Well. Then the real issue is that a single flight plan, erroneous or not, should not stop the full system. It should flag that flight plan for problem resolution and keep on working with the rest of the flight plans.
Would result in a slightly inconvenienced flight dispatcher, or worst case an inconvenienced flight, instead of a nationwide shutdown.
I'm sure no doubt they will now fix the issue, but you can only aim to handle faults that you predict during development, plan for unexpected faults, and hope that something super unexpected doesn't cause cascading faults
They might well have considered it the possibility of duplicate tags in the same flight plan but since identical tags are supposed to geographically distinct, they probably didn't further consider a flight plan where the entry and exit points from the UK (which is a relatively small airspace, I think) are the same tag (since it sounds from the report they did that this was an extremely weird flight plan.)
Are you sure? Have you also consulted with zimpenfish? From their comment it seems they disagree.
> hope that something super unexpected doesn't cause cascading faults
But that is the thing. Processing failing isn’t and shouldn’t be “unexpected”. Here the individual processing items are flight plans, but the concept is more general. They could be “requests” to a web server, they could be “tasks” in an async worker node, they could be “transactions” in a database, if you do any compute with a work item it can fail. You need to put a big “try-catch” around it and add a field in your database or queue or remote procedure call system to mark them as failed.
One work item failing shouldn’t be “super unexpected”. Even if you can’t name the exact conditions under witch it might fail.
Sure but "flight data is safety critical information that is passed to ATCOs the system must be sure it is correct and could not do so in this case" is a reasonably valid stance in a super-critical system that must absolutely defer to safe operations in the case of error.
That is not reasonable. And it won't become reasonable by alluding to how "super-critical" or "safety-critical" the system is.
Stopping in the face of being unable to verify that safety critical information is correct is a perfectly good choice, especially when the good consequences are fairly light like "some people are a bit late with their flights" and the bad consequences may be 10s or 100s of people dying.
I think this might be the root of the misunderstanding between us. The consequences of an airplane not having a flight plan is not “10s or 100s of people dying”. The consequences of rejecting a flight plan are:
- if caught on the ground:the one flight is delayed. They don’t take off until they manage to file a fligtplan the system accepts.
- if caught at the airspace boundary when they arrive without a flight plan in the system there are two options: if ATC want to be hard-ass they will be refused entry and have to land at an alternate airport. If ATC is acomodating they will be asked at every new controller “<flightnumber> state your intentions”.
Either way the system is fine and dandy. This is not what keeps airplanes from coliding with each other or the ground.
Obviously the first option, catching the problem on the ground, is better because it is not increasing the workload of the ATC personel.
Here is the thing, you are talking about “the system cannot verify this flight plan as being correct". And you are right! It cannot. So it shouldn’t try. It should give up. On that flight plan. I totally agree with that. But there were lots of other flight plans it could and should have verified.
Have you done web development? What would you think of a server where a single weird edge case request would stop the whole service for hours? Would you say it is well engineered?
The consequence of not being able to route a flight through reasonably congested airspace safely may well be "10s or 100s of people dying".
> when they arrive without a flight plan in the system
They had a flight plan but the system could not verify that it had correct data. i.e. the system believe it had internal corruption and should shut down.
> What would you think of a server where a single weird edge case request would stop the whole service for hours?
What would you think of a service where internal checks suggested corruption and it kept on serving potential corrupt data to customers and writing it to databases? I would consider that a failure in extremis.
And I would agree. So stop serving the potentially corrupted data to costumers. Mark it as potentially corrupt and let an operator handle that potentially corrupt data manually while the system keeps processing the the rest of the not corrupt data.
Is this such a hard concept to understand? Because it feels like it is not getting through.
I don't see it said anywhere that the two same-named waypoints were consecutive, with no other points between them. Just that they were "approximately 4000 nautical miles apart". Or that being consecutive duplicates rather than just duplicates was the cause.
Since they don't name the waypoints, it is very vague.
[0] https://publicapps.caa.co.uk/docs/33/NERL%20Major%20Incident...
No waypoints that enter UK airspace between them, since "In this specific event, both of the waypoints were located outside of the UK". (1)
So there could be any number from zero up, of international waters waypoints between them?
1) https://publicapps.caa.co.uk/docs/33/NERL%20Major%20Incident...
For me, it read like "there was no route between Aa and Ab because there were no waypoints available between them". But yeah, without a more detailed breakdown, information, and/or a better understanding of the precise format of the files and procedures, it is going to be a bit of assumption and guesswork.
But the flight plan wasn't erroneous - it was perfectly valid. It just happened to have a weird coincidence of two identically tagged airports spanning the UK. If someone had put an extra waypoint in between the two, nothing would have broken (AIUI).