I'm very confused by this description?
What exactly is "trans ideology"? And how do you "buy into it"?
I consider myself a centrist on most things. And I don't really understand that statement.
Either you think that people who want to dress, act, and be treated differently than their birth sex should be allowed to do so. Or you think that people should be forced to act and be treated as based on societal gender expectations.
I don't see what "ideology" there is here?
It goes much further than 'societal gender expectations' and accepting or denying that people should be able to dress and act how they want.
I said two things:
1. If a man does hormone therapy they are biologically transitioning towards a woman, this is e.g. why they can give breast milk. In biology a sex isn't always as clear cut as many believe and there exists ample scientific research on the topic, so this isn't the topic of our discussion.
2. With the biology out of the way, what remains is the question of the gender — the social, societal and mental role of what it means to "be" a woman. And obviously like with any role people can have different ideas of what it includes and what it excludes. What the left does is simply to say: "Fuck those social constructs, they don't help us, if someone wants to be a woman they are a woman", while the more conservative type might have very specific (bit in the face of history: arbitrary) ideas on what a "true" woman looks like, behaves like, is like.
The conservative definition of the gender roles we have a net-negative effect in our society. And that goes for men as well. So many "real" men, that immitate what they think "makes a man" — because of fear that they are not they fail their loved ones and they fail themselves. They confuse acting strong with being strong, while the strong (=harder to do) thing would be to confront your own weaknesses.
So if trans-ideology simply means not taking those roles seriously I am on board. If it means something else I am all ears.
What's missing here is the gender critical position: that women are female, men are male, and that gender roles should not be imposed on anyone, nor do they define who is a woman and who is a man.
By contrast, those who identify as trans need those roles so that, for example, a man can "be" a woman by behaving in accordance with the gender role traditionally applied to women (e.g. wearing dresses and make-up) while telling everyone he's a woman. In that sense, those who believe this are more similar to conservatives.
I do find it strange to call it an "ideology", but I guess if you want to say that.
It still seems to me it's just debating the idea that people who want to dress, act, and be treated differently than their birth sex should be allowed to do so or not.
I guess you can say that's an ideology, because it's an ideal societal reality that is being advocated for, to allow for this behavior and socially accept it.
But I don't see what you find goes beyond this?
Problem: Someone would prefer to be treated like society treats woman, including being referred too as one.
Debate: Should we allow this or not
Pro-trans stance: We should allow it.
Anti-trans stance: We should not allow it.
Males who develop gynecomastia, even if deliberately induced by taking exogenous oestrogen, don't somehow become female by doing so, if that's what you're implying?
Similarly for females who take testosterone and end up with hirsutism, and so on. There's no change of sex.
Do you mean that you do not believe that anyone has a brain chemistry that makes them feel like either they have the wrong gendered body or like they're not totally quite woman or man?
Or do you just mean that you don't trust everyone who pretends as such, and think there are some that are just opportunist about it?
That's not the issue, it's the idea that "woman" and "man" are identities that can be opted into, and the effects of implementing this belief in law and policy.
So, for example, in some jurisdictions, a male criminal who has been sentenced to prison can declare himself to be a woman, and as a consequence the authorities will lock him up in a women's prison rather than the men's. This type of policy has led to several sexual assaults, rapes and pregnancies of female prisoners by male inmates who have been incarcerated with them on the basis of this ideology.
Prisons should be evaluating whether the person was genuinely living as a woman (and possibly taking hormone treatments, etc) before putting them into a women’s prison, and not just because they declared “I’m a woman now” after being convicted and sentenced.
Nobody making a fuss about trans people causing problems in prisons seems to give a single fuck about all the sexual assaults and rapes that happen between men or between women in prisons. It’s only when trans people come into the picture then all of a sudden prison rape becomes a big issue.
- Ramel Blount, a man who was housed in a women's prison and raped a female inmate just after she'd finished showering. [1]
- Karen White, a man jailed for rape, who sexually assaulted two female inmates while in a women's prison. [2]
- Janiah Monroe, a man who murdered his male cell mate, who was transferred to a women's prison and raped a female inmate. [3]
- Demi Minor, a man incarcercated for manslaughter, who was housed in a women's prison after claiming a female gender identity, and impregnated two of the female inmates. After this, he was moved to a male prison. [4]
All of these cases, and more, could have been avoided by incarceration of these prisoners according their sex. This is a failure of policy caused by implementing the ideology of gender identity.
