Alternatively, suppose cars become super risky and you need to charge $10,000 a month to insure the car, and reasonably conclude that no one is going to pay that, and after you pay for marketing and overhead and payroll, you will still lose money if you try to sell the insurance product. Do you stay in the market?
It's especially funny to see everyone in the comments complaining that the insurance company is "only thinking about the short term".
There should be no marketing if it's mandated. These companies should not be run for profit since having insurance is required by law in many situations.
Or that insurance companies should be nonprofits?
I'm just not going to engage with you any more since clearly you're not thinking about what you're saying.
Yes, I think all insurance should be nationalized. You may not agree, but accusing me of not thinking clearly is an ad hominem.
It's safer to just get out of the market entirely. You can always go back in but if you stay in too long it could wipe you out entirely.
Payroll? Overhead? Marketing? Rent? This isn't a thought exercise, there are real costs associated with being in a certain business.
You're currently paying for that neat little 3d animated gecko under threat of US law.
That list includes my state. I buy auto insurance because it's more convenient (and cost-effective) than going through the bond posting process, arranging my own claims-handling and legal representation in the event of a loss, etc.
I looked into a surety bond specifically for auto insurance thinking I might be able to earn a bit of interest on $100-200k cash, get a small dividend, and "break even" in half a dozen years or so. The reality was pretty grim, basically if you're not already actively searching for things to do with 6 or 7 figure sums, it's not worth the time, and that's ignoring the logistics of having someone available for the claims processing side.
The healthcare argument is different and reasonable. The lack of a taxpayer-funded health scheme in the United States combined with making it illegal to opt out of being alive (and requiring health insurance) is nonsense.
The problem is lack of competition, both in pure number of companies due to consolidation, and also widespread collusion between what should be independent companies in the form of adopting the same business policies, software, and even surveillance databases (aka customer records).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...
Odd then that so many forms of insurance are mandated by the government.