News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by flagrant_taco on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @09:11AM (#37391137)
(I can only speak to the US, though I expect it's similar in many other western countries as well)

The unfortunate truth is that we have so heavily subsidized and centralized food production that anyone focusing on biodiversity, sustainability, or even animal welfare can compete economically.

If we care at all about any of these goals, let alone all three, the only solution seems to be a much more localized food system. Large-scale ranching and farming is heavily dependent on monoculture, i.e. growing only one type of crop or raising only one type of animal. Without this a farmer has a much harder time mechanising the process with heavy equipment, and that's a must give that exceedingly few people are willing to work on a farm. Even then, most farmers eek out a living based heavily on government subsidies and crop insurance.

I'm raising a small herd of cattle on pasture, I don't have as much experience farming crops so I'll stick with ranching here. Our cows are entirely grass fed and we don't use pesticides, herbicides, or antibiotics. We don't even own a tractor because it's not economically viable to take on the upfront or maintenance costs of modern tractors. No matter how I do the math I could never sell meat or dairy at prices that come close to grocery store prices.

And no, scale wouldn't solve the financial challenge. Raising healthy cattle on pasture requires much more land per head than industrial cattle production offers. Fertilizers, antibiotics, and pesticides are all additional inputs that require expensive equipment to apply properly and ultimately are just bandaids attempting to squeeze out more head per acre than the land can actually support. At the end of the day we would end up raising more cattle, but our expenses and risk would continue to grow at least as fast and we'd end up working harder and stressing out more just to make sure something doesn't go wrong and bring the entire house of cards down.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by lukas099 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @09:24AM (#37391314)
Isn't centralized agriculture more efficient on a calories-per-acre basis? You even say that you can't raise as many cattle as industrial cattle production. Also, the more people we can feed with land in places like the US Midwest, the less land we need to use in places like the tropics which are more important from a biodiversity standpoint.
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by SamoyedFurFluff on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @09:35AM (#37391447)
Centralized agriculture is not necessarily more efficient compared to localized agriculture, because centralization introduces additional machinery, transport costs, pesticide/fertilizer research/production/shipping etc etc. centralized agriculture is actually a huge resource suck compared to localized methods, which puts a huge thumb on calorie-per-acre net.
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by Ekaros on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @09:38AM (#37391482)
How does labour costs compare? As in amount of living wage labour per calorie?
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by lukas099 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:00AM (#37391726)
On the other hand, it's easy to teach a few large farmers best practices from ag and soil science. The more decentralized agriculture becomes, the more individuals have to educate themselves. Do you trust your next door neighbors to become ag scientists to be good stewards of their land?
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by defrost on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:28AM (#37392145)
As it happens, yes.

She is an ag scientist and and damned good one to by all accounts, co owner of a regional ag consulting group.

For that matter the chap down on the corner is in the grain seed ANOVA business, he has thousands of test plots all over the wheat belt region.

What's always happened here is that everybody multi skills - not everbody is an ag scientist, but everybody knows someone who is - ditto diesal mechanics, well borers, drone operators, tractor hackers, silo builders, etc.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by Calamitous on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:20AM (#37392007)
> Do you trust your next door neighbors to become ag scientists to be good stewards of their land?

As someone who lives in a rural/agricultural area, yes.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by circlefavshape on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:26AM (#37392115)
As someone else who lives in a rural/agricultural area (in Ireland), definitely not
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by artificialLimbs on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:00AM (#37392584)
>> Do you trust your next door neighbors to become ag scientists to be good stewards of their land?

I expect the people intending to produce good, healthy, and natural food to be more able to do so than those who follow FDA standards with the sole intention of making money.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:05AM (#37392645)
The problem with industrial farming isn't an education bottleneck, it's an incentives bottleneck. Family farmers treat the land like a legacy to be passed onto their children--they don't necessarily know that they're depleting the land, and as such education is a bottleneck. But industrial farmers know they're exploiting the land to make as much money as quickly as possible. They're perfectly happy to exhaust the soil because they can make a bunch of money and still sell the depleted land for a profit later on.

