News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by orochimaaru on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @10:39AM (#37584761)
Why complain if you need him? Not being snarky - but when it comes to things like these either you need some entity or you don’t. Sometimes they are needed bad enough that we excuse horrible behavior (US black sites, Saudi’s and Yemen, etc.). I think if you look you can put forth a rather long list.

Point is unless you have the power to remove turkey from nato the complaining is pointless.

Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by f6v on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @10:43AM (#37584824)
We’re allowed to dislike hypocrisy, aren’t we?
Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by orochimaaru on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @10:48AM (#37584888)
I didn’t mean the “you” as in personally but rather the states that represent you.

As an example - Sweden and NATO. If the Turks weren’t needed I’m sure NATO members could have come up with a method to remove them. Otherwise, Erdogan is going to press his advantage. From his perspective Kurds are terrorists. The reality is more complicated - but its what everyone is going to hold their nose and live with.

Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by nradov on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @11:41AM (#37585613)
Instead of being "sure" you should actually read the treaty. NATO members can withdraw, but there is no mechanism for other members to remove Turkey. And due to their geographic position they are absolutely still needed: removing Turkey would play into Putin's hands and could lead to catastrophic geopolitical consequences far worse than putting up Erdogan.
Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by Y_Y on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @11:43AM (#37585637)
If Sweden is willing to host the missile sites that are currently in Turkey then it might be an interesting proposition, seeing as they have a similarly strategic location.
Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by nradov on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @11:59PM (#37593070)
What missile sites? There are no strategic missiles in Turkey. The USAF does store some other nuclear weapons there. Sweden is not really an equivalent replacement option.

Do you want Turkey to turn into a Russian ally? Because driving Turkey out of NATO is how you turn Turkey into a Russian ally.

Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by binarymax on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @10:44AM (#37584827)
Not everyone thinks that we need those things.

It’s also not “complaining”, it’s spreading awareness.

Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by medo-bear on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @10:46AM (#37584864)
maybe he is not needed as much as he thinks he is
Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by fakedang on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @11:31AM (#37585484)
Yeah sure, second largest NATO military, battle-hardened in recent wars, not to mention rising military power in the Middle East, not needed in a defensive alliance, heh.

Not to mention control of the Bosphorus, as well as a tendency to have dalliances with Russia when ignored by the US (a tendency that, I must remind you, predates Erdoğan).

Start paying up 2% of your GDP (assuming you're European), on defence and military, or don't talk. Turkey is certainly paying their share, and paid their share way before Sultan Erdoğan took the throne.

Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by glogla on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @11:44AM (#37585647)
Alliances are not just about power, but also about common values and goals. Strong allies are good. Strong enemies that are for historic reason part of alliance are pretty bad, and need to be managed.

That is why Turkey is not getting F-35s or even F-16s now. Why help arm your enemy?

Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by orochimaaru on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @12:26PM (#37586212)
I mean what values do the west share with middle eastern monarchies? Yet they are propped up and lavished with weapons.

Alliances are mostly power jockeying. Common values will help to provide longevity to the alliance, but power is primary.

Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by glogla on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @01:22PM (#37586952)
I don't see many middle eastern monarchies in NATO.
Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by orochimaaru on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @02:08PM (#37587635)
Bahrain houses the 5th fleet. USCC and USAFCC are out of qatar. I’d call that being allies. And since they’re US bases they will be used by nato in times of conflict (or otherwise).
Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by fakedang on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @01:01PM (#37586687)
The fact that Israel is a nation propped up by $3.5 billion of arms spending by the US, yet makes sure to oppress the Palestinian population in their country in the guise of maintaining their "Jewish mess" is a direct affront to your "western values in alliances" nonsense.

Alliances are based out of pragmatism and a common enemy/threat. They have always been the case since history, whether it was the aggressive Assyrians' neighbours against them, to the Franco-Ottoman alliance, to the Axis alliance in WW1.

Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by glogla on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @01:44PM (#37587262)
Israel is still considered ally for multitude of reasons: big organisations don't turn on a dime and sometimes take decades to change course (same reason Turkey is still considered ally), fascists love Israel as model "pure people state" more than they hate Jews, and small but influential part of American Evangelicals believe that Jews having their own state is necessary step to get us the Rapture.

But you probably know all this, nothing you said was in good faith and and just come to HN to turn your hatred on random people.

Re:British journalist held by police at Luton airport for fi... by janc_ on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @05:04PM (#37590162)
Turkey has a lot of cheap draftees, but not so much otherwise. IIRC Sweden's military budget is double (or more?) that of Turkey, for example...