News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by itsoktocry on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:37AM (#37508105)
>The best engineers are worth literally 10x the worst engineers

Uh, I'm pretty sure the best employees in any field are worth 10x what the worst employees are, whether you're writing code, assembling a car or gutting fish.

The economics of labour suggest unions are most valuable where there's a monopsony buyer of labour. Big Tech might fit that bill, especially when we know they colluded to depress salaries.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by flerchin on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:38AM (#37508119)
The best airline pilot lands the plane the same as the worst.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by digitalsushi on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:40AM (#37508135)
99.999% of the time I agree with you.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by tartuffe78 on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:40AM (#37508134)
With a few notable outliers...
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by rmbyrro on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:42AM (#37508173)
Sure, just the integrity of the plane after landing vary sometimes.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by lnxg33k1 on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:42AM (#37508176)
Yeah the best developer uses the same compiler of the worst, guess the difference is not what you do at the end, but how you manage the trip, and how you write code before
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by itsoktocry on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:43AM (#37508180)
>The best airline pilot lands the plane the same as the worst

Have you considered there's more to being a pilot than landing the plane?

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by flerchin on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:04AM (#37509232)
Plenty more, but the economic impact to the airline is the same from any individual pilot.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by chii on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:47AM (#37508243)
Not really. The worst pilot only lands once, and never again.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by Ekaros on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:55AM (#37508329)
Now what qualifies as landing?
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by II2II on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:31AM (#37508789)
Collect a large number of pilots, divide them into two pools based upon their performance (low and high). Which pool do you think will incur more expenses to the airline? Keep in mind that some of those costs range from reducing consumer confidence (poor landings or damaged cargo), to planes requiring more maintenance (increased costs of maintenance, planes taken out of service more often), to planes being put out of commission (regardless of whether everyone walks away or not).

A lot of people seem to be measuring value in landings per day, widgets per minute, lines of code per week without acknowledging that the quality of work does have an impact.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by flerchin on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:05AM (#37509245)
There's only acceptable piloting and not. There's no pilot that makes the airline 10x more per flight.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by wil421 on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:48AM (#37508248)
The best airline pilots get the best routes for the best airlines and are mostly retired military. At the other end you have cargo pilots and regional flights that carry a brand of major airline but are operated by a different company.

Look at salary differences.

https://www.thepilotguys.com/blog/airline-pilot-salary

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by AptExtrapolatio on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:13AM (#37508555)
>The best airline pilots get the best routes for the best airlines and are mostly retired military.

Curious about this. I'd have thought going the civilian route of flight school should put one on equal footing on this regard? Or are you saying that just statistically more long-tenured pilots are retired military?

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by flerchin on Thursday September 14, 2023 @10:03AM (#37509217)
In general, these are due to union rules. The union decides what the compensation is, and it's largely by seniority. The airline makes no more money from retired military pilots than they do from any other pilot.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by frant-hartm on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:44AM (#37508197)
If you are on an assembly line and you have 45 s to do your job you either do it, or don't. If you do it fast and wait for 40 s you don't add any value.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by itsoktocry on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:46AM (#37508221)
>If you are on an assembly line and you have 45 s to do your job you either do it, or don't. If you do it fast and wait for 40 s you don't add any value.

Have you worked on an assembly line? I have.

You may not add value by doing it faster, but you certainly cause problems if you do it slower.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by mycologos on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:57AM (#37508350)
I think the distinction is the relationship between the median performer and the 90th percentile performer. The two are very different employees for software development but not on an assembly line. As you point out, there is a difference between the median performer and the 10th percentile performer on an assembly line, but that's not the comparison the parent comment introduced.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by itsoktocry on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:01AM (#37508409)
>As you point out, there is a difference between the median performer

But I didn't say that, and I don't agree.

I think the 90th percentile never causes delays on a particular station, while the median may cause a few per hour, and the 10th percentile might delay every 2nd or 3rd cycle.

There are tangible costs associated with those levels of performance.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by nonethewiser on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:32AM (#37508806)
This is a completely different argument though and irrelevant to the comment chain you replied to. Everyone involved may even agree with you - why did you frame it as an argument against the claim that there is less capacity for 10x performers?
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by bluGill on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:15AM (#37508582)
Generally you design your cycle times so that the median performer never is late. Remember if each median performer has 1 delay per hour, on a line with 100 workers that mean each cycle there is a delay somewhere and so the line always moves slower than expected. How much slack to add is a complex question, but you have to assume there will be delays. The 10th percentile cannot be allowed to delay the line, so you have to deal with it (training, fire them, give them faster tools, or switch to a station they can do in time come to mind, there may be more)
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by bigtechennui on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:56AM (#37508348)
So there’s a cap on the maximum value (always doing it on time), and a cap on the minimum value (never doing it).