Educating small farmers is a big task but it's at least actionable--I have no idea how you could go about making corporations care less about profit than they do about sustainability.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by randomdata on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @12:18PM (#37393913)
> The problem with industrial farming isn't an education bottleneck

The problem of industrial farming is the education bottleneck, though. There is good reason why virtually all farms in America have remained family farms. What growth in farm sizes we've seen has been mostly on the back of machinery and other technical innovation allowing families to do more work, and not so much farms being able to hire more and more labourers. The latter has not happened in any significant way because educating farmhands about agriculture is a monumental task. And if you manage to pull it off, there is a very good chance that they will soon want to become the farmer running their own family farm!

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @03:33PM (#37396619)
> There is good reason why virtually all farms in America have remained family farms.

This is the wrong metric; we don't care about the number of farms, we care about the amount of agricultural productivity. Large scale family farms and industrial farms account for more than half of all agricultural output in the US (USDA (2021) America’s Diverse Family Farms).

> What growth in farm sizes we've seen has been mostly on the back of machinery and other technical innovation allowing families to do more work, and not so much farms being able to hire more and more labourers.

I agree--in fact, larger machines and more automation allows large operations to reduce labor costs in ways that smaller family farms can't compete with, which is helping to squeeze out small family farms.

> The latter has not happened in any significant way because educating farmhands about agriculture is a monumental task.

No, it's because farmhands don't have access to capital to buy land and equipment. Farmhands understand agriculture, moreover, even if you can buy a small farm you'll be working 80 hour weeks to break even--you have to have a large operation in order to keep your head above water (the only really viable small operations are selling prestige 'organic / locally grown / free range' foods to yuppies and even then I'd bet many of those farmers feel pretty strapped). Anyway the farmhands aren't the ones calling the shots on how the land is managed, they're shoveling shit and driving the tractor where and how they're told.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by randomdata on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @04:39PM (#37397408)
> This is the wrong metric

It's not intended to be a metric, just a matter of fact. Industrial agriculture has never really taken off in any meaningful way because it is too hard to educate workers about agriculture.

Anyone who already has that education does so because they grew up on a family farm, and thus are likely to be still involved in that family farm. Very few people leave the family farm to work for an industrial operation.

It is true that some family farms have been able to leverage technology to grow quite large and supply a significant portion of all the food produced, but they are still family farms, not industrial farms.

> No, it's because farmhands don't have access to capital to buy land and equipment.

In my first couple of years of farming, I rented or hired out everything I needed. It is false to claim that you need to own capital to farm. In the long term I would agree it is prudent to start investing in those things, hopefully from the proceeds of your earlier years farming, but you most definitely don't have to begin farming as a BTO.

> Anyway the farmhands aren't the ones calling the shots on how the land is managed

They are going to be the actual steward of the land, though. An industrial farmer isn't going to be the one doing the work.

But when was the last time you saw a worker listen to shots called? I've worked in a lot of industries in my life and I've never seen workers listen to the shots called. They do whatever the want. They don't care if they destroy your equipment or land. What's it to them? They'll just go get a different job if you don't like it.

Thanks to advancements in automation, more and more work can be given to computers who will listen to the farmer, leaving the worker to just sit there and make a phone call to an expert if the computer fails. This is making the industrial farm idea more realistic, but we've only covered a very narrow swath of farming activities with such automation to this point.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by lukas099 on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @07:38AM (#37403673)
I think the incentives are more aligned than you think. Healthy land is productive land. Look at the adoption of no-till farming, cover cropping, crop rotation, etc. Plus inputs like fertilizer and pesticide is expensive.

I think a lot more is wasted by the millions of smallholder turfgrass farmers in the suburbs than major food producers.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by troyvit on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:39AM (#37393209)
My partner got a grant to find this out.[1]

It turns out that by building networks of producers who share their experiments as they try to find best practices for their specific place, time, and crops for regenrative ag actually helps them improve it for their context and make a little money.

The problem with ag scientists is that they stay in universities, grow a few test crops in their own fields, then try to replicate that at scale a hundred miles away. Then they throw their hands up when the producers tell them they're full of it.

