drinking, I just said it comes from stagnant water.

I still use it for that reason because lead free is a bitch to work with. I only solder micro electronics though.

Lead free solder is very easy to work with when putting copper pipes together. The torch puts out a lot of heat and you don't have to worry about destroying anything near it (except for wood behind it). I can't imagine all the twisted logic it would take for someone to think using leaded solder in pipes is a good idea.

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by c22 on Friday September 22, 2023 @10:41PM (#37620169)
One time I sweated a joint about 1 foot away from an electrical line running inside a steel conduit. The ambient heat (plus, I guess, whatever load was on the wires) was enough to melt the jacketing and cause a short.
Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by c22 on Thursday September 21, 2023 @10:27PM (#37607156)
I wash my cups and dishes with hot water, then I drink and eat from them later.
Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by ComputerGuru on Thursday September 21, 2023 @11:50PM (#37607621)
> legionnaires

Actually, this is famously caused by having water that’s not hot enough. It became a problem in some countries when they advised lowering boiler temps to save energy.

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by gmkabro on Thursday September 21, 2023 @05:38PM (#37604763)
It’s money. The answer is money. Somebody makes money by producing lead-infused products, so they pay off lawmakers to add a loophole that allows them to continue making money.
Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by tlrobinson on Thursday September 21, 2023 @06:23PM (#37605252)
Bill Gurley’s recent talk is worth a watch https://youtu.be/F9cO3-MLHOM
Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by hodgesrm on Thursday September 21, 2023 @09:39PM (#37606864)
That's an excellent talk. Thanks for posting.
Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by sneak on Thursday September 21, 2023 @09:25PM (#37606741)
Yet people still maintain the popular fiction that corruption isn't that common in the large western countries, and that it's somehow more prevalent in the east. It's nonsense.

Everywhere there are large governments, there is huge corruption that is literally killing people so that others may be enriched without working as much.

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by lacrimacida on Thursday September 21, 2023 @10:10PM (#37607070)
A small government wouldn’t magically solve this problem though
Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by Clubber on Thursday September 21, 2023 @10:39PM (#37607229)
>A small government wouldn’t magically solve this problem though

You'd have a lot fewer corrupt officials though.

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by ikekkdcjkfke on Friday September 22, 2023 @12:57AM (#37608044)
Well there are so many social issues that suck the oxygen out
Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by jstarfish on Thursday September 21, 2023 @05:54PM (#37604944)
People shit on California's Proposition 65, but the notices at Fry's made me aware of the lead content of solder, and the ones at Michael's highlighted the lead in Christmas decorations, lights, and fake trees/garland.

I went most of my life ignorant of all of this. But banning stuff outright seems like it would be counterproductive to either industry (banning soldering would be disruptive) or public image ("Liberals declare war on Christmas!").

(Tangential mention of McDonald's, whose warnings highlighted the acrylamide released in the potato-frying process.)

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by XorNot on Thursday September 21, 2023 @06:32PM (#37605351)
Lead-free solder exists though. It works fine - particularly for plumbing where you don't have tin-whisker concerns.

The only problem I've ever had with it is (1) that it turns out Bunnings in Australia sells utterly atrocious flux (the good stuff is also non-toxic, potable compatible and made in USA - and it works perfectly) and (2) that people aren't aware enough of the problem (i.e. my parents house has lead solder all through the plumbing where my father didn't know there was a difference and extended it).

EDIT: For any Australians out there - this one - https://www.totaltools.com.au/154135-la-co-56g-soldering-flu... - buy this one. This is the one which works.

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by boppo1 on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:28PM (#37606343)
Artist here. The UK had/has a ban on all lead white paint. Real bummer. Ti white works in a pinch, but it has dramatically different properties.
Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by kube-system on Thursday September 21, 2023 @06:54PM (#37605548)
If you write laws without an exceptions for exceptional cases, then you get more laws with unintended consequences.
Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by ekianjo on Thursday September 21, 2023 @07:09PM (#37605691)
> Why are there so many loopholes in every single US law

Bribery of politicians

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by deciplex on Thursday September 21, 2023 @07:27PM (#37605846)
Us lawmakers are effectively the employees of the people profiting from skirting these health issues.
Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by chmod600 on Thursday September 21, 2023 @10:13PM (#37607080)
It's much easier and faster to pass a law with loopholes that still removes 90%+ of the bad stuff you want to remove.

If you try to solve 100% of the problem you have the bad stuff on the market for another 10 years while the details are sorted out.

Or you just ignore the details and ram through the bill, and find out about a lot of unintended consequences and have a mess.

Ideally, politicians would pass the bill with loopholes first, and then follow up and try to close them to finish solving the problem. But that's one of those things like refactoring and code cleanup that you always mean to do and never get around to.

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by rendall on Friday September 22, 2023 @01:07AM (#37608103)
> Or is it judges who interpret laws literally instead of using the intent?

It's hard to interpret intent in a way that is consistent and fair. A ruling that does not go by what is written down is open to be criticized, while a ruling that adheres to the letter is almost never overturned.

Re:Lead poisoning causes far more death, IQ loss than though... by epivosism on Friday September 22, 2023 @01:18AM (#37608179)
Why can antelope still run faster than most cheetahs?

What I mean is that you only see what survives. The thousands of products which used to have lead which don't anymore are gone, out of sight out of mind. The ones which someone forgot, or someone bribed a politician to preserve, or even ones which were created specifically afterwards and which the law had no way to even know about, to ban, are what you see.

Dynamic systems have this property, and it's hard to get permanent dominance since both sides keep adjusting.