News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by helpfulContrib on Sunday September 17, 2023 @09:12AM (#37544713)
I can explain it to you, even though it will inevitably be downvoted for being unsavory to our readers' mindset ..

In the fog of war, all bets are off.

Apparently, we do not have the evidence of who actually blew the dam, because we do not have the conditions required to gain sufficiently suitable evidence. Perhaps one day we will, but sufficient doubt exists that we cannot make canonical conclusions.

Yet.

The best we can do is use conjecture and assumptions - but in the court of world opinion, this just simply isn't enough. It is the same situation behind the destruction of the Nordstream 2 pipeline or the Duma gas attacks - we can make assumptions, and conjecture, over who did it and how and for what purpose - but until there is actionable evidence, its simply not enough to make conclusions based on ones own political position.

Such is the nature of Lady Liberty - she is blind in the face of verifiable evidence - and this is a core Western Value which shall not be abrogated, for any reason - especially in the face of oppression, where she is needed most.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by yostrovs on Sunday September 17, 2023 @09:27AM (#37544848)
From the point of view of morality, I'm of the opinion that Russia did it. Even if Ukraine actually pulled the trigger. Just like in many US states: if you and your buddy get into someone's house to rob it in the middle of the night, and the homeowner gets his revolver and shoots your buddy dead, and you run out and the police catch you, it will be you that will be prosecuted for murder. You created the situation that led to the end result.
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by Dabphil on Sunday September 17, 2023 @09:37AM (#37544943)
If your morality justifies murder, it's not Christian morality, it's Satanism.
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by helpfulContrib on Sunday September 17, 2023 @09:57AM (#37545110)
That is a slippery slope argument that can be equitably applied by the Russians who believe this war was started by the West in 2016.

Be careful with the ease by which you can adopt this perspective. It doesn't actually serve you to adopt such fallacies. Evidence is important - faith in the world institutions that will act on that evidence, just as important. Literally nothing in your position will have a positive effect on those institutions.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by hdjjhhvvhga on Sunday September 17, 2023 @10:19AM (#37545325)
> Russians who believe this war was started by the West in 2016.

Why 2016? Putin first sent his troops to Ukraine in 2014. So from his point of view it would make sense to convince his citizens he was "forced" to do it earlier, not later.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by helpfulContrib on Sunday September 17, 2023 @02:05PM (#37547759)
For context, I live in middle-Europe, very close to the war, and as a result of my volunteer work with refugees, I have had extensive contact with both Ukrainian refugees, as well as Russian citizens entangled in this heinous mess.

The Russians I have spoken to about this consider that the West started aggressively arming Ukraine for this war in 2016, which was when official, overt US policies were put in place to allow it.

They identify this year as the point of no return, as "the West started officially arming Ukraine for conflict in 2016", a fact that can be observed in the US' 2016 Section 655 Report by the Dept of State. This is when US weapons first made it to the front lines.

I'm not here to argue for them - I would suggest you seek out Russian citizens and engage them on the topic, if it interests you what the other side have to say about this. I relay this merely to give context to this discussion; not because my opinion aligns with any of this.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by petre on Sunday September 17, 2023 @03:53PM (#37548715)
Then: "We were forced to invade Hungary and Czechoslovakia, they wanted free elections."

Now: "We were forced to invade Ukraine, the US gave them weapons to defend themselves and they won't have our man as president."

The US, UK and now the rest of NATO are doing the right thing arming Ukraine. The US ia doing the right thing approving weapons sales to Taiwan and Korea.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by helpfulContrib on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:57AM (#37557980)
"The US gave them weapons to attack Russia." <- ftfy.

The USA, which arms well known fascist totalitarian-authoritarian dictators engaged in actual genocide, is doing absolutely the wrong thing. US' arms exports are a significant cause of war and calamity across the globe - not safety and security. War, and calamity.

