News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by anon808 on Thursday March 22, 2012 @04:05PM (#3741655)
It sucks, but that's the price of doing business. They chose their customer, and now are (unfortunately) tied to consequences. Same thing happens to building owners who have a crime committed by a tenant, the leased space becomes a crime scene until the police/govt are done with their investigation.
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by xymostech on Thursday March 22, 2012 @04:19PM (#3741743)
But instead of just losing use of those servers, they have to actively maintain them. It looks like they just want someone to pay for the $9000 per day that it costs to keep the servers running, they aren't looking for money that they lost from not being able to use the servers.

To go with your analogy, sure building owners aren't allowed to rent the space back out, but they most certainly not asked to pay for usual water, gas, or electricity bills (because they aren't/shouldn't be being used).

Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by AJ007 on Thursday March 22, 2012 @06:02PM (#3742256)
The owner still has grounds, building maintenance, carrying costs from a mortgage, etc. Obviously the loss would differ from a strip mall with 10 tenants vs a giant commercial building with 2.

Third parties get f'd in criminal cases all the time. One of the asset seizure stories the WSJ recently covered involved a guy whose cash happened to be in transit with an armored car company. That was, until the companies assets were seized by the feds along with his cash.

Lucky for Kim Dotcom, New Zealand let him get a hold of some of his cash for living expenses. I'm not sure he'd be so lucky in the US. Carpathia probably should have had an insurance policy for this.

Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by ma2rten on Thursday March 22, 2012 @04:37PM (#3741859)
I don't understand why this is the case, why can't they exchange the HDDs in the servers, tell the FBI to come with a big van and store the HDDs with the evidence on it themselves in some evidence room?
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by DanBC on Thursday March 22, 2012 @04:42PM (#3741885)
25 petabytes of hard disc is a considerable cost.

Some people have mentioned insurance. Would any policy cover you for a customer being investigated for possibly criminal activity?

Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by samstave on Thursday March 22, 2012 @05:06PM (#3741989)
Assuming 2TB internal HDD's at $120.00 per piece, you would need $1.5MM worth of drives to transfer this to. Not including the man-hours associated with doing so.

The $3.2MM per year is actually sounding a lot more reasonable to keep it up and running.

Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by ma2rten on Thursday March 22, 2012 @05:22PM (#3742067)
Wow, I bother to calculate it. However,

- if you buy HDDs in these quantities you will get a big discount (50%+)

- they most likely get the HDDs back after the case is finished, but not the electricity bill.

- you have to factor in opportunity costs from not being able to rent out that rackspace.

- I don't even understand how this can be proper evidence if it just hangs around at a private company.

Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by samstave on Thursday March 22, 2012 @06:07PM (#3742282)
Agreed, I was doing budgetary napkin math here... there are a lot of factors, though it does seem that the 9000/day while MAYBE 20% higher than reality is fairly realistic.
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by yardie on Friday March 23, 2012 @07:47AM (#3744704)
* HDDs have some of the lowest margins in the components business. If you're buying from Newegg you're basically getting it at cost (unless there is some conspiracy by all warehouse retailers to keep the price at >$100).

* It's the chain of custody that is important not who keeps it. Most LEOs outsource to various contractors for all types of investigations.

Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by devicenull on Thursday March 22, 2012 @06:48PM (#3742458)
Don't forget replacement RAID controllers! The RAID config is usually dependent on the exact drive/controller combination, so removing the drives and not saving the controller may result in them becoming inaccessible. At the very least, they would almost certainly not pass requirements to be used as evidence if that happened.
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by mbell on Thursday March 22, 2012 @08:37PM (#3742890)
I really hope they weren't backing 25TB of data with RAID controllers, this is well out of RAID league and well into the territory of distributed file system techniques. I ditched RAID years ago for ZFS for only an 18TB file server at home. Start talking about thousands of servers and RAID is pretty useless.

That said, IANAL but I think the interesting thing here is that just making copies of the hard drives is likely not enough from a evidence standpoint. With such a data set there are likely layers of data abstraction software that would be need to be replicated to make any sense of it.

Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by gvb on Thursday March 22, 2012 @06:41PM (#3742420)
I would pull out the existing drives, put them in boxes for the FBI, and power down the servers. As customers sign up for machines and storage, buy replacement drives and power up the servers with the new drives.

It sounds to me like they are looking for a way to keep their income flowing with servers that they will have a hard time renting out in the near future. In other words, they just got hit with a huge excess of server capacity that they are going to have a hard time renting out short term (and probably longer term as well).

Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by tedunangst on Thursday March 22, 2012 @05:23PM (#3742071)
You can get insurance for "my client shafted me but I've still got bills to pay" but more typically I think you ask the client to post bond. It's called knowing your client. An ISP doing this much business with one client but not considering the possibility of MU going under is irresponsible.
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by ma2rten on Thursday March 22, 2012 @05:04PM (#3741976)
Still less than the cost of keeping all those servers up and running. I would think that from a legal point of view, like other people have pointed out, MegaUpload needs to cover the costs. They are essentially insolvent, so that is what you'd need to insure against. That it is related to a legal investigation, should not matter for the insurance coverage, imo.
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by rmc on Thursday March 22, 2012 @05:07PM (#3741991)
Why are the servers still running? Surely it's easier and cheaper to just turn off the servers, power down the racks and lock the cages?
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by Duff on Thursday March 22, 2012 @08:29PM (#3742848)
The running cost is just part of the equation... those servers are depreciating away and generating no revenue!
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by deadmike on Thursday March 22, 2012 @05:36PM (#3742145)
I'm wondering this, too. The data would still be there, and they wouldn't have to worry about maintenance costs at least, right?
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by Retric on Thursday March 22, 2012 @08:44PM (#3742918)
Shutting them down could easily destroy evidence depending on how it's done. EX: Many redundant systems try replicating data from machines that are taken off line. What happens when the full network is taken off line quickly has probably not been tested.
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by deadmike on Thursday March 22, 2012 @09:09PM (#3743025)
I see, so even just shutting down the servers hosting MU's data could be damaging to the whole network?
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by grecy on Thursday March 22, 2012 @05:08PM (#3742001)
The building owners have to continue to pay property tax, condo fees and maintenance costs like security, gardeners and window cleaners.
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by ajross on Thursday March 22, 2012 @04:29PM (#3741806)
I hate to say it, because I'm as sympathetic to this ISP as anyone else. But this is what insurance is for. Big single customers are risks. Surely someone out there would have been willing to write a policy to cover unforseeable things like this.
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by secretcurse on Friday March 23, 2012 @03:02PM (#3746594)
If the insurance writer did their due diligence and realized the big single customer was MegaUpload (and what a large portion of MU's users were doing with the service), they would've been insane to write an insurance policy. I really don't think MU going down in an investigation falls under the category of "unforseeable." It was always a question of when, not if IMHO.
Re:Storing 25 petabytes of Megaupload data costs us $9,000 a... by jellicle on Thursday March 22, 2012 @07:24PM (#3742581)
But investigations take hours, while this case will take years.