News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by thedrbrian on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:31AM (#37508786)
> Antarctica: Full of badass women and mediocre men

Stopped reading right there.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by boredumb on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:42AM (#37508916)
Good for you, if you kept going it goes on to complaing about... Antarctica being too white also. I'm sorry, a scientist in Antartica and you are spending your down time shadow boxing racism and sexism?

> Antartica: Is the harsh conditions and weather actually a form of redlining?

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by langliru on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:16AM (#37509406)
As a non-white woman I appreciate she is sharing details about race and gender. If the ratios are so extreme, then these aspects would have been a relevant part of the experience. If you're a white man, I understand how you might be annoyed as it may feel like she's throwing jabs at your club.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by shrimp_emoji on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:41AM (#37509647)
This is phrased as if you can't talk about the salience of a minority race and gender experience without racist and sexist deification of the minority and, as if by Netwon's third law, shitting on the majority. That's limited to the blurb, but it's still hurtful and inflammatory. It makes me wish we could just merge those forces back to neutral so we least seem like we're egalitarian (the pamphlet told me that was the goal, I recall).
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by EatingWithForks on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:28AM (#37510285)
I think it's difficult to dissociate this from the "how much can a banana cost?" style harmful ignorance. It makes sense to me that a woman who feels like she experienced sexism at the workplace from men have a poor opinion of the men there. Should she not say as such to make an appearance of neutrality, when she didn't experience a neutral or egalitarian environment?
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by invalidOrTaken on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:46AM (#37510533)
>It makes sense to me that a woman who feels like she experienced sexism at the workplace from men have a poor opinion of the men there.

This does not make sense to me. I've experienced poor treatment from whites, blacks, men, women, straights, and gays. Should I have a poor opinion of whites, blacks, men, women, straights, and gays?

It seems a similar leap from her own experience and anecdotal reports from coworkers to tarnish the 700-ish strong male pop of McMurdo as "mediocre."

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by EatingWithForks on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:00PM (#37510698)
I mean, this is also obviously an anecdote. In her experience, she worked with mediocre men. I think we're all intelligent enough to recognize that she's obviously talking from her experience.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by invalidOrTaken on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:23PM (#37511001)
>I think we're all intelligent enough to recognize that she's obviously talking from her experience.

She is talking from her experience, sure, but she's certainly going well beyond that!

>There’s a phrase I heard tossed around that I think is pretty accurate: Antarctica: Full of badass women and mediocre men.

But even more than epistemology, this is uncivil. Polite society is made up of small restraints for the sake of others. This represents one more crack in that.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by EatingWithForks on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:29PM (#37511113)
It's curious to me, that you're concerned she's extrapolated her experience to some set of men in Antarctica, and you've extrapolated her behavior to a crack in all of polite society in turn.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by at_a_remove on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:36AM (#37509603)
It isn't a "club," I was born to my race and sex the same way you were.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by kajecounterhack on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:49AM (#37509765)
It is a club in the sense that people self sort by ethnicity and gender in many social settings, and exclusion/discrimination against nonwhites & women is a well documented phenomenon.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by somenameforme on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:17AM (#37510159)
People sort into groups that have similar interests. This article is an example of it. Hey guys, who wants to go spend a year living in the middle of nowhere, in an ice cold region, dark enough to drive people insane, for mediocre pay?

For some people that sounds like an awesome adventure. For others its incomprehensible why anybody would even consider it. And these sort of interests, for both genetic and cultural reasons, are not going to be evenly distributed. It doesn't mean that e.g. hiphop or basketball is excluding non-blacks anymore than death metal and swimming is excluding non-whites.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by JambalayaJim on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:29AM (#37510288)
There is a very obvious reason why “going on an adventure for mediocre pay” would be both more feasible and appealing, to members of a financially advantaged group.

It’s absolutely incredible that you’re ascribing this as a cultural phenomenon!

