News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Short session expiration does not help security by labster on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:10PM (#37182821)
The USA was distrustful of national ID cards decades before the current level of hyperpartisan rancor. We just don’t the government enough to let them track us everywhere.

Not that the current climate helps. The REAL ID Act of 2005 has been delayed so many times, now to 2025. Maybe we should just repeal it instead.

Re:Short session expiration does not help security by xp84 on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:50PM (#37183713)
> We just don’t the government enough to let them track us everywhere.

That statement is both true and emblematic of the problem. Everyone is so cynical that a clean public-key, offline, certificate-based solution, with an absolute zero visibility to the government of who is doing what, would always be assumed to be part of some nefarious Illuminati/Democrat/Republican plot. Proving it to people with technical tests wouldn't prove it. They'll always be convinced.

What we need from the government is so minimal really, just to sign certificates if we prove our identity. But it'll never happen in the US due to the distrust situation.

Re:Short session expiration does not help security by jimmydorry on Friday August 18, 2023 @11:06PM (#37185073)
Because there has never been a proposal for a "clean public-key / offline / certificate-based solution". It's always a central database that also does x and y and will be available for w and z departments to do as they will with it.
Re:Short session expiration does not help security by xp84 on Monday August 21, 2023 @09:32PM (#37217525)
It doesn’t matter though, because the percentage of Americans who can understand public key crypto even in a vague way sufficient to critically read a technical analysis and judge it to be true, you could count on one hand. Nobody has proposed it because if any politicians have seen such a proposal on their desks, even if they themselves grasp it (unlikely), they know most Americans would freak out on principle.
Re:Short session expiration does not help security by mindslight on Saturday August 19, 2023 @01:29AM (#37185813)
Why are you talking in hypotheticals and abstract "distrust" ? We have already been suffering from existing central ID systems - social security numbers and drivers license numbers - with little hope for reform in sight. If there were something like the GDPR that prohibited companies from nonconsensually demanding, storing, or using these identifiers for anything but their bona fide governmental purposes, then it might make sense to talk about adding a new system. But until the government is capable of reigning in abuses of the existing systems, any new system of identification would inevitably be a gift to the surveillance companies.
Re:Short session expiration does not help security by sangnoir on Saturday August 19, 2023 @02:19AM (#37186088)
> The REAL ID Act of 2005 has been delayed so many times, now to 2025

Can one fly without a REAL-ID-compliant license or ID?

Re:Short session expiration does not help security by dgoldstein0 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @07:34AM (#37187720)
Yes, with a passport you can

... Probably not what you were trying to ask. I thought the deadline passed for using real ID for TSA but I haven't looked for that info in years

Re:Short session expiration does not help security by marcus0x62 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @08:04AM (#37187888)
The deadline has been pushed to May 7, 2025.
Re:Short session expiration does not help security by photonerd on Saturday August 19, 2023 @11:24AM (#37189690)
> We just don’t the government enough to let them track us everywhere.

Eh, that’s the pseudo-libertarian objection (which is… dumb as bricks, practically speaking) but the most common objection is one of access.

Until IDs are both free AND easy to obtain in the US (if you think they are, congrats: you’re in the lucky group) then a national id scheme will always be a non-starter.

IDs face the same problem voting has in recent years (and historically): the systems of power use limiting access as a tool to control those they don’t like.