News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by shaklee3 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:42AM (#37245081)
Starlink is not as amazing as it's made out to be. There have been many LEO constellations before it, but due to the space industry as a whole being unattractive to investors, it didn't get any attention until musk got into it. Starlink as a technology is nothing new; what is new is their launch cadence that gives them the ability to put so many satellites into space.

They are still not making money and will require starship before that happens. You can look at other ventures like one web that just didn't get the press that starlink got despite having similar characteristics. Vertical integration with the launch is the only thing that starlink apart technology wise.

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by kierank on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:37AM (#37246418)
SpaceX deliberately doesn't make money as they want to invest as much as possible into going to Mars.
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by shaklee3 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:14AM (#37248364)
That's not how VC investments work
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by yencabulator on Thursday August 24, 2023 @11:32AM (#37250014)
Lots of VCs will happily eat a loss for many years if it gives them a larger piece of the future pie. See Uber.
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by shaklee3 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @11:35AM (#37250071)
Nobody was arguing that point. I'm disputing the fact that Starlink, as a satellite internet service technology, is doing anything new. The launch cadence due to SpaceX's progress on rockets has nothing to do with the Starlink side.
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by yencabulator on Thursday August 24, 2023 @11:42AM (#37250187)
Show me a non-Starlink satellite internet service widely available that can reach 200+ Mbps for a smallish fixed monthly cost.
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by shaklee3 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:00PM (#37250468)
Ah, but anecdotes don't mean reality:

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/09/ookla-starlinks-...

Starlink's median download speeds in the US dropped from 90.6Mbps to 62.5Mbps between the first and second quarters of 2022, according to Ookla speed tests.

Satellite broadband has been able to hit 200Mbps to a single terminal for over a decade, but it makes no business sense to do that. This is why Starlink speeds are slowly degrading to where legacy satellite companies are. So having an anecdote from 4 years ago where the first Starlink terminals hit those speeds has really no basis in reality today as the system fills up.

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by yencabulator on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:05PM (#37250526)
Anecdote from 4 years ago? I ran that speedtest while writing the comment. You're blinded by your hate.
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by shaklee3 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:50PM (#37251259)
I'm not sure how many times you want me to repeat the same comment, but anecdotes don't match reality. Ookla and the FAA consistently show Starlink speeds on the decline to about 1/3 of what you're seeing for most users. The fact that you're in a (temporarily) uncongested area doesn't mean your speeds will stay what they are.
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by yencabulator on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:53PM (#37251324)
It's a little weird to me that you're telling me the thing I just experienced "doesn't match reality". You can say it doesn't match the typical experience or something, but surely what I just experienced is reality.

What me being in a relatively uncongested area means is that I'm exactly the kind of customer Starlink was meant for...

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by shaklee3 on Saturday August 26, 2023 @12:40PM (#37274389)
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by inemesitaffia on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:35PM (#37254204)
FCC cited Ookla. These aren't independent sources
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by shaklee3 on Saturday August 26, 2023 @12:40PM (#37274392)
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by inemesitaffia on Sunday August 27, 2023 @08:45AM (#37282162)
Merci. Still not relevant for the subsidies though since it's forward looking
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by inemesitaffia on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:35PM (#37284849)
Moreso these aren't relevant to denial of the application because it wasn't publicly available then.

And these are peak hours rather than median living day hours that providers usually use

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by xedeon on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:46PM (#37254326)
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by panick21_ on Thursday August 24, 2023 @07:12AM (#37247486)
So much nonsense. Starlink is nothing new lol. And sure launch is the only thing differnet about it, mmh sure.

You shit on Starlink and then hype up OneWeb a system that is generations behind technologically, went bust and has far, far, far less capability. While also being worst for space pollution.

Also SpaceX just made a profit, despite investment in future Starlink and Starship. Starlink is already cashflow positive and its still in its first generation.

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by shaklee3 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:13AM (#37248361)
Then tell me, what is new about starlink? You just refuted it without naming one thing.

They did not make a profit. That was a speculative article and nobody knows how they're accounting for starlink costs.

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by panick21_ on Sunday August 27, 2023 @09:20AM (#37282458)
First of all, quantity is a quality all on its own. This has to be repeated often, having one of something is far easier then having 1000s. So even if, nothing in Starlink was knew, nothing that is one Starlink was ever produced the way it is for Starlink. Starlinks vertical integration and mass production is totally knew in the sat industry.

Now since you might not want to count that (despite mass production of sats being a huge challange), lets look at some other things. While Electric propulsion isn't knew, it wasn't exactly common specially for non science missions. Starlink v1 used Krypton, as far as I know Krypton wasn't used on operational sats. The Starlink v2 Argon thruster is pretty damn revolutionary in its performance and the first use of argon on operational. So if you want to name 'one' thing this would be it and it isn't really debatable.

Starlinks laser communication is top of the line in terms of performance and having a whole constellation of laser link sats coordinating for best connection is certainty unique. And not as a research project, but actually operational on commercial sats.

