Division and square root are generally slower than the other arithmetic operations, in both latency and throughput. They are finally partially pipelined in recent CPUs (a result every two or three cycles), but were totally unpipelined in mainstream designs for many years before that. A decade ago, they might take a few tens of cycles, now they’re generally somewhere around ten cycles latency on “real” CPUs, vs 3-5 cycles latency for the other floating point arithmetic instructions.
Anyway the question is. If you implemented fast inverse square root with out the hack. (i don't know, perhaps packing your own bits, or it might be screwball enough you only assembly could do it.) would it be as fast?
It's not actually that fast, either. Every mainstream architecture from the last 15 years (except maybe RISC-V, since it's exactly the sort of thing they would forget to add) has a "approximate square root" instruction with single-cycle throughput, and they're all both more accurate and more efficient than this. It was good for its time, but it's time has passed.