I came here looking for the standard, oblivious, "Hey, what's so sexist about being completely sexist?" comment.
As usual, HN did not disappoint.
So let me explain:
"Women" are not a perk. Women are humans with as much value to contribute to software development as men. To list them as a "perk" and to relegate them to a service role minimizes women in two ways beyond the obvious, gross objectification:
First, by saying "hey, all women are good for at this event is serving beer."
Second, and much more toxic, listing women as a perk reveals the unspoken understanding that heterosexual males are the intended audience for the event and that anyone else is secondary.
> I think if anything it offends programmers.
But yeah, by all means, muster up some indignation for all the poor, privileged, over-represented men who should be offended by this.
It's bad for all of us. Sexism (or any -ism) is a net negative for anyone who values the intellectual growth of society, regardless of sex, gender, or orientation.
I didn't realise that they had listed women explicity as a perk. I just thought it was a bad bit of copy. I didn't see their original site and as it has now been taken down.
I thought they had listed it in a less obvious way noting the servers would be women to bait males to attend.
Perhaps this is a bit more than a kerfuffle then.
While what they wrote turned out to be sexist I don't think at all this was there intention. They fell into the trap of sterotyping their audience. If your a hacker your probably a pale introvert with little access to women. The trouble is a hacker/programmer/whatever is just a job title. The people who do these jobs have variety personalities and genitals.
If anything they misunderstood their audience which is a shame really and managed to generate some copy that could offend just about everyone.
Surely in this context generate == produce. I don't really get how you could take what I wrote as 'these guys made content "magically appear" in their event description'.
This isn't the kind of language that should be used by an event trying to attract female participants, but on the other hand I don't think many men would object to being listed as a "perk" at an event for elementary school teachers, flight attendants or some other female-dominated field. There certainly wouldn't have been a lynch-mob reaction as there was in this case.
The real world is asymmetric... and that holds for every human culture.
Sex sells. While there are good reasons for restrictions in many situations, the successful strategy will be to walk up to the line of what's acceptable, whether that is booth babes or simply having attractive people (particularly women) in PR and advertising materials. This isn't an ideal situation, but unfortunately we don't live in an ideal world.
I can respect people who wish we were built to value competence or altruism like this instead of sex. It's very hard to make progress without addressing reality, though. One of the more unfortunate things about political fads is that they make it difficult for people to even discuss issues. It's far easier to write-off, downmod or brand dissenting opinions as immoral, heretical, communist, sexist, divisive, etc... than it is to really probe them.
PERKS
* Women (who will serve you beer)
The people at Sqoot really need to learn better writing - their listing on EventBrite was full of typos.I think there is some value to "I'm sorry that upset you" -- obviously the apologizer is not sorry that the thing was done, but they are indicating they did not mean it maliciously.
"""Women: Need another beer? Let one of our friendly (female) event staff get that for you."""
Perhaps the quote is missing context, I found it here: http://philomousos.blogspot.co.uk/2012/03/how-to-apologize.h...
To me it doesn't even make sense. What is this 'Women:' bit about?
If you discount the 'Women colon' I think if anything it offends programmers. Are we really so geeky that we would go to an event just to get a beer from 'female' event staff?
Perhaps they think their audience is locked in some underground lair 364 days of the year and women have become nothing but a mythical creature to a programmer. The promise of seeing this rare and mysterious creature serve beer would make someone like me want to go? I think not.
There are 3 things that bug me about this.
1) The quote makes no sense and if you try to rationalise it attendees should be most offended.
2) People have got into such a kerfuffle which in scheme of things shows the inexperience of the hosts rather than their malace.
3) The event might not go ahead at all because of this... which seems like a bit of a shame.
This looks like a storm in the tea cup brewed by people who don't get out enough.