On the other hand when you build real social networks of producers they can find more common ground and share stories about practices that work.

It helps too because it's actually _their_ next door neighbors who don't use sustainable or regenerative practices who are coming over and telling them they're doing it wrong. IOW the isolation that comes with the decentralized ag that you're talking about is also a social isolation that makes it really hard to even experiment.

[1] https://www.farmsproject.org

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by randomdata on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:59AM (#37393592)
> it's easy to teach a few large farmers best practices from ag and soil science.

But much, much harder to teach their workers who actually steward the land on large farms. Farmers have some incentive to listen, but farmhands couldn't care less. They are just there to collect a paycheque. The long-term viability of the operation means nothing to them – they can always get a job somewhere else. The more decentralized farming, the more farmers, and thus more people who have reason to care and fewer people who have no reason to care.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:55AM (#37392516)
Centralized-vs-distributed is mostly a matter of efficiencies of scale vs transportation, and efficiencies of scale almost invariably win. Pesticide/fertilizer/etc are all orthogonal (there's nothing preventing local farmers from using pesticides and fertilizer). In particular, the machinery costs per acre are lower for centralized agriculture than for distributed agriculture, but the transport costs are higher (although not as high as you might think because the costs of moving things around the country are shared broadly--not just by food producers). Besides machinery, personnel costs are much lower for centralized agriculture.

There are a lot of advantages to local agriculture, but 'cost' isn't one of them. I would like to live in a world where more food is grown locally, but that means we have to solve (and not ignore) the cost problem--how do we afford the additional machinery, personnel, etc costs that are passed along in food prices without pricing out poorer people?

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by BiteCode_dev on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @09:34AM (#37391432)
Yes but we are past the point where calory price is the problem. That's solved. Now we need better food.
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by mym1990 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @09:47AM (#37391578)
A calorie is not indicative of nutrition. I can eat 10 pop tarts a day for a few bucks but it has little to no nutritional value.
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:38AM (#37392285)
That's the parent's point.
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by throw9away6 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:27AM (#37392138)
Absolutely is. Especially in meat production where you can have good quarantine practices in factory farms and test at scales. We choose not to because fda has no teeth but we could and it wouldn’t add much cost
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by cfn on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:56AM (#37392537)
It is not possible to compete on price with feed lots, only on quality. Feed lots are more efficient if the only thing you're measuring is weight of meat per acre.
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by flagrant_taco on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:40AM (#37393223)
Unfortunately that is how the industry works though. There are small niches for providing high quality meat and dairy, but the market is tiny in comparison and can't come close to competing on price.

Regulation is also a big blocker. It's not even legal to sell raw milk for human consumption in the US, and for red meat it all must be processed by a facility regulated by either the state or federal government (depending on if the cuts of meat will cross state lines). If you've ever seen how USDA processing facilities operate, its far from what anyone would consider humane and if you would rather not eat meat that was sprayed with bleach you have to look somewhere else entirely.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by cfn on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @10:59AM (#37406147)
You are right, it is a small market. I am surprised about the raw milk, though, I read of places in the US that sell raw milk, cheese, etc. Maybe it is legal in some states? I also heard of companies that go to your farm to put down your cattle (also in the US) so you don't have to send them to a slaughterhouse. Again, niche stuff but nice to know it exists.
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by flagrant_taco on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:36AM (#37393142)
> Isn't centralized agriculture more efficient on a calories-per-acre basis

That's exactly the problem, the entire industry is built on metrics that revolve around calories and poundage. The calorie is an absolutely useless metric by itself and says nothing of nutritional value. Similarly, a pound a beef is not always the same and nutritional value can vary wildly depending on how the animal was raised.

Moving all production to one place like the US Midwest only externalizes the costs for everyone else. Centralizing that dramatically leaves the Midwest in a huge whole with regards to input requirements - they have to ship in fuel, fertilizer, feed, etc from other areas. Not to mention the cost of processing, preserving, and shipping that product back to customers hundreds or thousands of miles away.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by aquaticsunset on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @09:29AM (#37391367)
I'm hoping the pendulum swings back toward the middle of things. A huge push for centralization and subsidization was to ensure domestic food security. Famine or blight in one region? Overproduce a bit in another and ship it to those people.

