News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by commandlinefan on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @05:19PM (#37501866)
> why this triggers such skepticism

I know it does for me - because the people who claim to believe in it the most don't actually live their lives as if they actually believed it. Don't get me wrong, I'd be happy to do whatever I could reasonably do to create cooler summers and less smog, but I've never heard any actual concrete proposal beyond "vote democrat".

Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by pixl97 on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @05:50PM (#37502206)
In general because the tragedy of the commons is solved by one group pointing a gun at everyone else. Nobody wants that, but at the end of the day that's what we're going to get if we like it or not.

The longer we wait, the more people are going to get shot by that gun.

Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by bottled_poe on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @07:47PM (#37503136)
Curious!
Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by vlz on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:33PM (#37503441)
Ok, I will bite. Concrete proposals for anybody regardless of political view:

* Eat half the meat you do or less

* Don‘t fly unless absolutely necessary

* Get on a plan for renewable electrical energy if possible

I know, far from everything in this topic is about consumer choices but a lot really is. If you don‘t want the nanny state to fix your problems you can start at your own doorstep.

Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by twobitshifter on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @08:50PM (#37503552)
The flying thing is weird. It’s really that you emit a lot because you traveled so far. It’s more efficient that driving per mile and slightly less efficient than rail (not sure the type)

https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2015/09/evolving-climate-...

So it should be don’t travel so far and if you have to, take a train and if there’s no train, carpool, but fly rather than drive if you are traveling alone.

Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by amrocha on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @09:15PM (#37503720)
Most people aren't driving across the country every time they need to go from the east coast to the west coast. If planes didn't exist these trips would also not exist.
Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by twobitshifter on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:11AM (#37508527)
Right, our quest for ever faster travel has led to consuming huge amounts of energy. Even something like the interstates has contributed to this by shrinking travel times to downtown and encouraging people to travel greater distances at higher speed.
Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by vlz on Thursday September 14, 2023 @01:24AM (#37505284)
Thank you for the linked article! Yes that is an apt and necessary correction.
Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by clnq on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @09:13PM (#37503709)
Another thing to bring up is how much we can change. I don't eat meat, I always travel by train if I can, for convenience if not anything else, my energy provider offers a renewable plan and I pay the premium for it. I also cycle instead of using a car, give away most things at the end of their usefulness cycle for reuse - I don't trade them in for recycling, I actually list them and deal with people who want to pick them up for free. I don't support companies that are known for anti-climate ethics. I only use rechargeable batteries, only LED lighting, only this and that....

And really, for all this effort, I don't think my children are getting a good deal. They'll still probably live in shit climate and deal with all sorts of crises that entails.

It doesn't even feel close to realistic for us to expect that our individual actions against climate change will have a significant impact on how we or our kids will live. Unless there is significant political change, which I don't honestly believe we'll see. And if we would see, I don't think people would like it. I think any politician who tries to restrict our freedoms enough to make a dent on the climate crisis has a short shelf-life. But significant political action on climate could at least still change things.

The best thing I can do for my children myself is move up North - no amount of bike trips over a car trip will help them in any meaningful capacity in this reality. We can imagine a utopian society where everyone bands together and does all these things to fight climate change and more (more on this in the next paragraph), and we can say that theoretically it's possible to fight climate change without politics. But, come on, let's be real.

About half of all emissions come from the 10% wealthiest individuals [0]. The other 90% of us, if we somehow all ceased to exist in 2030, would still only directly make earth meet the emission reduction target to avoid a global catastrophe [1]. This is how much the rich pollute.

Rather than ceasing to exist, we should vote to pass laws to reduce the emissions of the very rich to a point where it's somewhere in the region of a normal person's footprint. And how can you do this without serious laws? Have you ever tried talking to a CEO of a large company or anyone from serious money? Good luck getting them on a train for the sake of the planet alone. Maybe they'd do it here and there for the optics, but to really stop opulence emissions, we need laws.

Regardless, here's the real doom and gloom - if we can't even organize ourselves to vote every 4-5 years on climate action, what chance to we stand to minimize our emission footprint to almost zero? Remember, everyone of the bottom 90% of earners in most countries would need to do this. To the extreme extent of almost zero. No exceptions.

