Yes, flood insurance and some other examples, but my objection isn’t based on platonic ideals of equally bad policy for everyone, it’s based on pragmatic ideals of not extending bad policy more widely.
Let the market price insurance. At most I might support a mandatory tax on profits that is set aside to cover exceptional future losses, kind of FDIC-like.
At the risk of taking this down a political path, I'll take this a step further. States like FL who fall into this bucket are further aggravating as they are also the ones that espouse personal responsibility & small government.
I'm not personally against subsidizing these things. But I am against people screaming until they're blue in the face that they hate socialism and then cry foul when their insurance rates are too expensive for them to afford.
I'm 100% fine with an individual choosing to not pay going insurance rates and choosing to live in a risky environment. I'm also 100% fine with that person eschewing the idea that government should be subsidizing anything. I'm 0% fine with such people coming back and complaining that the leopards ate their face.
And then wouldn't it be in the interest of the insurers to maintain a shared list of "bad" (unprofitable) customers and freeze them out? Which is already a bit of what credit scores are for?
"Your previous insurer dropped you, there must have been a reason."
And, yeah, when applying for a policy, the questionnaire should include "have you filed a claim for X, Y, Z in the last 2 years?" Auto insurance does this already.
Insurance companies have a privileged legal position to do all sorts of stuff.
Depending on climate there’s some other options too.
... in a non-hurricane zone, right?
Sounds like some of these coastal areas are on a ~5 year roof replacement cycle. Up here in DC, shingles last for 30+.
It's becoming more difficult to find a place to live that does not have some potential issue, be it water, weather, heat, cold, earthquakes.... supervolcanos :)
Where do you live that’s so safe and disasters are uncommon and aren’t on the increase?
Everywhere will have different risk factors, the American attitude seems to be ‘I won’t pay for anyone else, even if it means I ultimately will have to pay more’.
Where I live, hardly any disasters - tornado about every 100 years, last time there was huge wildfires was just after WWII, zero risk of flooding - biggest 'risk' I have is being snowed in for a few days as I dig out - there are plenty of places that have a much lower risk profile - and people like me, that pick where we live based in part on the risk, shouldn't have to pay extra insurance to cover people who willing choose to live in low-lying, flood prone areas.
If you build your house in an area like that and fail to build any sort of protection for expected conditions, why in the world should your losses be subsidized by everyone else?
When the cost of insurance for your beach house is too high, that is a signal that you are at extreme risk, not a signal that you should pass a law to make the rest of the country pay for the portion of the risk that you can’t afford.
I don’t see a solution honestly. With global warming large parts of the world will become uninsurable. And we shouldn’t expect insurance companies/the government to carry that burden just because someone decided to live there.
Of course, there are ways to be humane about this, given that tearing people apart from their communities is bad for society. The government could taper off the program slowly, giving communities time to relocate. Or they could provide damage payouts with the stipulation that they are used to relocate somewhere else with lower risk, not rebuild in the same spot.
But to indefinitely subsidize building in doomed places? Doesn't seem right. I'm sure there's nuance I'm missing, happy to be enlightened.
If the amount of uninsurable properties is (comparatively) small, it’s way easier to throw some money at them and keep everyone happy. I think that’s the basic premise of the program.
Everything changes when, for example, a large chunk of South Florida becomes uninsurable or inhabitable, potentially displacing hundreds of thousands. I don’t think we have anything in place for that scenario.
In order to enjoy living in places where nature exact a larger toll - near the ocean, on a mountain that gets dry and doesn't have a fire station nearby - homeowners will need to invest in hardening their homes, invest in buying more expensive insurance and will need to make sure they have the financial buffer to rebuild if their home is damaged by the weather.
As the ocean rises, we will need to move more inland.
That's why I'm surprised that the government provides subsidized insurance for folks in extremely flood-prone areas.
There is a pretty obvious solution in my mind: The federal government offers homeowners a buyout for them to move out of that property. If they choose not to take the buyout, they are removed from the flood insurance program.
This would save the government a lot of money over time, even if they made the buyout significantly higher than the property value.
So we're going to buy those folks out anyway. This year, next year, 20 years from now. Eventually. It would be better to start now. New Orleans should have been abandoned already.
You're acting like a buyout is inevitable when it's not. The last thing we should do as a society is a multi-hundred-billion / trillion dollar buyout of beachfront hotels and luxury property.
The wealthy beachfront property owners will point the media's cameras at the also-destroyed properties of the poor and elderly in the area, saying "How can the USA let these poor people lose everything!" We, the stupid taxpayers, will fall for it and bail everyone out.
What the perso you are responding to is saying is that we should start in incentivizing people out of such properties now versus it happening over a longer period at a higher cost. Either way some people are going to probably have to move so we may as well get ahead of it
"Now you need to reach into your pocket and pay them back." "Nah; fuck off. They can live with their decision."
Doesn't matter if it's beachfront - there shouldn't be a home on a beach that sees significant hurricane damage every year.
It’s easy for states to regulate insurance companies for political points, which you’re seeing in California and Florida. However, insurance markets collapse slowly and then very very quickly when the math stops working out.
If beachfront properties have substantial risks that inland properties don't (such as flooding from storm surge*), then not using is_beachfront? as a factor will end up being a subsidy to the owners of beachfront properties.
Or at least they ought to be left to fend for themselves if they suffer losses due to that.
Is that a controversial statement? Beachfront property is not a human right. If it's too expensive to insure, then it becomes available only to people who don't financially need insurance - or those who are willing to risk going without it even if they would need it financially.
If the problem is stated that way, I think a lot of Americans are going to realize how little they care about Florida's insurance market.
Say you were an insurer… would you want to take risk for Florida hurricane losses knowing what we know?
If we want a functional insurance market in these places, we need a student loan type solution - make the Feds the reinsurer and have the insurance company mostly administer the policy.