Odd then that so many forms of insurance are mandated by the government.
Alternatively, suppose cars become super risky and you need to charge $10,000 a month to insure the car, and reasonably conclude that no one is going to pay that, and after you pay for marketing and overhead and payroll, you will still lose money if you try to sell the insurance product. Do you stay in the market?
It's especially funny to see everyone in the comments complaining that the insurance company is "only thinking about the short term".
There should be no marketing if it's mandated. These companies should not be run for profit since having insurance is required by law in many situations.
Or that insurance companies should be nonprofits?
I'm just not going to engage with you any more since clearly you're not thinking about what you're saying.
Yes, I think all insurance should be nationalized. You may not agree, but accusing me of not thinking clearly is an ad hominem.
It's safer to just get out of the market entirely. You can always go back in but if you stay in too long it could wipe you out entirely.
Payroll? Overhead? Marketing? Rent? This isn't a thought exercise, there are real costs associated with being in a certain business.
You're currently paying for that neat little 3d animated gecko under threat of US law.
That list includes my state. I buy auto insurance because it's more convenient (and cost-effective) than going through the bond posting process, arranging my own claims-handling and legal representation in the event of a loss, etc.
I looked into a surety bond specifically for auto insurance thinking I might be able to earn a bit of interest on $100-200k cash, get a small dividend, and "break even" in half a dozen years or so. The reality was pretty grim, basically if you're not already actively searching for things to do with 6 or 7 figure sums, it's not worth the time, and that's ignoring the logistics of having someone available for the claims processing side.
The healthcare argument is different and reasonable. The lack of a taxpayer-funded health scheme in the United States combined with making it illegal to opt out of being alive (and requiring health insurance) is nonsense.
The problem is lack of competition, both in pure number of companies due to consolidation, and also widespread collusion between what should be independent companies in the form of adopting the same business policies, software, and even surveillance databases (aka customer records).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...
I assume it's because of natural disasters such as Fires, Hurricanes, and sea level rise?
https://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/facts-statistics-homeowne...
Houses are more expensive in CA, building costs are more expensive in CA and the weather is more volatile (and becoming increasingly so) in CA.
The rate level in CA needs to increase. The regulator in CA makes it difficult to raise rates, so companies are responding by reducing their appetite.
So you would have a situation where a roof needed to be replaced, should cost $30k. A roofer comes up with an estimate for $60k (and maybe pays the homeowner back a $10k kicker), gets the homeowner to sign over the insurance policy to him. Then he hires a lawyer who spends $50k of his time litigating the case. Let's say the court sides in favor of the insurer and awards $30k, the lawyer still gets $150k (3x multiplier on the $50k of fees).
As a result you had Florida accounting for 8% of the homeowners insurance claims nationally and 75% of the lawsuits nationally. There are billboards for insurance attorneys EVERYWHERE in florida.
The phenomenon impacted big national companies like State Farm that have similar claims handling procedures across their book. So State Farm would handle claims exactly the same in Florida as in Illinois and get sued 10x more often in Florida because of the financial incentive to sue. It also impacts Florida's state-owned insurer, which does compete very vigorously in the market and is the largest insurer in the state.
David Altmaier, the former Commissioner of Insurance in Florida, wrote a good piece on that situation - https://floir.com/siteDocuments/ChairIngoglia04022021.pdf
Fortunately Florida took a really good stab at fixing the problem with some legislation passed last December. It will take a while to see if the legislation worked, however. Meanwhile we still have the macro factors (climate change, reinsurance costs) to contend with. https://bestsreview.ambest.com/edition/2023/february/Florida...
Systems do sometimes collapse, but I would prefer to look at it as "we are smart enough to study these systems and act in the social best interest when failure is imminent or has already happened, and responsible enough to work to improve the society that makes our lives possible."
Parts of the world are becoming inhospitable for human life. We can try as we might to terraform and engineer against it but Mother Nature will win.
At some point as an insurance company or even whole industry needs to look at the data and assess whether the juice is worth the squeeze. These companies - despite marketing materials - don’t care about fixing your home. They are only interested in risk versus reward. When the operating environment becomes too risky you either raise prices astronomically (this is happening) or you pull out entirely because your customer base simply can’t afford it (this is also happening).
Regarding the stance that we are smart enough to outsmart these problems - I agree but also disagree. What do you do when all signs are pointing to no and the cost of potential solutions far outweighs any benefits? You cut your losses and move.
We are smart enough to be proactive about these sorts of things, and considering we already have such an apparatus called "the state" to use to our benefit, we can provide assistance to people to reinforce their homes or move when necessary (in a rote economic sense, to keep them net-positive productive, in the utilitarian sense; in a humanistically compassionate sense, to keep them dignified) instead of trying to guide systemic patterns of behavior by punishing individuals for making impossibly complex choices regarding where they chose to and already do live.
That's literally the apparatus of the state (in both senses of the word) used to the benefit of the residents. That may just have the effect of moving the problem from "my insurance premiums are too high" to "my taxes are too high", because at the end of the day, someone has to be paid to fade the risks inherent in insuring the property against perils.
The issue with Citizens is that it does create a lot of financial risk for the state, especially since it doesn't buy as much reinsurance as a private company would.
as opposed to the whims of a few unelected bureaucrats? influenced by the whims of the politicians trying to buy votes?
> We are smart enough to be proactive about these sorts of things,
no, "we" are not. Let's suppose you are, for the sake of argument. What reason is there to think that the sort of people who get appointed to regulatory bodies are equally smart? As opposed to just "well-connected."
You're talking like this is some kind of conspiracy theory, when there's not really any other way it could work. Banks will not give you a mortgage without home insurance, because then it would be an unsecured loan against an asset which would be worthless, with them eating the loss, if the house was destroyed. That's not sinister: nobody wants to loan against an ephemeral asset. And car insurance is mandatory because if you hit somebody, causing a million dollars of lifetime medical bills, and you don't have insurance, you've just fucked their life over with no possible recourse.
Markets have taken many different forms, have been entrusted with different sets of responsibilities to different degrees, over the course of economic history.
Perhaps it makes more sense now to develop a fiscal institution to run insurance than to continue to rely on a market-based solution.
Lenders are mostly in the business of underwriting loans so that they conform to certain standards, such as those set by the government (fannie mae/ginnie mae/freddie mac/etc), and then selling them to the government after which their cash flows then get sold to investors looking for fixed income investments.
So it might be too much work to for little return to step outside of this optimized system and custom design a mortgage product, especially when the alternative is government subsidized mortgages whose interest rates you will not be able to beat.
>Mortgage interest is tax deductible but home insurance isn't.
Since 2017, 90% of US tax filers do not itemize, and so they cannot deduct home mortgage interest.
Wow, as someone who's been itemizing his whole life, that's astonishing if true. Learned something new today!
If you have a 3 year old child crying in a restaurant, can you get mad at it? No. You can pat it on the back and take it outside to respect the space and other patrons, but you can’t get mad at a child for crying. Same analogy. Don’t get mad at nature doing nature things.
If someone said I’m going to start free climbing the tallest buildings in the world - but I need insurance - the company will tell you to get lost because the risk outweighs the reward. This is what insurance companies are doing all over the place (fl/ca) because those environments are truly becoming uninsurable.
But then people are shocked and awed when the situation happens with them. Why? An insurance company is not a charity it’s just a profit engine. Don’t get mad at the dog for barking at the mail man :)