But somewhere along the way it flew way, way past that and created a huge opportunity for business profit. Excess production with subsidies...

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by pokeymcsnatch on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:09AM (#37391858)
> We don't even own a tractor because it's not economically viable to take on the upfront or maintenance costs of modern tractors.

This is a little bit ridiculous. A tractor is an invaluable tool and there's tons of them out there that are as old as 60-70 years and still running great. You don't need a brand new GPS-guided john deere with a dealership maintainence plan to work a small ranch; $5-10k will get you something that is old, but easily maintained and will last forever.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by zhynn on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:23AM (#37392923)
Totally agree! And my advice is to find something in the 30hp zone. The yard tractors are not as generally useful from a mechanical advantage standpoint. Tractors aren't just "tillers and mowers". Along with levers and pulleys, the tractor can be seen as a general purpose force applicator.

But it can often be better to get an older tractor, as they can be easier to repair and maintain than the newer ones.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by LeifCarrotson on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:28AM (#37393005)
You don't need to go back 60-70 years to the bad old days of 9Ns with leaking carburetors, slipping clutches, and transmission-driven PTOs. A 20-30 year old 4WD compact tractor with a diesel engine, hydrostatic transmission, and independent, live PTO can similarly last forever and be easily maintained (as long as you don't buy a Deere).
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by theodric on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @02:32PM (#37395841)
nothing runs away with your wallet like a Deere
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by flagrant_taco on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:31AM (#37393067)
Oh I have absolutely looked for an older tractor. Finding a model with parts still somewhat easy to find limits the market, finding one that hasn't rusted out in a field for 20+ years is even harder. The only ones I found within 300 miles of us over the last 12 months were either rusted to hell, clearly lazy paint jobs covering rust, or collectors items that were restored and priced out of the market.

In addition to that, old tractors aren't as capable as modern tractors and are heavy as hell. If the health of the soil is a concern it lsso not ideal to run a 3,000-7,000 pound tractor across the field regularly.

Dont get me wrong, more days than not I wish we had a tractor to make certain jobs easier. I've yet to find one that fits in our budget, is clean enough to be reliable, has parts available when it breaks, and can meaningfully improve the tasks we regularly deal with.

I the meantime we have a Kai truck (Japanese minitruck) that weighs next to nothing and does some serious work around here.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by lowkeyoptimist on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:42AM (#37393267)
Why limit the search to 300 miles? I imagine paying for shipping on a cost effective tractor would be worth its weight in gold in the long run. (financial situations very greatly I know)
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by dakna on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @03:01PM (#37396223)
It's one of those things where you have to take a look in person before you buy it. 600 miles round trip is relatively easy to drive in a day without staying overnight.
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by theodric on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @02:29PM (#37395814)
Something like a Kubota L2000 (or any of the many similar ones ranging 12-40HP) fits the bill for semi-modern-ish, light-ish, small-ish, capable-ish, and cheap-ish. It can even run a bucket loader. If I can get one with a mower, roller, and sicklebar tossed in, in Ireland, for €7000, I'd imagine the U.S. will have the same available at half the cost. Don't give up. Bar one guy in Donegal, EVERY regen ag hippie farmer I've met (who didn't go under) was all "we don't need a tractor" at the outset and owned one inside of 5 years. Any sweat you spend doing things a tractor can do better and faster inside your cost envelope is sweat wasted. https://www.tractordata.com/farm-tractors/006/8/8/6882-kubot...
Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:37AM (#37392276)
I'm guessing without the subsidies our food prices would go way up and we would still probably have a lot of farmers going out of business (because many farmers are dependent on international markets that they would no longer be able to compete in)? Maybe we could address food prices by expanding "food stamps" programs, but I'm not sure what kind of policy would keep small farmers in business. And I would think mandating organic, local, small scale, etc agriculture would only make food even more expensive? (I'm not inherently opposed to expensive food as long as it doesn't worsen food insecurity).

