Not that the current climate helps. The REAL ID Act of 2005 has been delayed so many times, now to 2025. Maybe we should just repeal it instead.
That statement is both true and emblematic of the problem. Everyone is so cynical that a clean public-key, offline, certificate-based solution, with an absolute zero visibility to the government of who is doing what, would always be assumed to be part of some nefarious Illuminati/Democrat/Republican plot. Proving it to people with technical tests wouldn't prove it. They'll always be convinced.
What we need from the government is so minimal really, just to sign certificates if we prove our identity. But it'll never happen in the US due to the distrust situation.
Can one fly without a REAL-ID-compliant license or ID?
... Probably not what you were trying to ask. I thought the deadline passed for using real ID for TSA but I haven't looked for that info in years
Eh, that’s the pseudo-libertarian objection (which is… dumb as bricks, practically speaking) but the most common objection is one of access.
Until IDs are both free AND easy to obtain in the US (if you think they are, congrats: you’re in the lucky group) then a national id scheme will always be a non-starter.
IDs face the same problem voting has in recent years (and historically): the systems of power use limiting access as a tool to control those they don’t like.
https://public.cyber.mil/pki-pke/interoperability/
Or in visual form:
https://dl.dod.cyber.mil/wp-content/uploads/pki-pke/img/fed_...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Personnel_Management...
What you want is some well-reviewed code that a bank or utility company can "apt install" onto their server and get secure decentralized web authentication working in five minutes instead of leaving them to create some custom in-house contraption designed by a rotating committee of middle managers.
And they should really endeavor to break that PKI thing into smaller, independent, less centralized pieces. It's way too big as it is. There appears to be something called "Symantec" between "Federal Bridge" and "US Senate" and then another "Symantec" between "Federal Bridge" and "Naval Reactors" -- that doesn't seem great.
Nor should they. Too much power for governments to have. Every so often some news gets posted here about some government official who just does not give a shit about people's rights, you can actually feel the contempt when you read what they say.
Government solutions are non-solutions. We should solve these problems with ubiquitous technology or not solve them at all.
Not least: they’re ignoring that simply having an identity is a traceable & trackable thing… because that would derail their paranoid fantasies where they’re a hero, fighting against a dystopian world.
I'm impressed how much Americans dislike the idea of a mandatory government issued ID. I don't mean it in a bad way - this sounds like a very principled and idealistic stance. I just really like my government issued ID, and consider it a reasonable tradeoff.
You shouldn't. I don't know if anything changed in the last few years, but having to insert your ID into a card reader is very cumbersome from a user experience perspective. Especially since the world is moving away from having to plug stuff into computers.
It seems literally infeasible for the United States to have state-issued PKI. It’s a meta-partisan issue: no side trusts the other to manage crypto or computer systems.
So for example instead of a public many-to-many digital publishing platform we are stuck with the whims of grown men who want to fist fight each other in the Colosseum and all because every X is convinced every Y is so despicable and corrupt that such a public system would be much worse than what we have now.