News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by ahoka on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:10AM (#37377930)
If a corporation indirectly kills millions, then no one is accountable, but try to steal from them and you end up in prison.
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by gruez on Monday September 04, 2023 @11:24AM (#37381369)
The key word here is "indirectly". You can get away with killing people too, if you do it by a traffic accident for instance.
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by beardedwizard on Monday September 04, 2023 @11:35AM (#37381499)
Tell me more about the millions dead because of coke. Are you going to apologize for criminals because people have free will? Did coke force people to drink it?
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by ipython on Monday September 04, 2023 @12:06PM (#37381789)
I believe the thread started with a veiled reference to the Sacklers and the lack of jail time related to the manufacture, marketing and covering up the fact that they knew of widespread abuse of OxyCotin (opioids).
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by drekk on Monday September 04, 2023 @12:31PM (#37382060)
It's so funny to watch commentators on HN act like every relationship sports two equal parties that individually are "autonomous rational agents"

Coke is cheaper than bottled water because of the aggressive subsidies they've pursued. The reason that poverty is correlated with obesity, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and dementia (among others) is not politically neutral or ethically innocent. It's a byproduct of the system in which we live and for which we are responsible.

Sure, you're right, the board of coca cola did not put a gun to my head and force me to do a kegger with their sodas. They "only" spent more than the discretionary budgets of some nation states to get kids "craving" (read: addicted to) high fructose corn syrup.

Speaking of guns and forcing people though, are we going to talk about how the company funds paramilitary forces in countries such as Columbia where they kill union activists? I guess those people are foreigners so they don't really enter the calculus. There's nothing more quintessentially American than funding death squads in Latin America I suppose. https://prospect.org/features/coca-cola-killings/

Watching people defend multinationals that would turn them into Soylent Green for 0.01% higher quarter-quarter growth is tragic.

Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by beardedwizard on Monday September 04, 2023 @12:47PM (#37382207)
No, we aren't because this is a story about IP theft. Why the comments devolved into apologizing for criminals is beyond me. Nobody is defending multinationals, theft is theft is theft regardless of your politics or personal agenda.
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by gruez on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:35PM (#37384110)
>Coke is cheaper than bottled water because of the aggressive subsidies they've pursued.

Source? Last time I looked into it[1], the claim didn't hold up to scrutiny.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36841407

Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by gruez on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:44PM (#37384194)
>Are you going to apologize for criminals because people have free will?

Typically victims of crime didn't choose to be harmed out of their own free will. A murder victim didn't consent to be killed. In that case I'm not sure how "free will" applies. People suffering from the negative effects of coke however, did consume it out of their free will.

Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by beardedwizard on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:09PM (#37384467)
> People suffering from the negative effects of coke however, did consume it out of their free will.

That is exactly my point. The implication in many comments is that the crime is ok because "coca cola bad" - it's not.

Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by simplyskeptic on Monday September 04, 2023 @11:33AM (#37381477)
What he's talking about isn't something they do by accident.
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by gruez on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:48PM (#37384232)
Every mile of you driving causes a non-zero amount of risk of injury to other road users. The specific crash might be "accidental", but by driving you're making a conscious choice to cause harm to other people.
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by phs318u on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @12:21AM (#37387819)
If you take this argument to its absurd conclusion, one could argue that by merely living, I'm making a conscious choice to harm other people.
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by jychang on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @06:17AM (#37389913)
… yes. That’s the entire point. That’s basically the plot to the TV show “The Good Place”.
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by FrankoDelMar on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @01:53PM (#37395343)
If you subscribe to this idea you may enjoy Schopenhauer's "On the Suffering of the World"
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by FrankoDelMar on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @01:46PM (#37395253)
Maybe a better example is to refer to the marginal effects on mortality caused by vehicle pollution, whereby simply by driving the vehicle causes harm to others, without necessitating a direct consequence of the behavior itself (such in the case of a crash). If say, one in every 10,000 trips resulted in a crash, it would be a bit absurd to say each trip I drive results in 1/10000 of a crash, whereas emitted pollutants is discrete and measurable.
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by beardedwizard on Monday September 04, 2023 @11:33AM (#37381478)
What a ridiculous take. Are you trying to say the ends justify the means? This person stole so they could make a competing company.
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by a_puppy on Monday September 04, 2023 @12:03PM (#37381771)
How do corporations "indirectly kill millions"? If you're talking about things like "Coke selling sugary drinks that contribute to millions of people dying of health problems", well, it's perfectly legal for you to sell sugary drinks too.
Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by bena on Monday September 04, 2023 @12:23PM (#37381959)
It's a bit more apparent if we use Coke's Christian name, 'Coca-Cola', and take a second to break it down. Coca-Cola implies a cola made from coca. Which is pretty much what it is. Coca farming is kind of a big deal and soft drinks aren't the only thing you can make from the coca plant. And while Coca-Cola does use leaf extract that has had the cocaine removed from it, this is less a "seedless watermelon" situation and more of a "decaffeinated coffee" situation.

So basically, Coca-Cola is kind of orthogonal to Colombian drug cartels.

Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by gruez on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:40PM (#37384153)
>And while Coca-Cola does use leaf extract that has had the cocaine removed from it, this is less a "seedless watermelon" situation and more of a "decaffeinated coffee" situation.

>So basically, Coca-Cola is kind of orthogonal to Colombian drug cartels.

This comment is baffling. The first paragraph implies that coca-cola is somehow acting like a drug cartel because their products contain coca extract, but the second paragraph does a 180 and claims that it's "orthogonal" (ie. independent or irrelevant) to drug cartels.

Re:A plot to steal the secret Coke can-liner formula by bena on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:29PM (#37384691)
Why would the information that Coca-Cola uses coca plants imply that they are a drug cartel?

They base their business off of the same plant as the drug cartels. They operate independently, and Coca-Cola isn't really going to do anything about the cartels. Or care what they do to coca farmers as long as they also get the part of the plant they care about. And since they don't need the cocaine, it's quite possible that Coca-Cola is made with the by-products of the cocaine extraction process.

Technically, we could have one without the other. Because each needs a part that the other does not. And I'm sure as long as it's cheap enough, Coca-Cola isn't going to question too hard about where its extract is source from.

And to be fair, Coca-Cola isn't above hiring paramilitaries to keep people in line.