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by RugnirViking on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:49AM (#37510561)
You're saying this as though the reason most people there are able to go is by living on savings. I don't think that's true - anyway with bread and board covered it's more likely to push away those with dependants than economic class. As someone who'd really like to work for my country's arctic/Antarctic program, I think the biggest barrier is getting qualified to work there, which is stuff like mountain leader courses etc. Mountaineering is not exactly a cheap hobby, but it's also fair that they only want to hire people with survival experience
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by JambalayaJim on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:05AM (#37524178)
It’s not just about being able to live on savings. When you come from a poorer community you can’t really afford to take on an expensive education and mediocre pay, because the outcome of that expensive education generally requires you also support your parents/family that helped you get there.

But moreover yeah, richer families can do more outdoorish activities like mountaineering and that feeds back into the loop of even being interested in something like this.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by somenameforme on Friday September 15, 2023 @02:10PM (#37527007)
Many, and in America I'd dare say most, people just don't really like doing outdoor things. It's some of the cheapest entertainment you can have, as many parks and locations are completely free. You don't need to full on belaying to have a great time. All you really need is a tank of gas, a bus ticket, or a bike. There are just dramatic cultural differences that drive people in different directions.

Programs like ROTC/JROTC also offer countless outdoor opportunities alongside other possibilities for personal enrichment. I'm vehemently antiwar/hegemony, but I think training offered by ROTC/JROTC is extremely valuable for anybody and everybody. It's also completely free.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by stainablesteel on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:07AM (#37510037)
this is speaking from the perspective as if that's all that happens, which its most definitely not

i can show you plenty of anti-white racism in the crime statistics, especially from people who are ungrateful to be allowed into the greatest countries where they're given better opportunities than 99% of the world population, isn't that crazy?

and all you talk about is exclusion

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by selimthegrim on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:30AM (#37510314)
The whole ungrateful immigrant thing is really long in the tooth, man. Are their children supposed to be “grateful” too or can they be just as dissatisfied with their lives as the “indigenes”?
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by mrits on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:11AM (#37510078)
You sound like someone that either hasn't traveled the world or doesn't know what the word phenomenon means.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by gnrlst on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:41AM (#37508910)
Same. I'm sure there ARE some mediocre men there, but turning this into a "women good men bad post" really ruined it for me.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by BurningPenguin on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:50AM (#37509024)
Did you guys actually read that article, or only the pretty colorful boxes? Because the text right before that fancy box explains why that phrase came into existence.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by vGPU on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:57AM (#37509128)
> dealing with misogynistic comments and just overall disappointing behavior from quite a few less than stellar men was a regular occurrence at work for me and my female coworkers.

Subjective judgements on behavior, from someone who complains that there are too many white scientists.

Pardon me if I take their judgement with a grain of salt.

The entire article is incredibly poorly written, to boot. I was expecting to see a credit card advertisement any second. “Use my referral code and you too can fly to Antarctica for free!”. Actually - the majority of points/credit card referral sites have higher quality writing.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by EatingWithForks on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:13AM (#37509370)
I mean, let's view this charitably. It makes total sense for a woman, who feels like she received misogynistic comments from men at her workplace, to have a poor opinion of the men there. I also don't know if it's really good faith to dismiss a woman saying something was misogynistic as subjective. Of course being a bigot is kind of subjective-- the bigot just thinks their prejudice is normal/true. I wouldn't trust any of the male scientists to say "no of course misogynistic comments didn't happen"; they're guys and, speaking as a guy, it's a blindspot for most men when they make women uncomfortable.

I also charitably don't think there's anything wrong with being suspicious of a very obvious lacking in racial diversity. Globally, white people are a minority of people, and they're likely not the overwhelming majority of all scientists even. So it would obviously be a statistical anomaly if only white people were on a specific research trip.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by gottorf on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:27AM (#37509502)
> Globally, white people are a minority of people, and they're likely not the overwhelming majority of all scientists even. So it would obviously be a statistical anomaly if only white people were on a specific research trip.

This was a trip to McMurdo Station, which is operated by the US, which is majority white as of the 2020 census (58.9% "white alone, not Hispanic or Latino"). In 1956, when McMurdo was established, the US was nearly 90% white. If anything, it would be a statistical anomaly if there were too few white people, considering that the science community is whiter than the country as a whole.