Starlink flat construction is also pretty unique, making so many sats stack-able is a significant advance if you compare it how the other largest constellations were deployed. There is additional innovation in the way they are deployed threw a rocket rotation and a spring mechanism, its unique and brilliant.

The Starlink sats also use a sun shield to make the sats harder to see for earth observation, as far as I know this has not been done before.

Starlink operations is also whole unique, on a personal per sat bases SpaceX is leading by far. SpaceX has a very small team for operations and made excellent use of automatic avoidance on a large scale, doing avoidance even for even unlikely collisions.

We simple don't have all the information, we don't know everything there is to know about the antennas for example. They are likely quite a unique design as the ground terminals are, but we just don't know.

I could go on to talk about ground systems as well, be lets leave it here.

The simple reality is, Starlink as system is fundamentally revolutionary. Any claim that cheaper rockets is the only 'new thing' is basically putting a board before your head and screaming 'lalalalal'. Even being charitable and assume that all individual technologies were demonstrated as research before doesn't change how revolutionary the system as a whole is.

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by yencabulator on Thursday August 24, 2023 @11:28AM (#37249955)
> Starlink as a technology is nothing new

Dishy is the first phased array antenna widely available to consumers, as far as I know.

Starlink is the first low orbit massive satellite constellation. The scale is truly new. The older geostationary communication satellites are a distinctly different system.

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by shaklee3 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @11:33AM (#37250042)
> Dishy is the first phased array antenna widely available to consumers, as far as I know.

Dishy is the first phased array antenna that was willing to take a huge loss on each sale to consumers. This goes back to the point of getting VC and FCC money to subsidize the service. The estimated cost of the dish is still $1100-$2000 since SpaceX doesn't have any phased array technology that's proprietary, so at $500 they're taking a loss.

> Starlink is the first low orbit massive satellite constellation

Massive is a property of the launch cadence and not anything specific to the satellites.

> The older geostationary communication satellites are a distinctly different system.

What is different about the satellites compared to something like Iridium, O3b, Intelsat, etc?

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by yencabulator on Thursday August 24, 2023 @11:41AM (#37250175)
[delayed]
Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by shaklee3 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:08PM (#37250566)
Once again, your anecdotes don't match reality, which is decreasing quickly:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37250468

You can say 210Mbps all you want, but that's simply not even close to what most starlink users get.

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by inemesitaffia on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:32PM (#37254170)
Flat pack design for one. Cheaper propulsion. Laser links for truly global coverage. Massively lower price per bit. Around $1 per GB (comparable to Jetpack like plans for 4G servics) for the most expensive public Best effort plan

There's no FCC subsidy for it. And the fact it's still running means it wasn't necessary for deployment. It will just make profits come faster. Or losses stop faster

The loss on the phased arrays is much bigger since there was a commitment to $2400 for the first million.(Ukraine is a big source of losses if the Feds haven't fully paid up)

But consider what other phased arrays sell for

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by shaklee3 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:45PM (#37254305)
Flat design is irrelevant and is not a differentiator. Cheaper propulsion is speculation unless you have data to prove otherwise. ISL has been around for a long time (see iridium). SpaceX achieved higher rates, though.

They won $900M in RDOF funding (based on a lie), which is still in limbo because of the poor performance. It's likely they will still get some or all of that since not all $900M was tied to the same speed tier. There is absolutely no proof this can be sustained forever, just like there isn't for Uber or Lyft not being profitable.

Other phased arrays with their specs do not sell for much more. They're small, low G/T, low EIRP, "cheap" units.

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by inemesitaffia on Thursday August 24, 2023 @05:32PM (#37254817)
On propulsion::::

https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=36552.1200

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5MEPWsdo-UE

https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/36165/why-will-sta...

I don't know if it's cheaper because it's something im not particularly familiar with.

But there's people who think SpaceX isn't launching (internal costs) for less than 60 million anyway and reuse isn't saving money

Re:SpaceX working with Cloudflare to speed up Starlink service by inemesitaffia on Thursday August 24, 2023 @05:11PM (#37254601)
I remember looking for a Ku Band Phased array for a large drone. Cheapest I could find from a reputable company was $16k.

Kymeta dishes in Ukraine that replaced starlink go for $25k minimum

Not one dime of RDOF was paid. And knowing how the last RDOF equivalent worked they had every right to apply and get awarded (delivery is dubious though except in less densely populated areas). They don't seem to fake speed tests too unlike the US Telco they are partnering with for direct to cell.

The flat design means way more sats per launch. And that means you're mass rather than volume limited. It's a big difference maker since theres no central stand. Check out the SpaceX OneWeb launch as a comparison.

Iridium links are microwave. SpaceX is a laser. The tech is licensed. It's not just bit rate. And I don't think you can do 10 to 20 up on Iridium. is it possible? Is it possible at say Viasat Maritime prices? Iridium to carry drone video and/or Netflix at $10k to $20k p/m?

Is it financially viable? Time will tell. Some space economist claims SpaceX twisted the arm of the Feds for over a billion in Ukraine. I don't believe him