News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by charlieok on Saturday March 24, 2012 @12:23PM (#3749744)
“I told you, didn’t I, about hearing Noam Chomsky speak recently? When the great man was asked about the chaos in public education, he responded quickly, decisively, and to the point: “Public education in this country is under attack.” The words, though chilling, comforted me in a weird way. I’d been feeling, the past few years of my 30-plus-year tenure in public education, that there was something or somebody out there, a power of a sort, that doesn’t really want you kids to be educated. I felt a force that wants you ignorant and pliable, and that needs you able to fill in the boxes and follow instructions. Now I’m sure.”

This speaks to a rather odd state of mind on the part of the teacher. “The great man”?

Believing that the state of education and testing is the result of some powerful villain behind the curtain requires more credulity than simply attributing it to the massive complexity and inertia you describe.

Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by nessus42 on Saturday March 24, 2012 @11:48PM (#3751650)
This speaks to a rather odd state of mind on the part of the teacher. “The great man”?

Believing that the state of education and testing is the result of some powerful villain behind the curtain requires more credulity than simply attributing it to the massive complexity and inertia you describe.

Certainly Chomsky is a great man. He's the founder of modern linguistics. He wrote the paper that demolished behavioral psychology, paving the way for cognitive psychology. He invented the hierarchy of formal languages that is still taught in every Computer Science program in the world. He is the most cited academic in the world. He is the most influential thinker in two completely unrelated fields: linguistics and political activism. He's an "Institute Professor" at MIT, which is the highest honor that MIT bestows. (I think that there are fewer of them at MIT than there are Nobel Laureates.)

Just what is there not to consider great?

As to "some powerful villain", where did either Chomsky or the OP ever assert that the "villain" isn't a system? Perhaps a system comprised largely of complexity and inertia?

I know for a fact that Chomsky believes something along these lines. He's stated many times that the harmful influences that he describes are not the result of a cabal, as he is often misattributed as asserting, but that he is and always has been speaking about the effects of a complex system, whose intent is not the intent of any individual part of the system.

Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by charlieok on Sunday March 25, 2012 @01:51PM (#3753224)
You make the case much more convincingly than the OP. The passage I quoted came across to me as uncritical fawning.
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by jovrtn on Sunday March 25, 2012 @05:39PM (#3753924)
As opposed to your uncritical lack of appreciation?
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by charlieok on Sunday March 25, 2012 @06:17PM (#3754028)
Not really sure what you mean, but don't want to fight about it.
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by jovrtn on Monday March 26, 2012 @01:02AM (#3755092)
Questioning whether Chomsky was worth the teacher's praise demonstrated that you held the uncritical viewpoint, not her.
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by charlieok on Monday March 26, 2012 @11:58AM (#3757248)
It was never about Chomsky or whether he's "worth the teacher's praise".

I don't care how great somebody is. It still comes off badly to refer to them as "the great man" and appeal to their authority if you want to persuade your reader of something.

Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by nessus42 on Monday March 26, 2012 @04:13PM (#3758431)
I disagree. Replace Chomsky with Lincoln or Jefferson or Newton or Einstein. Would you object then? "Great" doesn't imply correctness. It implies only profound respect for one's achievements.

Furthermore, the OP did not appeal to authority. She cited a claim from a reputable source, and asserted that this claimed seemed to be evident in her own experience. She never asserted that the claim was true merely because Chomsky said so. Your criticism is no more valid than it would be for the case where she might document evidence from her personal life for one of Newton's theories.

Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by astrofinch on Saturday March 24, 2012 @04:31PM (#3750616)
"Never ascribe to malice that which is adequately explained by incompetence."
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by Iv on Sunday March 25, 2012 @12:47AM (#3751755)
I read that quote too often. Greed exists and often masquerades as incompetence. Do not be always that adamant.
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by emmelaich on Saturday March 24, 2012 @02:25PM (#3750163)
I found it jarring, too.

Fun link: a fake interview with Chomsky: http://proteinwisdom.com/?p=16470

Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by guelo on Sunday March 25, 2012 @05:41AM (#3752182)
Warning, link is to a right wing propaganda website.
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by wyclif on Sunday March 25, 2012 @11:54AM (#3752879)
Do you give equal time fair warnings regarding left-wing propaganda websites? Hmmm?
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by emmelaich on Sunday March 25, 2012 @06:21PM (#3754041)
Perhaps guelo would like something less likely to offend his/her sensibilities. Here you go: http://norvig.com/chomsky.html
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by charlieok on Sunday March 25, 2012 @06:50PM (#3754118)
That's a very different sort of read than your first link. Your first link was basically snark. I laughed a few times, although I didn't agree with where the author was coming from. I didn't come away thinking the author had very much to say.

Go to the root domain of that site, and you find what I think most would agree is right-wing spin on current events.

Your second one is to Peter Norvig, a super-smart person at the top of his field, writing inside his area of expertise. He isn't snarking, or being disrespectful, but he's definitely giving substantive answers to legitimate questions. Norvig clearly has a lot of interesting things to say.

Visit the root domain and you find a bunch of other interesting stuff by Norvig, most of it technical. No axes to grind jump out at me.

More of the second, please :)

Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by emmelaich on Monday March 26, 2012 @07:52AM (#3756194)
Let me first agree with you that the first link was not very HNish.

But I don't think it was mere snark. It was mockery, of quite a high order. In case its not obvious most of the words quoted are actually Chomsky, from http://www.chomsky.info/interviews/200307--.htm

But let me draw some parallels.

PW paraphrases Chomsky as saying "Language has nothing much to do with language" Norvig paraphrases Chomsky as saying "Observed use of language ... may provide evidence ... but surely cannot constitute the subject-matter of linguistics" Not so different.

Lastly, you could say Chomsky might even take more offense at Norvigs calling him 'Mystic' and likening him to Bill O'Reilly!

Anyway, I don't take PW so seriously, but he is quite entertaining.

Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by charlieok on Monday March 26, 2012 @12:03PM (#3757268)
fair enough :)
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by samstave on Saturday March 24, 2012 @07:56PM (#3751207)
>Public education in this country is under attack

I think it would be far more accurate to say that our entire culture is under attack, from multiple vectors, to reduce the current upwardly ambitious mass populous to neo-feudalism.

Keeping the peasants stupid is just one tactic in a complex strategy.

Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by mooneater on Saturday March 24, 2012 @12:47PM (#3749828)
what is odd about admiring noam chomsky?
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by charlieok on Saturday March 24, 2012 @01:52PM (#3750041)
Nothing. I admire him. But I wouldn't cite him in such a hero-worshiping manner. Doing so would detract from my argument and undermine my credibility.
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by dhughes on Saturday March 24, 2012 @01:24PM (#3749942)
Why does a person have to admire?

(FYI writing the first letters of a person's first and last name in lower-case is not very polite)

Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by mynameishere on Saturday March 24, 2012 @05:58PM (#3750873)
And what kind of middle school manages to get Noam Chomsky invited for a talk? Is that something he does normally?
Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her... by charlieok on Saturday March 24, 2012 @07:24PM (#3751133)
Doesn't sound like he did. Sounds like the teacher heard him speak, and then told students about it.