News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by lofaszvanitt on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:42AM (#37433383)
Time to open source the chip making industry... ... ...

This whole fabrication thing is a biiig chokepoint.

Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by sloreti on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:53AM (#37433507)
Read Chip Wars [1]. The cost to stand up an advanced chip fab has reached tens of billions of dollars. It’s so capital intensive that even the US Department of Defense has exited the game.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chip_War:_The_Fight_for_the_...

Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by champagnepapi on Friday September 08, 2023 @10:00AM (#37433604)
I’ve read it, and I agree with you 100%. Open sourcing won’t don’t anything with an ASML machine costs $300,000,000.

Open sourcing software works because some many people already have the hardware (a computer)

Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by viscanti on Friday September 08, 2023 @12:18PM (#37435632)
And it's not just needing to buy the ASML machine. There's a ton of proprietary knowhow to actually get it integrated into a fab so that yields are reasonable.
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by samtho on Friday September 08, 2023 @10:36AM (#37434054)
Semiconductor manufacturing requires a lot of capital expense just to open the doors, it also requires a staff of all levels to keep the machinery working and multiple suppliers for raw materials that require multi-thousand dollar minimum orders. The process these facilities implement are fairly well understood, it’s just cost prohibitive.

If you’re trying to draw parallels between this is and, say 3D printing, you will not find many similarities. PCB fabrication is also a a different beast but a lot of people think it’s as easy as finding a fab house that takes gerber files and creates a board for them.

If we want something that more closely resembles how we develop software, we probably will need to develop processes that enables us to flash FPGAs like MCUs, make them fully read only, and allow the customer to etch their own marking onto the chip. There facilities that produce ASICs like this already, but I can see something more standardized becoming more successful for general purpose. This does however require that we have a foundry create the original chips, the difference here is that they are producing the same standardized chip for everyone which would allow any foundry to make compatible alternatives.

Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by lofaszvanitt on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:08PM (#37437987)
Yeah, we know this way. It's as convoluted and deliberately complex as building a nuclear plant.
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by 0_____0 on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:48AM (#37433455)
This is exactly the kind of thing that will never be open source. Any entity with the extremely high level of resources to fabricate chips at this node have zero incentive to open source anything, and no number of amateurs with 3D printers can change that.
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by lofaszvanitt on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:26PM (#37472453)
Would be nice to fabricate your own chips.
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by HankB99 on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:47AM (#37433433)
Isn't the cost of the equipment and sophistication required to operate the biggest barrier to entry? How would open sourcing change that?
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by FirmwareBurner on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:58AM (#37433577)
It wouldn't. HN lives in a SW bubble where Foss is the solution to everything , but fails to see that capital is the main barrier in the semi industry and, unlike their Node library, the secret sauce of cutting edge chips is a matter of national security at this point and will be kept as close to the chest as possible.
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by adrian_b on Friday September 08, 2023 @10:28AM (#37433943)
Actually if the IC design tools would be FOSS, the cost of new designs would decrease considerably, even up to two times.

The cost of the subscriptions to the design tools provided by Cadence, Synopsis, Siemens (Mentor) and a few others is ridiculously high and it can contribute with many millions of $ to the design cost of a state-of-the-art chip.

The design tools themselves have been improved extremely slowly and they are of a quite low quality for so expensive professional tools. In an open-source environment it would be easy to make much better alternatives.

The reason that only a few timid attempts exist to provide alternatives for only some parts of a complete toolchain, is that the semiconductor manufacturers, like TSMC, do not provide public information about the exact data that they need as input for manufacturing, about the design rules that must be implemented for valid designs and about the characteristics of their processes that must be known for simulations.

All this information is available only to big companies like Synopsis, Cadence etc. and this perpetuates their monopoly and their ability of extracting huge amounts of money with minimal software development work, from all the companies that design ICs.

While the companies that design ICs are not happy for this huge rent that they pay for the design tools, they are also extremely risk-averse and they do not want to make any change in their design workflows, no matter how small, that might increase the risks of failure in a designed chip. Because of this there are no chances of replacing the incumbents with open-source tools, at least not in the big established companies that design chips.

Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by FirmwareBurner on Friday September 08, 2023 @10:32AM (#37433996)
>Actually if the IC design tools would be FOSS, the cost of new designs would decrease considerably, even up to two times.

There are FOSS IC design tools but nothing that can match Synopsis, Mentor and Cadence and the semi industry isn't gonna start dealing with FOSS jank and destroy their productivity and competitiveness just to save a few milion in licensing costs to those 3 companies, which are peanuts in the end.