The above poster takes the position that the ratio between the maximum value, and minimum employable value is less than 10.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by nonethewiser on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:30AM (#37508784)
> You may not add value by doing it faster, but you certainly cause problems if you do it slower.

This makes his point though. There is no capacity to be 10x more productive.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by adrianovaroli on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:50PM (#37517233)
With all due respect, why are you both talking about yourselves as if you were machines? If your job is so mechanical it can be automated, you're screwed. If it's not, but your boss wants to downsize it bc "savings", a union would help you.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by bluGill on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:06AM (#37508475)
That depends on the assembly line. The assembly the car line works like that: you get 45 seconds (or whatever time) to put your part one, then the car moves to the next station.

However I know of assembly lines where things spend several hours at each station. The people (often as many as 10 people per station) all work together for that time putting different parts on. If you can do the job faster than the time in station you can take an extra break to do what you want. Such lines are generally planned so that if you work as expected you get a 20 minute break when the lines move, most teams work faster and get a 30 minute break, almost never does some team get less than the 20 minute break planned.

The car model assembly line is the most efficient, but it has high costs. When you make a lot of something it is well worth those costs, but if you are only expecting to sell 100 "things" per year it isn't worth setting up the line.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by pydry on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:47AM (#37508237)
Unions add the same kind of value whether you're writing a Hollywood screenplay or assembling a Tesla because you have the same relationship to capital either way.

The same divide/conquer tactic was done 100 years ago when owners of mines in Pennsylvania pitted white and black miners against each other.

The actual distinction doesn't matter to the owners provided it divides labor. Anything that makes you feel special and separates you from people in the same boat as you is fair game - whether that's the intellectual needs of your job or just plain old racism.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by SpicyLemonZest on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:03AM (#37508434)
Do I have the same relationship to capital? A miner’s relationship to capital seems pretty plausibly adversarial to me: capital buys a bunch of tools and shafts and scaffolding, asks miners to use them to pull coal out of the ground, then pays the miners a fraction of what the coal sells for. My relationship with capital is that rich investors send money to my company’s bank account and they forward it directly to my bank account.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by randy5235 on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:13AM (#37508553)
Rich investors send money to your companies bank account. Upper management then pays as little as they can get away with. You might have “shares” in your company that gain value in an “exit” event, but have you looked at how those payout structures are arranged? Mostly the investors and “founders” are paid out first with great returns. What little is left gets divided up amongst the rest.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by bluGill on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:16AM (#37508593)
There is value in an investor paying for the shafts and scaffolding. The investor also takes the risk that coal prices will fall (eventually the miner is laid off, but the investor takes a lot of the risk)
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by pydry on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:56AM (#37509093)
Mines also had investors and they also paid wage bills before the company was profitable. Did you think that they did not?
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by pydry on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:45AM (#37508210)
This idea crops up so frequently that Ive started calling it the "Apparently Tom Cruise Works in a Factory" fallacy.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by runako on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:54AM (#37508322)
Is Tom Cruise represented by a union?
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by germinalphrase on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:34AM (#37508830)
The film industry is highly unionized. At some point in his career, he absolutely was - possibly multiple.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by onion2k on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:04AM (#37508443)
Yes. He's a member of the Screen Actors Guild. He stopped shooting MI:8 in solidarity with the union.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by TimPC on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:50AM (#37508273)
I'm pretty sure there are plenty of fields where the output of your best and worst employees don't differ dramatically. Worst is generally some passable minimum not someone who refuses to do the job entirely. For plenty of assembly line jobs, your worst employee has similar productivity to your best employee because there is no ability to make the assembly line faster for the more productive person.

In code on the other hand, your best employee can straight up do things your worst employee can't. The differences are much larger. There is a reason people hire Principal Software Engineers, but most IC roles in other fields don't have the same range of seniorities.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by eaton on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:28PM (#37511084)
I've been doing software professionally for about thirty years now, and what's interesting to me is that the conversations I had with my grandfather about factory work involved all of the same dynamics. Prototyping new solutions versus consistent reproduction of known solutions? People who only understand their own tasks versus those who have a holistic understanding of the components, the process, and the final product? Troubleshooting unexpected failure states in complex systems and fixing mission-critical problems that can make or break the business, versus checking out when The System Breaks? Conflicts between book-smart college grads and grizzled vets who know how things "really work" under the hood?