If the US were building roads and water treatment plants across the globe, instead of bombing them - then your claim that it is doing the right thing might have some substance. But, it isn't. The only thing the US builds on foreign nations' soils, is illegal dark CIA torture bases.

You see, this line of thinking works both ways ..

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by hdjjhhvvhga on Monday September 18, 2023 @12:14PM (#37558230)
> "The US gave them weapons to attack Russia." <- ftfy.

This would only make sense if Ukrainians were suicidal enough to actually even consider attacking Russia. Yet, in spite of massive attacks on civil houses and infrastructure, there is nothing comparable on the part of Ukraine. They attacked very few targets on Russian soil, and as far as I can tell, these were only military targets, and attacked only after Russia started the war.

One would have to be either delusional or paranoid to think Ukraine wanted to attack Russia. The only thing these folsk wanted is to stay as far away from the Russian regime as possible. Unfortunately, they weren't allowed to.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by helpfulContrib on Monday September 18, 2023 @12:58PM (#37558772)
>This would only make sense if Ukrainians were suicidal enough to actually even consider attacking Russia.

When you consider yourself a minority and you are convinced you will be wiped out and are thus desperate, it is not uncommon for highly courageous acts to be made.

There are no hard black/white lines in this spectacle.

>They attacked very few targets on Russian soil

I challenge you to differentiate between attacking a nation, and attacking a nations citizens, and justify those legislative positions which allow this difference to be attained, across a spectrum of international sovereign nations' own laws on the protection of their citizens.

It is specious to assume, for example, that the USA are the only nation that would bomb other countries in order to protect their citizens' interests.

Other nations do it, too.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by xg15 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @10:17AM (#37545311)
> From the point of view of morality, I'm of the opinion that Russia did it. Even if Ukraine actually pulled the trigger.

Are you talking about the war at large or about the specific question who blew up the dam?

I'd agree with the sibling comment here. In war, morality is always crystal clear for the parties that are at war - we are the good guys, the others are the bad guys. I'd go out on a limb and say this is almost a requirement to be able to fight a war in the first place: If you didn't think you are in the right, how would you even motivate your own troops to risk their lives for your cause?

Usually, when historians look back at the war later, they find the actual morality to be anything but clear.

> if you and your buddy get into someone's house to rob it in the middle of the night, and the homeowner gets his revolver and shoots your buddy dead, and you run out and the police catch you, it will be you that will be prosecuted for murder. You created the situation that led to the end result.

This isn't how it works. In this case, you have two separate crimes - robbery and murder - with two different perpetrators - the burglars and the homeowner.

The homeowner has a good chance that his charge will be dropped as a case of self-defence - but in no way would the robbers suddenly end up with a murder charge against themselves because they are "obviously" the bad guys.

(And by the way, the homeowner might in fact be prosecuted for murder if it turned out there was no self-defence situation and he just shot the robber out of rage.

You can use this to counter the russian argument too, btw: Even if you assume, for the sake of the argument, that Russia was threatened by an expanding NATO and by a militarized Ukraine, is it still "self-defence" to invade - and keep invading - a country, annexing land, attacking power stations and grain storage sites?)

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by rich_sasha on Sunday September 17, 2023 @10:29AM (#37545407)
I think it's hard to imagine a future historical context in which Russia is the goodie here.
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by xg15 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @10:33AM (#37545441)
Then you should ask a few people from South American or African countries.
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by rich_sasha on Sunday September 17, 2023 @01:29PM (#37547442)
Like the ones who were buying food from Ukraine? Food that is either bombed by the Russians, or stuck in a port under a Russian blockade?

I mean, admittedly, some of the grain the Russians stole and are trying to sell it on. Is that the Good Samaritan points?

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by xg15 on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:05PM (#37549300)
Fully agreed here - just that, from what I understand so far, the global south countries are interested in ending the war as soon as possible, with little regard to the conditions - because the longer the war will go on, the further the food crisis will worsen for them.

