But alas, very few laws use that kind of structure - not only in the USA, but anywhere in the world, and not just for environmental stuff, but for any regulated thing.
Instead lawmakers seem to prefer to see some problem, make some move, and then if the problem still exists repeat the process.
I don't really understand the aversion to 'automation' of that loop.
Even if they were all electric or powered by unicorn farts or whatever, it's still millions of multi-ton steel vehicles zipping around leaving as much trace as a multi-ton moving thing would. I grant you at least the air quality would be better without internal combustion.
In the end, all Europe is filled with cute little walkable towns, yet people still congregate to the congested, filthy, car-filled metros, for some reason. And at a certain level of built-up population density, you just can't have a very nice natural environment; the brief moments of peace you observed during the Covid lockdowns or whatever can't last, because that would mean the city itself dies.
Argument that we'll need to live with 5% or 10% or 20% of traffic we have today, so we can as well do nothing is dishonest.
Unless your solution is that people should just move less?
Humanity might go extinct in the process, but they would have at least stopped further destroying the only planet they have to live on in the process.
Even if scaled in over time to avoid breaking the economy you would have a long tail of cheap used cars which would be difficult for users to up and replace owned by those least likely to be able to absorb the shock.
You have folks commuting in a $5000 car for 10 years for which $20,000 would be a financial death sentence. There are plenty of folks who absolutely need a car to be able to work and continually keep an older used car for a LOT less than average.
Not all of these folks could even get a car loan for a compliant car so you would be basically telling them to go fuck themselves.
It makes more sense to simply mandate phasing out manufacturing or importing new gas powered consumer cars and let cars age out rather than using extreme gas taxes as a lever.
Yeah, great idea there.
Cash for clunkers has directly caused what will be the next subprime loan crisis.
Why would I want the govt screwing up the situation even more?
In lockdown most people sat inside and went a bit crazy. That's not an improvement.
I've witnessed two political decisions that led to no cars on the roads (the UK fuel strike 23 years ago, and the COVID lockdowns), and in both cases they made the sub/urban environment better immediately.
As soon as batteries or whatever can replace hydrocarbon engines for the average person, then sure $160US/gallon or whatever.