Markets have taken many different forms, have been entrusted with different sets of responsibilities to different degrees, over the course of economic history.
Perhaps it makes more sense now to develop a fiscal institution to run insurance than to continue to rely on a market-based solution.
Lenders are mostly in the business of underwriting loans so that they conform to certain standards, such as those set by the government (fannie mae/ginnie mae/freddie mac/etc), and then selling them to the government after which their cash flows then get sold to investors looking for fixed income investments.
So it might be too much work to for little return to step outside of this optimized system and custom design a mortgage product, especially when the alternative is government subsidized mortgages whose interest rates you will not be able to beat.
>Mortgage interest is tax deductible but home insurance isn't.
Since 2017, 90% of US tax filers do not itemize, and so they cannot deduct home mortgage interest.
Wow, as someone who's been itemizing his whole life, that's astonishing if true. Learned something new today!
You're talking like this is some kind of conspiracy theory, when there's not really any other way it could work. Banks will not give you a mortgage without home insurance, because then it would be an unsecured loan against an asset which would be worthless, with them eating the loss, if the house was destroyed. That's not sinister: nobody wants to loan against an ephemeral asset. And car insurance is mandatory because if you hit somebody, causing a million dollars of lifetime medical bills, and you don't have insurance, you've just fucked their life over with no possible recourse.