In contrast, Ukraine and the West are interested in a full Ukrainian victory, even if it takes a long time.

So the interests are not completely aligned here.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by helpfulContrib on Sunday September 17, 2023 @02:11PM (#37547826)
Or rather, ask the Iraqi or Afghani or Syrian or Libyan or Somalian, or Yemeni people, if they think the US and the West are the 'good guys'.

This is purile argumentation. The West, by statistic, are not the good guys. Neither are Russia.

The closest 'good guys' we've got are nations like Austria, who only send their military for the purpose of observing the war crimes of the other belligerents...

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by jrmg on Sunday September 17, 2023 @10:26AM (#37545376)
in many US states if you and your buddy get into someone's house to rob it in the middle of the night, and the homeowner gets his revolver and shoots your buddy dead, and you run out and the police catch you, it will be you that will be prosecuted for murder.

This isn’t actually true, is it?

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by lisper on Sunday September 17, 2023 @10:44AM (#37545540)
Yes, it is.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Felony_murder_rule

IMHO it's a defensible position.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by rjzzleep on Sunday September 17, 2023 @10:20AM (#37545337)
Did everyone forget that Ukraine was happily shelling the Kakhovka dam last year and that every western media outlet was reporting on it[1]?

It's sort of a rhetorical question, since the answer is clearly yes, but come on, we sit here talking like we know everything better than everyone else, about the world, about policy and everything else in general, yet we constantly forget things that happened only a couple of months ago?

Russians did this because Russians are crazy evil beings that like to destroy their own shit. Really? I understand that sort of reasoning coming from the media outlets that gave us the Iraq war amongst other things, but hacker news? Is that what we pride ourselves in?

[1] https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraines-russian-held-n...

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by Theodores on Sunday September 17, 2023 @11:00AM (#37545717)
I think the question has to be asked - who benefits?

It is like Nordstream where we are supposed to believe the Russians did it. Yet they controlled the taps to it and had no benefit from blowing it up.

I read a lot of information from the Russian side and we clearly have two truths regarding the Kakhovka Dam. The Russians understand that the Kiev regime did it. Furthermore, if you look at the graph of the water level in the lake, the Kiev regime released water from upstream to deliberately top it up so they could blow it up and sweep away all of the Russian armed forces downstream in the Kherson area.

People that only get their news from one side - the NATO side - are not aware of how the Russians understand what happened. I suspect these people are the ones that are modding you down, but sometimes getting down voted is worth it.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by euroderf on Sunday September 17, 2023 @11:17AM (#37545941)
"Kiev regime" - interesting choice of term.
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by dralley on Sunday September 17, 2023 @11:25AM (#37546044)
The IAEA didn't refute anything, their statement was couched in tons of language like "from the areas we have seen" while also stating that they haven't been allowed to see all of the areas they wanted to see.

Anyway, from the article in the OP

"The destruction of the dam, Russian President Vladimir Putin said in a news conference a week after the event, "ruined their counteroffensive in this direction." It was a comment that didn’t fit particularly well with his claim that the Ukrainians had destroyed the dam themselves."

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by petre on Sunday September 17, 2023 @03:17PM (#37548408)
It's just like with the little green men who invaded Crimea:

  2014: "It isn't us, you can go to the store and buy any uniforms."

  2015: "That’s why I gave orders to the Defense Ministry -- why hide it? -- to deploy special forces of the GRU as well as marines and commandos there under the guise of reinforcing security for our military facilities in Crimea."

  2023: “I want to point out and I want everyone to know about it: The maintenance of the entire Wagner Group was fully provided for by the state.”
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by rjzzleep on Monday September 18, 2023 @06:38AM (#37554452)
I think you ought to look up the UN security council resolution 2202 (2015)[1] by which the Minsk agreements became part of international law.

Fun trivia fact for you, in 2014 in multiple cities Ukranian soldiers defected to the east and took loads of military equipment with them[2].