[1] https://reduxx.info/transgender-inmate-convicted-of-raping-f...
[2] https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/oct/11/transgender-...
[3] https://www.womenarehuman.com/transgender-felon-who-killed-m...
[4] https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-news/nj-trans-prisoner-i...
One could argue that all those many, many incidents documented by Fry were "cherry picked" too, but that would seem rather disingenuous, considering the clear pattern demonstrated, and the much-needed reforms that followed. These recent cases in jurisdictions that have decided to make prisons mixed-sex again just add more data onto what is already known.
Yes, sexual assault is a wider problem in prisons, but that's no reason to make it even worse for women prisoners by locking them up with men, based on this fashionable but harmful ideology that claims these men are somehow actually women.
Second, a grammatical gotcha is far from a proof. Our language is not a perfect representation of reality.
That's the point. Your conceptualization of gender doesn't actually make sense to the true reality of gender expression.
You have this idea that gender "should" be some way. You were told this, and raised to believe that. But if you're observant of the real world, you see that there exists many people for whom this doesn't make sense.
You can see there are people that have the traits of one and the sex of another. You can see that there exist many more relevant characteristics than just genitals. The structure, size and connections of the brain, the hormonal balance, the organs, the bone structure, the chromosomes, etc. All these things exists in so many more combinations than two distinct clearly delineated sets.
And so, like we did in the past with believing the earth was the center of the universe, or not knowing what caused diseases before we learned about germs, or why thunder would strike. We're forced to re-evaluate our understanding of reality, and update our mental models with one that can fit all we observe and better predict reality.
In the past, ideology has actually worked to repress and hide this reality. Forcing people that don't comform to pretend otherwise.
And yet here we are, thousands of years into human history, and still there exists many people that don't fit the model. They existed throughout history, there's accounts of it in writing from many prior civilizations.
Which takes me back to what I said previously. You can continue to want to repress them. Or you can just accept a model where there is a spectrum of gender, with most people fitting nicely one side or the other, but also many that are somewhere in between.
And that means, if they want to act or be treated one way or another, you can be okay with that. Or you can think that we should force them otherwise.
> Or you think that people should be forced to act and be treated as based on societal gender expectations.
IMO both the things you described are already ideologies. They're narratives which take observations and applies a moral or policy prescription. Ideology is a dirty word in the US but it's also apt here.
Says who? You can be left wing without accepting trans ideology, and you can be right wing without becoming a nutjob. And nobody is forcing you to align with either the left or the right anyway.
What party? It's very strange that the democratic party exists in two states within America - the boogeyman democratic party on Fox News, and the actual democratic party that votes in congress. What trans "agenda" is the democratic party actually pushing?
This boogeyman democratic party seems to only exist so that conservatives can hide behind the label of "centrist". In this alternative universe, AOC is the president instead of a Representative (she's not even a Senator!).
https://karadansky.substack.com/p/why-i-think-were-much-furt...
Do we actually know that yet though? Handedness seems to be genetic, but for the rest we really don't know the causes.
> "If you are born trans, that is okay, we accept you." ... this should be a acceptable view to you too.
Why? It shouldn't matter if it's innate, a development 'disorder', a choice, or a result of trauma or social contagion. We can just accept people anyway.
Yeah we know that (for various definitions of "know", but the evidence suggests biological factors have the most impact). There could be more research on that topic (and there would have been if the Nazis didn't burn down the first research institute that researched that field). This is a good starting point: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causes_of_gender_incongruenc...
> Why? It shouldn't matter if it's innate, a development 'disorder', a choice, or a result of trauma or social contagion. We can just accept people anyway.
Then we agree. And I am not sure "The" left wouldn't agree with the both of us as well. Most leftists I know are also pretty accepting of similar conditions (e.g. mental health acceptance, etc).
One of the most taboo is the influence of pornography. As Andrea Long Chu, a male who now identifies as a woman, writes: "If you've ever seen sissy porn, you'll know that turning people female is exactly what sissy porn says it does. [...] Sissy porn did make me trans."
This is from his book Females, where he has other such porn-soaked insights, such as: "At the center of sissy porn lies the asshole, a kind of universal vagina through which femaleness can always be accessed."
So I agree, it's wise to be sceptical of claims that this is some innate condition. But I also think we should be wary of accepting it in all its guises - should a man who has masturbated his way into having a "female gender identity" really be accepted as if he is a woman? Probably not.