The GP's point stands, still: though the OP's article doesn't explicitly say that the lack of racial diversity in McMurdo is a problem, it's implied. Why is it a problem? I don't think anyone at McMurdo is complaining about minorities coming in.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by EatingWithForks on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:39AM (#37509637)
Oh okay, I thought this was a station that was hiring internationally or something like that.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by shrimp_emoji on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:48AM (#37509745)
Not only that, but racism/sexism is too good to let go. People will always find another casus belli. White people still have most of the world's wealth, so, even when whites are the minority, they still deserve to be subalterned. And hey, they did that to other races for most of history, so it's all fair!

The only winning move is not to play these shitty games.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by BurningPenguin on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:16AM (#37509408)
I guess you and i have a very different understanding of the word "complaint". Because i don't see any.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by paint on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:59AM (#37509926)
She's not wrong. There are too many white scientists (statistically) and STEM graduates.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by gottorf on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:32AM (#37510335)
One of the greatest fallacies of the modern identitarian movement is that every subsection of society, no matter how you slice and dice it, must reflect the composition of the society as a whole. There's no reason why this should be the case, because different cultural subgroups value and prefer different things.

"Too many white scientists" carries exactly the same amount of meaning as "too many black NFL players" (over half are black, compared to 13.6% of the population) or "too many male roofers" (95% are male) or "too many female special ed teachers" (84.2% are female); that is to say, it carries no meaning at all.

Once you free yourself from the plausible-sounding but false idea that the composition of subgroups must necessarily reflect the composition of the whole, a lot of today's racial divides and those who fan those flames are evident for what they are: those with agendas that benefit from pitting people against one another.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by paint on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:06PM (#37510776)
A lot of fancy words to show that you didn't understand my point. You are saying: "women just don't want to become scientists". You don't think to challenge the society and culture because you're not discriminated against by it.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by gottorf on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:40PM (#37511288)
> You are saying: "women just don't want to become scientists".

In the aggregate, this is true.

Your theory is that it's only true because of discrimination against women in science, and absent that discrimination, scientists would be more or less 50% women and 50% men.

My counter-theory is that because women and men value and prefer different things in the aggregate, there's no reason to believe that even absent discrimination, there would be an equal distribution; and that to attempt to force an equal distribution necessarily means privileging some and disadvantaging others.

> You don't think to challenge the society and culture because you're not discriminated against by it.

Sometimes, people really just make decisions on their own without discrimination being a factor. Heck, people of different races in this country prefer different makes of sedans[0]. Are you going to tell me that Ford dealers discriminate more against black people than Chevy dealers, and that's why a greater share of black people buy Chevys than Fords?

Around where I live, even among modifications to pickup trucks, there's a clear divide. Virtually everyone who drives a lowered pickup is Hispanic. Virtually everyone who drives one with big wheels and very low-profile tires is black. Virtually everyone who drives one with a big lift and wide, knobby tires is white. Why is that the case? Does discrimination explain why the percentage of people who drive lowered pickups is overwhelmingly more likely to be Hispanic than the demographic of the area would suggest?

[0]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/825131/united-states-bra...

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by paint on Thursday September 14, 2023 @03:46PM (#37513892)
I read your entire comment in good faith and I'm now convinced you have a mental disability. Are you high or retarded or something? Also, the "Identitarian movement" is a ultra-right nationalist ideology most prominent in Austria and Germany (you were thinking of "identity politics")

> Your theory is that it's only true because of discrimination against women in science

That's not my "theory". Discrimination of course plays a huge role in it, but also how we're raised (a simple example for someone as mind-numbingly stupid as you: the kinds of toys parents give their children), the fact that women are more likely to have to engage in unpaid care work their men won't do, but also many other factors in society you're too ignorant to see. If you're actually this stupid I think you should do everyone a favour and just kill yourself.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by dang on Thursday September 14, 2023 @05:59PM (#37515394)
> I'm now convinced you have a mental disability. Are you high or retarded

