News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by Aaronstotle on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:44PM (#37312092)
For anyone interested in a good video about this, there is YT video that details how the Ice Cream Machine's being broken is essentially a scheme that McDonald's corporate runs on their franchisees.

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrDEtSlqJC4

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by nyokodo on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:40PM (#37312837)
Can you summarize that video? I got about 7 minutes in and it still hadn't answered the question but did get an ad, so I gave up. Too much filler and noise!
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by kevinventullo on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:45PM (#37312904)
From https://www.fastcompany.com/90923565/congress-mcdonalds-ice-...:

The incentives here are all aligned against quick repair: Taylor makes more money when machines are broken. McDonald’s corporate has a lucrative service contract with Taylor. As a result, poor franchisees, who have no choice about what equipment to buy or how to service it, are forced to deal with broken machines and annoyed customers.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by googlryas on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:22PM (#37314309)
Why wouldn't McDonalds just not do that, and charge more to franchisees, and pocket 100% of the amount instead of whatever cut they have to give to Taylor?

Surely, franchisees and potential franchisees talk to each other, and if any appreciable amount of money was going out the door to fix the ice cream machine repeatedly, it would be a known cost of doing business.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by MostlyStable on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:46PM (#37314574)
One possible reasons is that repair fees might not show up in planning the way a guaranteed franchise fee bump would. You can get your franchisees to pay more money if they don't know they are going to be paying it ahead of time, potentially.

If the full extent of the repairs necessitated by the behavior were clear, obvious, and known ahead of time, then yeah, this would strictly be worse. But a slightly lower, but secret, fee might be preferable to a higher but obvious fee.

That's just me speculating though. Could also just be incompetence or maliciousness, or maybe just once upon a time a particular person in McDonalds corporate took a bribe to make it happen. Who knows.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by qudat on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @06:39PM (#37315086)
30 min video condensed to 3 sentences. Thank you for saving our time!
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by jmorenoamor on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:46PM (#37312922)
I make and repair machines, you have tons of restaurants.

You mandate that franchises have to buy my machines, and only me can service them.

We both benefit economically from this agreement.

Also, machines enter in service mode without needing it just to give me more business.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by SirMaster on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:33PM (#37313601)
If I recall some video I watched awhile ago:

1. McD HQ mandates franchises buy a special model Taylor-Made machine (not the same that like Chick-fil-a and others use). This is why McD machines stop working but other companies don't.

2. Every night there is a very specific maintenance routine that needs to be ran to clean and prep the machine for the next day. If it's not followed perfectly, the process will likely fail and the next morning workers will be greeted to a cryptic error code. Sometimes re-running the process will clear it, sometimes it wont. But this can take hours.

3. If re-running it doesn't fix it, then the franchise owner is stuck with the dilemma of bleeding money not having a working ice cream machine for customers, or calling an expensive hourly certified Taylor-Made repair person.

4. So they usually end up calling the repair person.

The idea is that McD HQ is working with Taylor-Made to make this problem happen so that franchise owners have to pay for expensive repair people.

Apparently the error codes have been reverse-engineered with a USB device that a third party created. But Taylor-Made is said to deny warranty and service etc if you try to use one.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by ixwt on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:51PM (#37313873)
I believe that there is a lawsuit involving the third party devices as well. Pretty interesting saga.
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by chongli on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:02PM (#37314056)
A small nitpick:

TaylorMade is a manufacturer of golf equipment. They are not related to Taylor Company, the maker of these ice cream machines.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by skyyler on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:14PM (#37314206)
I took it as they were trying to say tailor-made, in reference to a bespoke-for-McDonald's product.
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by SirMaster on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:52PM (#37314643)
That works haha, but I did get the company name wrong, my bad.
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by skyyler on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @07:33PM (#37315597)
I try to give things the most generous interpretation on here :-)
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by magic123_ on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @05:30AM (#37319464)
Not sure if you knew this but it is actually explicitly asked in the HN guidelines: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by SirMaster on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:52PM (#37314639)
Whoops, yeah I got the company name wrong.
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by listenallyall on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @06:38PM (#37315074)
> This is why McD machines stop working but other companies don't.

Is it possible that what goes into those machines at McDonald's is thicker than Chick-fil-A's mix, rather than the machine being to blame? Just like some kinds of motor oil are harder on an engine than others.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by SirMaster on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @09:54AM (#37322210)
Well the question is why does McD franchising terms stipulate they have to buy a special model of the machine, but it seems that no other fast food places that use ice cream machines from the company have such a requirement.

I mean I guess there could be other reasons of features or quality or something, but it seems a bit strange. I mean, in the end, it's just McD machines that constantly break down, so if anything you would think HQ would want to improve this situation somehow, when it seems they are completely uninterested.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by listenallyall on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:41PM (#37324770)
Maybe McDonald's has decided, their unique ice cream mix performs better in taste tests, or that it works better for McFlurries, or whatever... but the one downside is that it jams up machines much more frequently.