I'm curious how Europe does it--do they just import their food from countries that can produce more cheaply (because of cheap cost of living / dodgy labor laws)? More expansive welfare to help people buy costlier food? Both?

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by flagrant_taco on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:47AM (#37393371)
I won't speak for Europeans, I lived there for a few years but not long enough to understand their system deeply enough.

I agree though, removing subsidies would destroy many of the farms that exist today. It's a prime example of the risks of welfare programs, they are presumably all run with very good intentions but in this case the industry is so wholly dependent on the subsidies that we can't remove them. The problem there is a broken system can only be propped up so many times, and the more you pile on top of it the worse it is when it finally collapses.

Hopefully people wiser than me can orchestrate a soft landing here, because I can't personally see how we safely transition our food industry off the centralized, subsidized model.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @03:52PM (#37396904)
> It's a prime example of the risks of welfare programs, they are presumably all run with very good intentions but in this case the industry is so wholly dependent on the subsidies that we can't remove them

I don't think this can reasonably be interpreted as a cautionary tale about subsidizing food prices because even if we never subsidized food production, the alternative was starvation among the poor, which seems strictly worse. Yeah, we have a system that is dependent on subsidies, but that's precisely because human beings are necessarily dependent on food. As far as I can tell, the only way to avoid both subsidies and starvation is to drastically reduce inequality.

I could also believe that we shouldn't subsidize food production, but rather we should have essentially expanded food stamps--basically give poor (and maybe even middle class) people a food stipend to offset the rising food costs.

> Hopefully people wiser than me can orchestrate a soft landing here, because I can't personally see how we safely transition our food industry off the centralized, subsidized model.

"Centralized" just means "more efficient" and thus "lower cost". Transitioning away from that model necessarily implies higher costs, which means you need subsidies so people can still afford to eat. Moreover, I don't think you're going to transition as far away from "centralized" as people think, because most of the country doesn't have the climate and geography to support local farming at the scale required to feed people (especially along the coasts). Moreover, you're just not going to grow bananas, citrus fruit, etc at scale in northern states.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by jklinger410 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:07AM (#37392675)
> The unfortunate truth is that we have so heavily subsidized and centralized food production that anyone focusing on biodiversity, sustainability, or even animal welfare can compete economically.

Inflation is far beyond what most can comprehend.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by User23 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:46AM (#37393345)
> The unfortunate truth is that we have so heavily subsidized and centralized food production that anyone focusing on biodiversity, sustainability, or even animal welfare can compete economically.

I don’t believe this, because the Amish down the road present a living counterexample. They are not only self sufficient, but they produce a surplus of frankly superior food at competitive prices.

Likewise you can get healthy and affordable (average around $3 per pound) beef from a local farmer by buying a share of a cow on the hoof and then taking your share after slaughter.

The two main “catches” that come to mind are that you only get fresh food when it’s in season and you need some kind of preservation story for when it’s not.

Since you admit your relative lack of expertise, I caution you against extrapolating too much from your personal anecdotes.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by lifechoseme123 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @11:54AM (#37393482)
"The unfortunate truth is that we have so heavily subsidized and centralized food production that anyone focusing on biodiversity, sustainability, or even animal welfare can compete economically."

...Compete... With what? I don't understand what you're saying.

Farms can't compete with farms?

To me it seems such a statement's validity would vary wildly because the value of land relative to intentions for agriculture or conservation, is dependent on geography.

It's not as though all areas receive the same subsidies or even need them. Nor do we know what subsidies or amounts are even being discussed. The whole statement just seems vague and undefined to me.

Say we're discussing private real estate in the context of agriculture & ecology-- Focusing on biodiversity, for example, has a much different ROI and perspective on that ROI, on the boundaries of a national park vs in a suburban neighborhood.

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by balderdash on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @04:19PM (#37397167)
A lot of the problem is that it is hard to compete on quality in a commodity market (even taking into account usda quality tiers).

How do you convince someone to pay 2x for your beef vs the feed lot competition (especially when the steaks look pretty similar side by side in the butcher case)

Re:Farms that create habitat key to food security and biodiv... by bmitc on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @04:33AM (#37402653)
> can compete economically

I think you meant to say can't here.