Is there any chance you'd expand on that? I'm curious to know your thoughts.
I’ve heard this exact argument about VHDL versus Verilog, with the former being explicitly based on Ada’s syntax and the latter being explicitly based on C’s. (Turns out though that VHDL is also strictly better than at least traditional Verilog, as it requires separate interface specifications which lead to improved modularity.)
If anyone were to actually try to create “Ada: The Next Generation” I’d encourage you to just go all the way to S-expressions. Focus on the completeness and correctness of _the system_ and stop worrying about superficial complaints—or brush them off with a suggestion that they can use any syntax they want and just translate it to the standard one via tree-walking.
I think of it a bit like rat's nest wiring vs. nice neat labelled cable looms.
I'll use this chance to say that I'm a fan of Ada's declarative blocks, which you could say are part of its syntax. There's a lot to like about Ada, and I'd encourage anyone interested in bare-metal programming to give it a try. Even if you don't intend to use it long-term, there's a lot of good language design ideas in Ada that can be learned from.
To address a sibling comment alleging that I'd rather it look like C, that's not necessarily true. I know this is much more controversial, but I'm actually more of a fan of Python's syntax.
I always felt that repeating myself to the compiler (down to `procedure subprogram is begin`…`end subprogram`) or otherwise being verbose was something of a feature in the vein of defense in depth than the syntax not aging well. It never seemed to me like it was meant to impose clarity on the code, just that you were meant to file your subprograms and types in triplicate. It's useful as a backstop against trying to do things quickly instead of doing them deliberately.
At least, Ada's use of verbosity stands in stark contrast to COBOL, which does have the explicit aim to make things clear.
I'm mostly of the same mind as you in re Python's (and Haskell's and F#'s) whitespace-oriented ways of doing things, at least until the real world creeps in. I've had problems with early block termination because of mixed tabs and spaces that weren't readily apparent, and the language's toolchain wasn't particularly helpful in diagnosing them, leading me to lean on external tools. (COBOL at least has the heritage of being column-oriented, so indentation being significant is less problematic there.)
It's not a bad way to go, in practice, as long as it lasts.
I'm curious, never had a look at Ada, can you elaborate?
General lack of dumb C stuff like switch fallthrough, null terminated strings (Arrays in Ada are passed with fat pointers), undefined behavior, no need for memcpy, no preprocessor bullshit etc.
Ada is more like C++ in functionality so it has Generics, Tasks (Threads), Exceptions, Packages, Strong types, Design by contract etc (All much much saner than C++ stuff)
Despite all of the features it's very embedded friendly. Language allows you to disable features you dont wont with Restrictions Pragma (Very long list of restrictions you can apply: https://docs.adacore.com/gnat_rm-docs/html/gnat_rm/gnat_rm/s...). You can also fairly easily change runtimes: https://docs.adacore.com/gnat_ugx-docs/html/gnat_ugx/gnat_ug....
> Ada is better than C
> lack of dumb C stuff
Back to your comment, strong types and generics look super nice for embedded. Not sure I would like fat pointers, exceptions and threads in my embedded code though.
Sorry about that, English is not my first language so i might sound rude sometimes. I actually dont hate C, but if you used it you know its flaws. I think stuff i mentioned about C is objectively bad, hence why i called them dumb stuff.
>Not sure I would like fat pointers, exceptions and threads in my embedded code though
Fat pointers are just pointer + size of an object. You have to pass array size anyway, so its just convenient. Obviously, if you need to just pass a pointer there are ways to do that.
As for exceptions and threads: As i said, you can disable or modify them just by using Restrictions pragma. Its a language defined thing. For example, Ada 2022 defines two profiles for safety-critical hard real-time computing:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ravenscar_profile http://www.ada-auth.org/standards/22rm/html/rm-d-13.html
No offense taken, not a native here either ;-)
> if you used it you know its flaws
Indeed, I've been using C for almost 20 years now. I won't say it's without flaw for sure, it has its quirks, but overall I do think it's quite okay for the job.
> Fat pointers are just pointer + size of an object
Yeah I know what fat pointers are, I even resort to handcraft some form in C for some neat performance hackery on x64.
But the thing is, we're talking embedded here. Most ucontrollers I use have 8b address space, no MMU or any form of virtual memory, separated instruction/data bus (MVHA). That kind of thing don't play well with funky fat pointers.
Sure if your definition of embedded is "64b ARM" all is good, but I guess we're on a spectrum.
Exceptions are pretty much non existing as well, since that would require some form of runtime, which you often just cannot afford on a small chip (if not just form the sheer size of it).
Threading is a no go as well. To get threads, or any form of multitasking really, you have to rely on an operating system, which by definition is a bit weird to have on an embedded IC.
You can definitely use Ada on 8bit microcontrollers, for example on 8bit AVR: https://docs.adacore.com/gnat_ugx-docs/html/gnat_ugx/gnat_ug...
You can make runtime as small as you want.
As for exceptions and threads: I mentioned them because thats what comes to mind first, there are more benefits obviously.
https://learn.adacore.com/courses/advanced-ada/parts/data_ty...
http://www.ada-auth.org/standards/22rm/html/RM-13-1.html
Wouldn't it be nice in C to be able to define how a struct is laid out in the machine representation? In Ada, you can and it is part of the standard, so it is portable:
https://learn.adacore.com/courses/advanced-ada/parts/data_ty...
// Ada
for Day use (Mon => 2#00000001#,
Tue => 2#00000010#,
Wed => 2#00000100#,
Thu => 2#00001000#,
Fri => 2#00010000#,
Sat => 2#00100000#,
Sun => 2#01000000#);
// C++
enum Day {
Mon = 0b00000001,
Tue = 0b00000010,
Wed = 0b00000100,
Thu = 0b00001000,
Fri = 0b00010000,
Sat = 0b00100000,
Sun = 0b01000000,
};
As for the record representation, my understanding is that it is equivalent to having a normalized __attribute__((__packed__)), where smart compiler padding is disabled and you can arbitrarily decide the memory layout of your struct? procedure Enable_USB_Clock is
begin
Registers.PMC_Periph.PMC_SCER.USBCLK := 1;
end Enable_USB_Clock;
Example taken from here: https://learn.adacore.com/courses/Ada_For_The_Embedded_C_Dev...
I think that an ada-like language could make a real resurgence in embedded programming. Ada gets all the things about bare-metal right that C got wrong. However, it's held up by legacy tooling, clunky syntax, and obtuse compiler errors. Adacore has gone a long way towards alleviating those issues over the last few years, with alire and the ada_language_server. Time will see where this language takes us.