Those are the stories he told me about working in a factory, and frankly the lessons I learned from him were just as valuable as any "fifteen lessons for software architects" books our industry has produced. Sure — software is unique! So is food, so is metal, so is film, so is concrete…

People don't deserve unions because they're 10x workers. People deserve unions because they're workers.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by TimPC on Thursday September 14, 2023 @02:47PM (#37513077)
I think a working model of a technology union would have to work closely to professional sports unions or acting unions that support wide disparities in pay. I think historical tech opposition to unions is people not wanting the idea of a standardized wage and extremely high job security (which acts as a downward force on wages). Many people look for something like the Netflix model where you're expected to move on if you're not producing lots of value, but you get compensated more for it. The thing about having 10x engineers being possible is that everyone thinks they are above 1x and deserve above average pay.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by nordsieck on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:52AM (#37508296)
> Uh, I'm pretty sure the best employees in any field are worth 10x what the worst employees are, whether you're writing code, assembling a car or gutting fish.

I've worked at FedEx as a package handler before. That is absolutely not the case there. The absolutely best employees might be 3x more productive than someone who's mediocre with 2 weeks of experience. When the job is picking up boxes off of a conveyor belt and putting them in trucks, your walking speed is one of the key limiters. And no one can walk 10x faster than someone else. Not for a 6-8 hr shift.

Some jobs - especially jobs that involve heavy manual labor - just don't have a wide range between the most and least productive employees.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by itsoktocry on Thursday September 14, 2023 @08:57AM (#37508358)
>Some jobs - especially jobs that involve heavy manual labor - just don't have a wide range between the most and least productive employees.

Obviously we're all just throwing around numbers to make a point, this isn't hard data.

But I assure you there are zero jobs where there is no difference between the best and worst employees. Zero.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by Kye on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:25AM (#37510250)
3x seems like a lot in a business that lives or dies on thin margins.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by dartos on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:16AM (#37508591)
Specifically in the software development field, a good engineer increases the productivity of all other engineers in a way that allows engineers to increase the productivity of each other in a compounding way.

A “10x” engineer is worth a compounding amount more than their peers.

I don’t think that holds for every field.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by adrianovaroli on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:53PM (#37517256)
Jorge Luis Borges colleagues at the National Library forced him to go slower because he could catalogue books in a fraction of the time they needed.

So yeah, if you're an absolute genius, you don't need a union. Everybody else does. Your common people colleagues do.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by dartos on Sunday September 17, 2023 @10:41AM (#37545514)
Yeah, that’s the trade off with many collectivist ideas.

They optimize for equality, which necessarily hurts the highest performers (in one way or another) and benefits the lower ones (in many ways)

Like anything, it’s a trade off

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by jhgfjhgfjhfgjhg on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:22AM (#37508673)
You would depress the wages of 10x engineers with unions. Look at teacher unions for an example.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by atmavatar on Friday September 15, 2023 @01:43AM (#37518940)
Actors and athletes don't seem to have that problem despite having unions.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by nonethewiser on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:25AM (#37508714)
> Uh, I'm pretty sure the best employees in any field are worth 10x what the worst employees are, whether you're writing code, assembling a car or gutting fish.

Or presumably anything else (because you said "any field"). But why?

It seems like the less skill or expertise something takes the less ability there is to deviate from the average. In which case unions, if most useful for low-skilled labor like OP described, are most useful for industries that tend to outsource their labor to other countries. And thus reduces the need for unions. Seems consistent with the decline of unions in the US.

Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by shortrounddev2 on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:28AM (#37508758)
Jobs aren't all technical skills. You can be the best coder in the world but if you're a colossal asshole you're not going to get put in charge of other people. If you show up to work drunk or high, you're definitely not going to advance.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by nonethewiser on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:33AM (#37508825)
Never said it was. We're talking about productivity. Being such an asshole that your performance is crippled is baked into that.
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by shortrounddev2 on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:30AM (#37508778)
Big tech might, but unlike steelworking or auto manufacturing, the barrier for entry for tech is very low, and so big tech aren't the only employers out there. They're not even the only employers paying high wages (you can get good salaries at startups as well)
Re:Tech Workers Deserve a Union: An Interview with Ethan Mar... by neotrope on Thursday September 14, 2023 @11:39AM (#37510441)
> Uh, I'm pretty sure the best employees in any field are worth 10x what the worst employees are, whether you're writing code, assembling a car or gutting fish.

This is a big misconception. The difference is whether 10x talent is more valuable than 1x talent. You could be the worlds best fish gutter, but if you can't gut 10x more fish than the next guy, then your salary is capped and you're wasting your talent. In software, you can be 10x more productive than the next guy.