I'm not even sure if in hindsight the wrong decision was made.
~Not enough people in 1985, I guess. They seem more concerned with leap years than anything. https://groups.google.com/g/net.bugs/c/ZGlqGwNaq3I
Unix time is 32 bits, so I guess Unix time was invented a bit later, but around 1970, when Unix was written, RAM cost around $700k/megabyte, or, ballpark, $1/byte (https://jcmit.net/memoryprice.htm)
Even if you had infinite memory, you couldn’t use much of it in your computer. The PDP-7 that Unix started life on topped out at 144kB, the PDP-11 that it was soon ported to at 288kB (64k 36-bit words), and many installs wouldn’t have that.
But at least Jeff bezos is putting his fortune into an immortal clock in the desert (I'm being sarcastic but the desert clock is actually real and supposedly a gift to future generations as if measuring time wasn't a problem that stone-age civilizations all over the world were able to solve independently).