The rich and their companies won't do it, the normals can't organize well enough and the organization would need to be so extreme that it's a fantasy anyways. No. Regulation is much more realistic. Specifically, cutting down on certain industry emissions and opulence emissions. As unlikely as such harsh regulation is, at least it stands a chance.

[0] https://wedocs.unep.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.11822/34438/..., p15

[1] https://www.unep.org/resources/emissions-gap-report-2022

Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by labster on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @09:19PM (#37503751)
It’s expensive to eat less meat. And I done mean in an abstract way about the time it takes to prepare meals, etc.

On a per weight basis, chicken is half the price of peanut butter or cheese at the local grocery store. A whole cooked chicken is even cheaper at Costco. Not everyone can afford to eat less meat and replace it with plant protein.

Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by midoridensha on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:39AM (#37505038)
Fair, but you can probably help save both money and the environment by cutting back on beef, and replacing it with chicken. Chicken is FAR more resource-efficient than beef. It's too bad they haven't figured out how to make it taste similar (of course, chicken doesn't taste bad, it's just really different, just like vanilla and chocolate ice cream taste different but one is not better than the other except in terms of personal preference).
Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by vlz on Thursday September 14, 2023 @02:23AM (#37505616)
True, but I would like to add:

1. If you can afford it, you should still reduce.

2. The meat and dairy industries are heavily subsidized especially in developed countries. These prices are artificially low.[1]

The subsidies could of course be shifted to human edible plants (instead of feeding corn/maize) making plant-based diets more affordable.

At the moment however few politician want to be connected to rising meat prices. If they were to get clear signals from their voters for shifting preferences of course that could also change.

[1]: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/sep/14/global-f...

Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by elevaet on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:20PM (#37510965)
Chicken is a really green choice for getting your protein:

- Chicken produces around 1/6 the CO2 of beef, and less than cheese.

- Chicken uses around 1/10 the water than beef does.

- Beef produces lots of methane and chicken doesn't.

Chicken consumption isn't really a problem. When we say "reduce meat consumption" we should be saying reduce beef consumption.

Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by lazide on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:30AM (#37504990)
Considering that will just result in a lower quality of life for me, and everyone else not even noticing (and not moving the needle even a little globally) - why?

It’s like self flagellation in private. Maybe soul cleansing religiously or something, but utterly pointless in the real world.

Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by midoridensha on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:40AM (#37505047)
You completely left out the enormous impact that cars have. How about get rid of your car, move someplace walkable if you have to, and stop driving?
Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by vlz on Thursday September 14, 2023 @01:56AM (#37505476)
You are right, that would certainly be a very big contribution and could have been listed as well. Relocating however is a very big step. While I actually don’t own a car myself and seldom needed one, I am hesitant to prescribe that to others as I know the situation outside the bigger cities gets unpleasant very fast when you are not mobile and relocating is a drastic step not available to everyone.

In the area of personal mobility, change away from cars could only result from collective action, e.g. drastic improvements to public transport and less from personal choice. (EVs however or hybrids are also a real option for many.)

Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by dr_dshiv on Thursday September 14, 2023 @02:40AM (#37505723)
Yeah, but not having children blows these out of the water. I mean, its not even on the same chart.
Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by deprecative on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @09:03PM (#37503631)
One of the reasons for this is because you're not actually responsible for all that much as a middle class and below person. Yeah, get better fuel efficient cars. Yeah, eat less meat. Yeah, get the most out of what you can when you buy things. But that's not going to do much while corporations are still chugging along. It won't do much while coal and gas are the primary energy production. Sure, use less electricity and get onto renewables as much as you can but the offenders will buy these nonsensical carbon credits and such that cause issue.

The real answer is definitely vote Democratic, one cannot vote democrat as that's not a party in the US. But more than that it gets involved in the political process such that change to our policies are done with climate change in kind. You won't get that from Republicans.

Re:Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries by yongjik on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:42AM (#37505063)
> I've never heard any actual concrete proposal beyond "vote democrat".

Trump called the global warming a "Chinese hoax." If you're looking for leverages to influence the global climate as a US citizen, "vote democrat" is not a bad strategy. (Have to add: it's not because democrats are awesome, but because the alternative is horrible.)