News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by nawgz on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:24PM (#37343886)
It's a big claim. To estimate "1280 individuals" is... very precise.
Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by psychphysic on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:37PM (#37344004)
The estimate is the estimate (1280 +/- 131).

It's be foolish of them to mask it intentionally.

Once independent estimates are made then you might synthesize an reasonable estimate.

Both the editor summary I'm science and the headline here don't place much emphasis on the precise number.

Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by adhesive_wombat on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:40PM (#37344032)
The actual linked article isn't the paper, and doesn't even name the paper as far I can tell, it's just given as "Hu, W. et al. Science 381, 979–984 (2023)."

This is the actual paper, which (presumably, I cannot access) is specifically about how they made the estimate: Genomic inference of a severe human bottleneck during the Early to Middle Pleistocene transition:

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abq7487

Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by br1 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:39PM (#37344029)
It is a somewhat 'round' number, the width of 720p resolution.
Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by spiderice on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:33PM (#37343970)
Yeah.. how can they possibly be so precise in that number? Anyone know?
Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by sho_hn on Thursday August 31, 2023 @06:03PM (#37344259)
They aren't, it's an estimate (with error bars).
Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by RoyalHenOil on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:47PM (#37344086)
This is the number supported by DNA evidence. There will be a margin of error.

The bigger issue, for me, is that I'm not sure how they can rule out the possibility that there were lots of other people around at that time whose lineages gradually died out. Modern genetic lineages may trace back to 1280 people (+/- the margin of error), but it seems pretty dubious to assume that those were the only people living at that time. It seems highly likely to me that there were infertile people, people who died young, people whose only living children were infertile or died young, etc.

(I did not read the original paper, so maybe they accounted for this, or maybe they that specify that this was a genetic bottle neck for modern humans, but not necessarily the actual size of the population.)

Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by jltsiren on Thursday August 31, 2023 @06:39PM (#37344532)
"1280 people" is just a misleading simplification early in the linked article. Both the news article and the original paper speak of 1280 breeding individuals.

Also, the way population dynamics work, lineages tend to die out quickly or not at all. Isolated populations can die out gradually, but it takes exceptional circumstances for a population to survive in the long term while remaining isolated.

Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by postmodest on Thursday August 31, 2023 @06:24PM (#37344419)
"there were lots of other people around at that time whose lineages gradually died out"

It seems to me that if those lineages aren't in the DNA data, then they didn't --in the intervening years-- intermix with the lineages in the DNA data.

So, ipso facto, those lineages went extinct, and the 1280 ancestors posited in the study are the non-extinct lineages. QED.

Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by RoyalHenOil on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:08PM (#37344746)
That's correct.

Now, that doesn't necessarily mean they were isolated from each other, however. If we suppose that the population was actually 5000 people (just an example; I have no idea if this is a realistic number), then some percentage of those people died with having children, some may have seen their children die, etc. Of the 1280 people who still have living descendants, many of them would have had children with those people who did not, but those children (or grandchildren, etc.) eventually did not have any children themselves.

Within your own social circle, you likely know some people who will still have living descendant generations from now and some who will not.

Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by suoduandao2 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:00PM (#37345120)
If those lines died out from intertribal competition though, it wasn’t a near-extinction era. Some slightly less competitive group could have made it into the present day in that case.
Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by svnt on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:56PM (#37344180)
There is a minimum in the fossil record at that time. There may be other explanations for it, but one very reasonable one is that there just weren't very many skeletons to potentially fossilize.
Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by RoyalHenOil on Thursday August 31, 2023 @06:41PM (#37344556)
Certainly. However, I am still highly doubtful that there were only 1280 people alive at that time. I'm not sure that this is what the article is claiming; however, it is written in a way that makes it very easy to come away with that message (as evidenced in this comment section).

What are the chances that every person alive today, for example, will still have living descendants in 400,000 years? If people 400,000 years in the future do a genetic study on themselves to determine how many of their ancestors were alive in the year 2023, what percentage of the 2023 population will they be able to account for? My guess is a lot lower than 100%.

Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by Roboprog on Thursday August 31, 2023 @06:02PM (#37344248)
Exactly: it's really hard to tell if "the environment" took out the other hominids, or if the descendants of the 1280 took them out.

"Hmm, this monkey looking thing isn't as tasty as a wooly mammoth, but it'll do."

(it's not like chimps don't catch and eat other primates)

Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by sidfthec on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:52PM (#37344131)
> I did not read the original paper, so maybe they accounted for this

Then why say it's an issue?

Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by fooker on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:54PM (#37344155)
They haven't.
Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by RoyalHenOil on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:00PM (#37344703)
I'm not saying it's an issue with the research. It's very likely the researchers thought of this.

It IS an issue with the article linked here, since it does not explain the research and causes readers to walk away believing there were only 1280 people.

Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by vic-traill on Thursday August 31, 2023 @06:05PM (#37344274)
It's obviously the result of Roll Call: SMITH Here! JOHNSON Here! WILLIAMS Here! BROWN Here! JONES Here! GARCIA Here! MILLER Here! DAVIS Here! RODRIGUEZ Here! MARTINEZ Here! HERNANDEZ Here! LOPEZ Here! GONZALEZ Here! WILSON Here! ANDERSON Here! THOMAS Here! TAYLOR Here! MOORE Here! JACKSON Here! MARTIN Here! LEE Here! PEREZ Here! THOMPSON Here! WHITE Here! HARRIS Here! SANCHEZ Here! CLARK Here! RAMIREZ Here! LEWIS Here! ROBINSON Here! WALKER Here! YOUNG Here! ALLEN Here! KING Here! WRIGHT Here! SCOTT Here! TORRES Here! NGUYEN Here! HILL Here! FLORES Here! GREEN Here! ADAMS Here! NELSON Here! BAKER Here! HALL Here! [ ... ] ROSADO [ ... Crickets ... ]
Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by latchkey on Thursday August 31, 2023 @06:11PM (#37344318)
I upvoted you on the amount of work you put into that comment. Even threw in a nguyen there too.
Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by vic-traill on Thursday August 31, 2023 @06:23PM (#37344411)
I was shooting for 1280 surnames, but the comment length limit fixed that. Which I am grateful for in general :-)

Anyway, I surmised I would give away just about all my karma on the comment, but, hell, I just couldn't resist!

Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by latchkey on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:16PM (#37344801)
It is always worth risking a few karma points for a well crafted comment.
Re:Human ancestors nearly went extinct 900k years ago by hulitu on Saturday September 02, 2023 @09:41AM (#37361463)
They have very good meters those days. /s

The fact that there is no comma (as in 1280,3333) is puzzling.