C# tooling is open and freely available. The source for the compiler and tools are all on github and the tools are all available free to download and use.
If you, for e.g., want to debug you have to use MS tooling.[0] You also can't use VSCodium because only the MS built/distributed version of VSCode contains the proprietary binary blobs necessary to debug C# (which also means you're forced into the aggressive telemetry and other data collection built into the non-open source distribution of VSCode).
They've also taken steps to lock down the LSP support for C#, which once again requires that you use a MS sanctioned editor to write C#. [1]
I really enjoy writing C# and think dotnet is a great platform to develop for, but the barriers preventing me from building more projects on it is that I don't want to be forced to use VSCode or Visual Studio. I also don't want to get too invested into a particular piece of tooling that is going to be rug pulled down the road by some MS product manager who isn't aligned with the "MS <3 OSS" side of the company.
I was actually devops for a .net project at my $dayjob, and I noticed the nuget repositories we setup in Gitlab for the developers. So I could tell that a lot of my preconceptions about .net are probably wrong.
But I'd still prefer any other language like Python, Rust, Golang, Nodejs just because I'm afraid of running into some enterprise wall in their historic walled garden.
It's so damn frustrating to run into tooling issues, and when they stem from ruthless capitalism it seems even more frustrating than simple package management issues with npm for example. At least I can always check the source code. ;)
https://source.dot.net or github
>than simple package management issues with npm
Unlike js, Microsoft has shitton of stuff in std, so no need for 3rd :)
$ apt search dotnet
Sorting... Done
Full Text Search... Done
libgtk-dotnet3.0-cil/testing,unstable 2.99.3-4.1 amd64 GTK.NET library
libgtk-dotnet3.0-cil-dev/testing,unstable 2.99.3-4.1 amd64 GTK.NET library - development files
libgtk2.0-cil/testing,unstable 2.12.40-3.1 amd64 CLI binding for the GTK+ toolkit 2.12
libgtk2.0-cil-dev/testing,unstable 2.12.40-3.1 amd64 CLI binding for the GTK+ toolkit 2.12
Repo
wget https://packages.microsoft.com/config/debian/12/packages-mic... -O packages-microsoft-prod.deb sudo dpkg -i packages-microsoft-prod.deb rm packages-microsoft-prod.deb
The two things that "bit" me all these years is that, all "free" stuff given by Microsoft was just "hooks" to claw you into their expensive and closed ecosystem .
As someone said, there may be some misconceptions from legacy behaviour that is no longer true, but I fear that the only "first class" citizen CLR and tooling for .NET lives in windows. Suddenly you need IIS and sqlserver windows and all the expensive stack.
OTOH I think as a language C# is pretty neat and CLR is great tech as well, but I wouldnt dare to use it on production in a Linux system
How do you even imagine it could work?
But it comes from the corporate world, was a Windows only product for years and (worse) was made by Microsoft, so hackers ignored it.
I only figured out how good it was because I started a job doing, yes, corporate/government it.
When I'm in the zone, my creativity is flowing, the last thing I need is to register on some website, or to purchase a license.