Of course history has been conveniently written the entire last year.

[1] https://press.un.org/en/2015/sc11785.doc.htm

[2] https://web.archive.org/web/20140420132508/https://www.chron...

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by petre on Monday September 18, 2023 @08:23AM (#37555190)
Putin never wanted peace through the Mink agreements, he only wanted to buy time. But US and the UK weren't wasting time either.

"Amid rising tensions between Russia and Ukraine in early 2022, Russia officially recognised the DPR and LPR on 21 February 2022.[9] Following that decision, on 22 February 2022, Russian President Vladimir Putin declared that the Minsk agreements "no longer existed", and that Ukraine, not Russia, was to blame for their collapse.[10] Russia then invaded Ukraine on 24 February 2022."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minsk_agreements

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by rjzzleep on Monday September 18, 2023 @09:22AM (#37555749)
Funny you should say that, since:

a) the Ukrainian forces were saved by the Minsk agreements[1]

b) it was both Merkel and Hollande that said they tried to buy time using the Minsk agreements[2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Battle_of_Debalts...

[2] https://archive.ph/c4ZVK

[3] https://kyivindependent.com/hollande-there-will-only-be-a-wa...

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by helpfulContrib on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:50AM (#37557875)
How do you know Putin never wanted peace with the Minsk agreements? Why were they officially ratified, then?
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by jnsaff2 on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:06PM (#37558873)
And immediately broken. Why were "green men" invading Ukraine, Putin LYING about them not being russian army and then later telling proudly that of course they were russian army.
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by petre on Monday September 18, 2023 @03:39PM (#37560960)
> How do you know Putin never wanted peace

Happo-Kuzushi. Typical judoka balance breaking. He wants peace, just under his own terms. Like Belarus, only with a weaker puppet he can control.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by pydry on Sunday September 17, 2023 @04:12PM (#37548864)
>"The destruction of the dam, Russian President Vladimir Putin said in a news conference a week after the event, "ruined their counteroffensive in this direction." It was a comment that didn’t fit particularly well with his claim that the Ukrainians had destroyed the dam themselves."

It fits just fine. Ukraine was pressured into this offensive by its western partners and was publicly dragging its feet for months. They knew it wouldn't be successful.

Washing their hands of one of the fronts while doing a massive amount of damage to the Russian side of the Dnieper that they knew they were never going to recapture probably seemed like a good trade off.

The narrative that Russia blew it up and did more damage to themselves because they were terrified of the counter offensive, on the other hand, matches with reality about as well as "Russia blew up nordstream 2" did. Their public stance before the offensive was that it would be a catastrophic failure because it lacked air support and was at a munitions disadvantage and lo and behold that's exactly what happened.

So why on earth would they blow up a dam that would do far more damage to the areas they controlled?

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by _kbh_ on Sunday September 17, 2023 @07:07PM (#37550242)
> So why on earth would they blow up a dam that would do far more damage to the areas they controlled?

Because actions like this are less about Russia winning and more about Ukraine losing.

They did this to cause decades of damage to Ukraines industry and an ecocide.

It’s the same reason they fire missiles into civilian buildings, destroy power plants during winter, rape and torture children, execute teenagers and fire on civilians. L The terror and damage destruction is the point.

Destruction of this dam was also a war crime by Russia.

They gain a lot by trying to cover up another of there war crimes and to muddy the water with their firehose of falsehood propaganda method.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by pydry on Monday September 18, 2023 @03:45AM (#37553426)
>They did this to cause decades of damage to Ukraines industry and an ecocide.

"They did this to cause decades of damage to Ukraines industry and an ecocide" and ended up doing more damage to the side they controlled doesn't make any sense at all. Not unless you assume that Russia is some irrational cartoonist supervillain that would cut off its own nose to spite its face.

