But whether something is going to catch fire or not is often the domain of voodoo witches. The person who can figure out how to make the right game at the right time consistently will be rich, the one who doesn't will not.
i feel like there is no structured decision making that will produce a successful game. In the same way, there's no such a decision making process to painting a piece of artwork that will sell.
And if you found this secret process or meta formula for coming up with new amazing game formulas, why not just keep it to yourself to build the most spectacularly successful game studio in history. (Maybe that's Nintendo? Blizzard at its best also has some magic touch on any new genre they touch, even where they mess up like Overwatch they end up making and taking down the entire genre with them.)
I dunno, maybe in ten years game development will be like some automated AI windtunnel/R&D lab remixing various game genres and formulas and spitting out new fun things. But I like that there is a sorcery to it for now that elevates human creativity over process.
I do appreciate the effort to build a risk assessment framework, even if it feels slightly oversimplified. I'm looking forward to seeing how this evolves and hopefully, this nudges the industry / idealistic indie devs towards more informed decisions. nice effort.