We've banned this account for egregiously breaking the site guidelines. You can't post like this here, regardless of how wrong someone or how right you are, or you feel they are, or you feel you are.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by dang on Thursday September 14, 2023 @06:01PM (#37515417)
Please don't perpetuate flamewars on HN. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by invalidOrTaken on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:27PM (#37511079)
There are not nearly enough white, black, East Asian, Latin, or Native American scientists and STEM graduates.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by paint on Thursday September 14, 2023 @03:46PM (#37513897)
Exactly man, we have to change that. Thanks for pointing it out.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by omscs99 on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:45AM (#37509694)
If the genders were reversed it would be binned as sexist without any support or regard for context

Why exactly should the expectation of justification go one way but not the other?

Frankly, I’ll take the same standard and apply it the other way. The author is sexist, the article is hot garbage

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by kajecounterhack on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:02AM (#37509967)
Language is contextual. A woman who has seen repeated instances of male misbehavior is within her rights to record her feelings about it — “the men here are mediocre” in this context is clearly not talking about all men but her feelings about the shitty men she encountered, and also pointing at a pattern of what happens when there are a large number of white males vs more diverse settings (this isn’t unique to Antarctica — Google has this problem). Mistreatment of women in such settings is well documented.

It’s like if you say “my job sucks” — not all parts of your job may actually suck, just the parts you hate. Or “the government is corrupt” most folks would infer that you are talking about a specific subelement.

If we lived in a society where women routinely mistreated men then flipping the statement wouldn’t be offensive. What makes it offensive flipped is mostly that generalizations about women typically encode harmful falsehoods that come from generations of patriarchy. You could not flip her statements in good faith because women do not treat men the way she described anyway.

As a progressive I hate that it isn’t simple as much as everyone else. But to fight for equality is to understand that the origins of the fight come from unwanted asymmetry and of course that’s going to be reflected in discourse.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by omscs99 on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:47AM (#37510543)
> because women do not treat men the way she described anyway.

How would you know?

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by vkou on Friday September 15, 2023 @03:29AM (#37519712)
What evidence would you accept?
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by Supermancho on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:43AM (#37510486)
> Why exactly should the expectation of justification go one way but not the other?

The existing conditions in Antarctica.

The idea that sexism is an absolute abhorrent behavior (with a focus on either or both genders) is not something to promote, despite the fervor in recent years. The sexes have a different representation in the arctic and pointing them out is akin to pointing out that a lot of left handers apply to NASA. I wouldn't call something garbage because I'm offended someone held up a patch that says "Only left handers are in their right mind".

Getting upset at this writer/article/situation is not constructive. Nor is the condemnation a fair editorial critique, imo.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by paint on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:50AM (#37510574)
> If the genders were reversed it would be binned as sexist without any support or regard for context

This is what happened in the comments?

She gave context in the post. Did you read it?

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by seanw444 on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:47AM (#37508987)
Can't even read about Antarctica without an agenda. Ugh.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by vkou on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:51AM (#37510582)
I'm very sympathetic to your discomfort as a reader, but it seems odd to air it in a subthread that discusses how ~50% of the population can't even be in Antarctica as a worker without experiencing a lot of discomfort.
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by mrits on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:19AM (#37509449)
A phrase that would come out of the mouth of a mediocre woman
[dead]
Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by dang on Friday September 15, 2023 @01:40AM (#37518910)
"Don't feed egregious comments by replying; flag them instead."

a.k.a. please don't feed the trolls

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by otikik on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:02AM (#37509959)
I found it interesting. My expectation was that in a tight, isolated community of mostly scientist and associated personnel, people would know better. Apparently not.

If you have to get mad about something, be mad about the guys who decided to behave like assholes. Part of the problem is that when that happens the rest of us don't do anything about it.

Re:How I Got Paid to Live in Antarctica by petemir on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:11AM (#37510076)
At least in bases from other countries (i.e., speaking from personal experience), a majority of the personnel, at least during the winter, would come from the military. In those specific countries too, at least, military personnel did not correlate with (well)educated people, so sexism was also common.