If you already anticipate that your ingredients are going to break machines quite often, and that you'll require a lot of repairs, it would benefit you to standardize on a single large-scale support contract rather than leaving it up to every independent operator for themselves. Kind of the same way taxi fleets usually mandate one single specific model of automobile despite thousands of independent medallion holders.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by voisin on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:56PM (#37312235)
I am surprised the franchisees haven’t launched a class action. No other fast food chain has these issues.
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by 0cf8612b2e1e on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:15PM (#37312483)
Surely the franchise agreement would prohibit such an action?
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by voisin on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:38PM (#37312816)
I am not sure such a clause would be upheld in a scenario where the franchisor blatantly acts in bad faith outside of industry norms to fleece the franchisee. There is a reasonable expectation of good faith.
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by liveoneggs on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @08:26PM (#37316055)
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by krisoft on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @06:56PM (#37315255)
It's probably not even that. As a franchise you are under the thumb of the big corporation. They have a lot more money, and a lot more leverage to break you if you start suing them. They can probably inspect your premises, find 200 violations normally overlooked and then suspend your right to use their branding or suppliers. Sure you might win eventually, maybe in court. And then maybe you can sue them that the inspection happened in retaliation, but do you really want to risk that?
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by kevinventullo on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:48PM (#37312950)
FWIW, I imagine the “invisible hand” is already in effect. That is, at the margins there are probably some potential franchisees who were dissuaded by McDonalds’ actions here.
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by saikia81 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @07:06AM (#37320215)
Is this an American joke I'm too European to understand? /s
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by droopyEyelids on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @03:23PM (#37312604)
On the other hand, we have the fact that listeria just killed a couple people due to ice cream machines not getting cleaned properly. https://www.cdc.gov/listeria/outbreaks/monocytogenes-06-22/i...

Franchise owners use 'hacks' to disable the lengthy cleaning process on their machines to make more money at the expense of our health.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by ImPostingOnHN on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:07PM (#37313203)
that seems like a unrelated issue, the machines here aren't being disabled due to non-cleaning

also that was last year

also there's nothing in your link about it being due to someone hacking their machine

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:34PM (#37313609)
It's also obvious that technical measures would be useless at preventing this. Checking whether a local restaurant is following safety standards is for the local Health Inspector, not the machine vendor -- who would have the incentive to help them cheat as the one paying for their machines, if they weren't running a scam that makes the machine return false positives on purpose to generate profitable service calls.

A prohibition on "hacking" only protects the scam.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by adolph on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:17PM (#37314245)
Below is a milkshake listeria incident from this month. There is a balance to be sought between "right to repair" and safe operation of equipment. The discussion here [1] about dangers of ill informed self-service ebike batteries is an example. I'd like to see the standards for chilled dairy equipment maintenance before I would believe any claims about capabilities for self-repair.

OLYMPIA – Listeria bacteria found in all milkshake flavors sold at Frugals restaurant at 10727 Pacific Ave. S., Tacoma, WA are associated with a foodborne listeriosis outbreak linked to six hospitalizations and three deaths. Investigators found Listeria in the ice cream machines, which were not cleaned correctly. No other Frugals restaurants are believed to be affected. The restaurant stopped using its ice cream machines Aug. 8, but Listeria can sicken people up to 70 days later. [0]

0. https://doh.wa.gov/newsroom/listeria-bacteria-found-milkshak...

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37293557

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by bsder on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @07:31PM (#37315579)
In the McDonald's case, though, it wasn't a "hack". It was simply reporting the error properly.

Apparently one of the biggest failure modes is "overfull supply hopper doesn't heat fast enough". Just reporting that tells you what you need to do to fix the problem. Dump a couple cups out and rerun the cycle. Or "feed too viscous"--dump the entire thing and run water on a cycle. Then reload with a fresh batch.

This seems to be emblematic of that machine.

And, the problem isn't that these machines don't have good error reporting. The problem is the fact that these machines are terribly unreliable. A 15% failure rate is bad. However, there is no money to be gained from fixing the issues. So, neither Taylor nor McDonalds's will spend any money to fix it.

It's also emblematic that, given the health sensitive nature of the machines, no other company attempts to do heating in place. I presume that somebody in those franchises looked at the reliability numbers and laughed Taylor out of the room.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by Bukhmanizer on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @04:07PM (#37313205)
As someone who used to take apart and clean those machines I expected to hate this video but found it pretty spot on.

McDonalds was my first job and as someone who was pretty technologically inclined I started taking apart and fixing a lot of the old broken machines. I wouldn’t say the ice cream machine was completely impossible to fix, but it was absolutely a pain. We also had an older model so it may also have been simpler to fix.

One thing I would add is that it also highlights the importance of having a good maintenance person even in McDonalds. The reason why I knew a lot of the tricks with the ice cream machine is we had a guy there, who had been working overnight maintenance for >10 years there. The video mentions that you can’t expect minimum wage employees who have only been there for 2 weeks to know how to do these things. But there’s so much involved with running a restaurant that you can’t expect a 15 year old with no experience to do. But so often these positions are treated like any other low wage/low skill job. He probably saved the franchisee millions of dollars in maintenance costs over the years yet only was paid ~$20 an hour (if that).

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by specialist on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @05:54PM (#37314652)
Great share, thanks.

To your last point: That's the mentality of treating labor as an expense rather than an investment.

Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by jherico on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @06:27PM (#37314960)
I've seen this video and while it's informative overall, it's also about 10 minutes or less of information stretched out to 30 minutes. super repetitive throughout and trying to constantly tickle you with the idea that resolution to questions are coming any second now.
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by qudat on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @06:37PM (#37315056)
Totally agree. I couldn’t make it through 10 mins before being completely annoyed. It’s well constructed but frustrating to watch. It was constantly teasing their results throughout the video and I left knowing less than I did prior to watching.
Re:iFixit Petitions Government for Right to Hack McDonald's ... by sen on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @08:02PM (#37315862)
Welcome to modern YouTube, where channels are heavily pressured to increase user watch-time or they'll get penalised.

I'm a huge fan of YouTube, it's the only tv/video/etc type content I watch in life, yet they're intent on destroying everything that made it amazing in the first place.