Have you considered there's more to being a pilot than landing the plane?
A lot of people seem to be measuring value in landings per day, widgets per minute, lines of code per week without acknowledging that the quality of work does have an impact.
Look at salary differences.
Curious about this. I'd have thought going the civilian route of flight school should put one on equal footing on this regard? Or are you saying that just statistically more long-tenured pilots are retired military?
Have you worked on an assembly line? I have.
You may not add value by doing it faster, but you certainly cause problems if you do it slower.
But I didn't say that, and I don't agree.
I think the 90th percentile never causes delays on a particular station, while the median may cause a few per hour, and the 10th percentile might delay every 2nd or 3rd cycle.
There are tangible costs associated with those levels of performance.
The above poster takes the position that the ratio between the maximum value, and minimum employable value is less than 10.
This makes his point though. There is no capacity to be 10x more productive.
However I know of assembly lines where things spend several hours at each station. The people (often as many as 10 people per station) all work together for that time putting different parts on. If you can do the job faster than the time in station you can take an extra break to do what you want. Such lines are generally planned so that if you work as expected you get a 20 minute break when the lines move, most teams work faster and get a 30 minute break, almost never does some team get less than the 20 minute break planned.
The car model assembly line is the most efficient, but it has high costs. When you make a lot of something it is well worth those costs, but if you are only expecting to sell 100 "things" per year it isn't worth setting up the line.
The same divide/conquer tactic was done 100 years ago when owners of mines in Pennsylvania pitted white and black miners against each other.
The actual distinction doesn't matter to the owners provided it divides labor. Anything that makes you feel special and separates you from people in the same boat as you is fair game - whether that's the intellectual needs of your job or just plain old racism.
In code on the other hand, your best employee can straight up do things your worst employee can't. The differences are much larger. There is a reason people hire Principal Software Engineers, but most IC roles in other fields don't have the same range of seniorities.
Those are the stories he told me about working in a factory, and frankly the lessons I learned from him were just as valuable as any "fifteen lessons for software architects" books our industry has produced. Sure — software is unique! So is food, so is metal, so is film, so is concrete…
People don't deserve unions because they're 10x workers. People deserve unions because they're workers.
I've worked at FedEx as a package handler before. That is absolutely not the case there. The absolutely best employees might be 3x more productive than someone who's mediocre with 2 weeks of experience. When the job is picking up boxes off of a conveyor belt and putting them in trucks, your walking speed is one of the key limiters. And no one can walk 10x faster than someone else. Not for a 6-8 hr shift.
Some jobs - especially jobs that involve heavy manual labor - just don't have a wide range between the most and least productive employees.
Obviously we're all just throwing around numbers to make a point, this isn't hard data.
But I assure you there are zero jobs where there is no difference between the best and worst employees. Zero.
A “10x” engineer is worth a compounding amount more than their peers.
I don’t think that holds for every field.
So yeah, if you're an absolute genius, you don't need a union. Everybody else does. Your common people colleagues do.
They optimize for equality, which necessarily hurts the highest performers (in one way or another) and benefits the lower ones (in many ways)
Like anything, it’s a trade off
Or presumably anything else (because you said "any field"). But why?
It seems like the less skill or expertise something takes the less ability there is to deviate from the average. In which case unions, if most useful for low-skilled labor like OP described, are most useful for industries that tend to outsource their labor to other countries. And thus reduces the need for unions. Seems consistent with the decline of unions in the US.
This is a big misconception. The difference is whether 10x talent is more valuable than 1x talent. You could be the worlds best fish gutter, but if you can't gut 10x more fish than the next guy, then your salary is capped and you're wasting your talent. In software, you can be 10x more productive than the next guy.
Uh, I'm pretty sure the best employees in any field are worth 10x what the worst employees are, whether you're writing code, assembling a car or gutting fish.
The economics of labour suggest unions are most valuable where there's a monopsony buyer of labour. Big Tech might fit that bill, especially when we know they colluded to depress salaries.