Prisons should be evaluating whether the person was genuinely living as a woman (and possibly taking hormone treatments, etc) before putting them into a women’s prison, and not just because they declared “I’m a woman now” after being convicted and sentenced.
Nobody making a fuss about trans people causing problems in prisons seems to give a single fuck about all the sexual assaults and rapes that happen between men or between women in prisons. It’s only when trans people come into the picture then all of a sudden prison rape becomes a big issue.
- Ramel Blount, a man who was housed in a women's prison and raped a female inmate just after she'd finished showering. [1]
- Karen White, a man jailed for rape, who sexually assaulted two female inmates while in a women's prison. [2]
- Janiah Monroe, a man who murdered his male cell mate, who was transferred to a women's prison and raped a female inmate. [3]
- Demi Minor, a man incarcercated for manslaughter, who was housed in a women's prison after claiming a female gender identity, and impregnated two of the female inmates. After this, he was moved to a male prison. [4]
All of these cases, and more, could have been avoided by incarceration of these prisoners according their sex. This is a failure of policy caused by implementing the ideology of gender identity.
[1] https://reduxx.info/transgender-inmate-convicted-of-raping-f...
[2] https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/oct/11/transgender-...
[3] https://www.womenarehuman.com/transgender-felon-who-killed-m...
[4] https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-news/nj-trans-prisoner-i...
One could argue that all those many, many incidents documented by Fry were "cherry picked" too, but that would seem rather disingenuous, considering the clear pattern demonstrated, and the much-needed reforms that followed. These recent cases in jurisdictions that have decided to make prisons mixed-sex again just add more data onto what is already known.
Yes, sexual assault is a wider problem in prisons, but that's no reason to make it even worse for women prisoners by locking them up with men, based on this fashionable but harmful ideology that claims these men are somehow actually women.
That's not the issue, it's the idea that "woman" and "man" are identities that can be opted into, and the effects of implementing this belief in law and policy.
So, for example, in some jurisdictions, a male criminal who has been sentenced to prison can declare himself to be a woman, and as a consequence the authorities will lock him up in a women's prison rather than the men's. This type of policy has led to several sexual assaults, rapes and pregnancies of female prisoners by male inmates who have been incarcerated with them on the basis of this ideology.