They're like the John Deer of semi tools, expensive to own and run, but necessary to be competitive and get the most out of this field.

Plus, the proprietary stuff is still the standard-cell libraries of TSMC, Samsung, Glo-Fo etc. They will never open source this.

>and this perpetuates their monopoly and their ability of extracting huge amounts of money with minimal software development work,

Oh, you mean just like Microsoft, Google, Apple, etc?

Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by adrian_b on Friday September 08, 2023 @12:23PM (#37435708)
At least Microsoft, Google, Apple etc. do not demand (yet) hundreds of thousands of $ per year for a single license.
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by FirmwareBurner on Friday September 08, 2023 @12:26PM (#37435749)
>At least Microsoft, Google, Apple etc. do not demand (yet) hundreds of thousands of $ per year for a single license.

Because they sell ads and monetize their users instead, which is a pipe of infinite money.

Why does it matter to you how much they're charging? It's not communism. It's their honest labor and they're allowed to charge as much as they want for it, same how you're allowed to ask for as much money as you want for your salary negotiations.

So please excuse traditional engineering companies for trying to make a living by monetizing their hard earned IP like every single company out there, and not selling ads like big-tech.

The world still needs traditional engineering companies to exist to progress, we can't have a society where everyone only works by selling ads to one another.

If you feel like they're price gouging, then feel free to write your own EDA tools and sell them for cheap, I'm sure the market is open to paying much less and saving some money.

Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by adrian_b on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:32PM (#37437521)
Like I have already said, there is no shortage of people who could write better EDA tools, but none of them can obtain the information needed to make them compatible with e.g. TSMC, despite the fact that one would think that it is in the interest of a foundry to provide the information that would be needed to enable the appearance of new customers.

However most foundries, like too many other businesses today, are not interested in new customers, unless they already are very big companies, which is one of the factors that has resulted in the extraordinary reduction in the number of companies that compete in every field, in comparison with the situation from a couple of decades ago.

Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by wincy on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:46AM (#37433431)
About as likely as open source nuke design.
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by hef19898 on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:53AM (#37433511)
Building one the WW2 designs isn't really that hard today, is it? Getting the fission material on the other hand... Just ask Doc Brown, because it is not the 80s anymore were you get Plutonium at pharmacies, ah those days!
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by pests on Friday September 08, 2023 @01:38PM (#37436770)
It depends. Little boy would be easiest as the speherical detonation and materials science for the Fat Man implosion would still be difficult to design and machine. I also do not beleive the activator designs have ever been declassified.
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by hef19898 on Friday September 08, 2023 @01:57PM (#37437050)
Doesn't have to be an exact copy so, but yes design might be tricky. I assume solvable so, at least in a primitive and workable way. Machining, to be honest, beside size of the parts themselves, is something you can do in some reasonably well equipped maker space. And for size, CNC machines are readily available on the used market. And those are light years ahead of anything the Manhatten project had. Or Apollo for that matter (excluding the Saturn V of course, but that is rocket science).
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by trashtester on Friday September 08, 2023 @05:41PM (#37439758)
From my undertanding, Fat Man requires a very precise design to focus the shock wave properly, or the bomb will never detonate properly.

This design is quite non-trivial even today. It took several of the brightest minds of all time to get it just right back then (like von Neumann).

Even with modern tools, you still need a team of quite capable engineers/scientists to pull something like that off, even if you do have the plutonium.

The little boy design is easier to engineer, but bomb grade uranium is even harder to produce than plutonium.

Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by hef19898 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @12:57AM (#37442432)
Totally agree, the science / design part of it is still not trivial. Also I know next to nothing about it.

The machining bit so, uaing proper machinery, is easy. And the necessary engineers and technicians readily available.

Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by trashtester on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:34PM (#37469754)
Not even a 1000 normal engineers can replace a single von Neumann.

What makes it easier, though, is that the general principle is relatively well known, so one could always brute force the solution using computer simulations, even if unable to do the math by hand.

Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by alwayslikethis on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:50AM (#37433484)
If we ignore the sanctions you'll be getting, open sourcing nuke design is much easier.
Re:TSMC warns AI chip crunch will last another 18 months by FirmwareBurner on Friday September 08, 2023 @10:45AM (#37434160)
North Korea can build a Nuke without OS. I doubt they can build a semi fab even with OS.