"They did this because they were terrified of the counter offensive" made more sense than that.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by jnsaff2 on Monday September 18, 2023 @05:07AM (#37553903)
> Not unless you assume that Russia is some irrational cartoonist supervillain that would cut off its own nose to spite its face.

So they went to Ukraine to gain what? At the expense of what?

How would you explain why they brutally attacked Ukraine without coming to the conclusion of them being exactly what you described?

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by helpfulContrib on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:54AM (#37557929)
They went to Ukraine to take the land required to give them a buffer against NATO-aligned forces, which have called for the destruction of Russia for years - and thats exactly what they've created.

Whether you like that answer or not, has no bearing on whether the cartoon-character in your head reflects reality. It clearly doesn't.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by jnsaff2 on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:02PM (#37558827)
So in 1939 did they invade Poland in defense against Nato as well?

This is just such a dumb take, even the mafia bosses running the show don't believe that.

Let alone Ukraine not being in NATO at all.

Also I remember the rhetoric being about denazification, so apparently every russian nationalist has a different story they push.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by _kbh_ on Monday September 18, 2023 @07:11PM (#37563387)
> They went to Ukraine to take the land required to give them a buffer against NATO-aligned forces, which have called for the destruction of Russia for years - and thats exactly what they've created.

Interesting cause the victory article they accidentally posted then quickly deleted didn’t even mention NATO once.

But do you know what it did talk about?, the tragedy of Ukrainian independence and fixing that historical “mistake” of 1991.

That sounds more like imperialism than wanting a buffer state to me.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by pydry on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:40PM (#37559317)
>So they went to Ukraine to gain what?

Thats a different question entirely to who blew up the dam and why.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by jnsaff2 on Monday September 18, 2023 @01:57PM (#37559551)
So you are avoiding that question?

Also it's crystal clear that if russia had not illegally invaded Ukraine no-one would have blown up the dam.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by pydry on Monday September 18, 2023 @04:38PM (#37561689)
Yes I am avoiding this sharp departure from the original topic.
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by jnsaff2 on Monday September 18, 2023 @04:42PM (#37561741)
Then we can discount you argument that they are not crazy or spiteful as you are not willing to discuss refutations.
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by petre on Sunday September 17, 2023 @03:36PM (#37548584)
They shelled the road above it, as opposed to blowing up the engine room where only Russians had access.

It's pretty clear who did it, but you can wait 50 years until the CIA report about it is declassified if you want to be absolutely sure.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by helpfulContrib on Thursday September 21, 2023 @12:49PM (#37600361)
>shelled by "someone"

See, that is entirely the point. In the fog of war, unless someone takes responsibility for an action, we cannot be sure who performed that action.

There is substantial reason to believe that covert Western operatives are also on the battleground. This is, after all, what those trillions of dollars of 'investment' each year, are all about .. however this equally valid suspicion is, tribally, also easily overlooked.

Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by dindobre on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:18AM (#37557363)
Next stop: a nuclear bomb gets dropped on a Ukrainian city wiping out thousands of people like nothing and we'll still have someone stating "we don't really know who did it". I'm honestly amazed humanity made it to 2023
Re:A trip to Dried-up Kakhovka Reservoir by helpfulContrib on Monday September 18, 2023 @12:51PM (#37558668)
Ask yourself, by what means do we get there? The answer is: people believing they are more right than anyone else.

>humanity

We have been doing the opposite - believing in the righteousness of others - as well. Somehow, it has balanced out so far, but that is really the point of being a fair and open society, seeking truth in the face of all duress, in order to provide justice: we have a balance.

Until the call for the more base, banal emotions overwhelms the rational and the discreet, and - above all - the common truth-seeking which all humans can produce, no matter the languages we use, we have peace.

But, when that happens, it happens fast and it happens on the basis of forgone conclusions, know-best, pride, hubris and arrogance. On all sides of the fence.

As long as there is a modicum of truth-seeking left - and not assumption-based superstition-driven mob rule - we humans have a lot more than 2023 to attain ..