News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by noelwelsh on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:29AM (#37173210)
London really grew in the Victorian era. E.g. http://www.demographia.com/dm-lon31.htm

Reading Dickens is one way to get a feel for this. Many locations in his books are not yet part of the London conurbation. IIRC, one book has a character walking over fields to get to Hammersmith, for example.

Going back further there is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St_Martin-in-the-Fields

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by mytailorisrich on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:32AM (#37173755)
" Henry VIII rebuilt the church in 1542 ... at this time it was literally "in the fields", occupying an isolated position between the cities of Westminster and London."

In the 1550s the country was unrecognisable compared to now. England's total population was about 3 million, now London's population is 9 million (and was 100k then)...

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by illwrks on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:59AM (#37173948)
It makes you wonder what it will be like in another few hundred years... When we first moved to London (Zone 2/3) the place we lived in used to be a large apple orchard 100-150 years prior. Where we moved to after was on the grounds of a former nunnery then recouperation hospital. And now the area we're in used to be grazing fields 100 years ago.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by ido on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:01AM (#37173969)
It will not continue seeing such rapid growth for another few hundred years, world population will plateau by mid century and even the big cities will at some point stop growing.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by codetrotter on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:03AM (#37173988)
Why?
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by RugnirViking on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:18AM (#37174140)
birth rates in pretty much every developed nation are below replacement level. Some countries are using migration as a sort of band-aid fixed but the worst fears are starting to come true recently. Previously some people had thought or hoped that falling birthrates was/is a natural concequence of becoming rich enough, that as countries develop kids are seen as less of a necessity. But iirc newer data shows falling birthrates even in poorer nations that are stagnant/not developing. They are still well above replacement rate for now but its not a good trend.

As for reasons why: nobody has one single cause, but a major one is that current economies mean children are more of a cost than a benefit, and even the most ambitious incentive programs dont make up for the toll of both working a job and taking care of a helpless human.

As for why this is a bad thing: There are a lot of inbuilt assumptions to the way society is structured that will begin to break down. Things like: there are more workers than retirees. There are more students than teachers. There are more juior employees than managers. When these kinds of things start to change, we will have to adapt society or things will just fall apart.

You're already starting to see previews of this sort of crisis in sectors where few young people join, like becoming merchant ship captains. People having to be called back from retirement, buisnesses failing not from lack of buisness but from lack of employees

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by noelwelsh on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:39AM (#37174316)
The human population cannot grow indefinitely without moving to other planets, which is very much infeasible now and probably infeasible into the foreseeable future. Society just has to adapt. The problem I see is our current leaders are only interested in pushing the problem down the road. Declining population (which won't actually decline till 2080-ish IIRC) is not in itself a problem.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by RugnirViking on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:16AM (#37175187)
I agree. This is a transitory state, where a lot of assumption built into the social contract will break down. If we can fix them (and presumably we will... eventually), there is nothing inherently bad about a declining population.

But in the meantime things may get interesting.

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by kiba on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:34AM (#37175406)
We still have plenty of room on this planet, and upcoming medical technology may change the equation on the number of people dying.

I hope to start a family before people start imposing measure to limit population growth.

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by RugnirViking on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:56AM (#37175665)
it is extrodinarily unlikely anyone will do such as thing.

As I noted earlier. the birth rate is below replacement rate in almost all developed countries. If not for immigrants population would be shrinking. If anything they would demand more children...

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by kiba on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:12AM (#37175872)
It is because the elderly are dying, same as they always been dying through out the ages. The older you get the more likely you are to die.

The current demographic trend is based on this assumption. It goes out the window the moment we start meaningfully reducing the probability of death.

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by andsoitis on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:52AM (#37176482)
> It goes out the window the moment we start meaningfully reducing the probability of death.

What does “Meaningfully reducing the probability of death” mean?

I thought death is certain. Do you mean pushing death further into to future, say by hundreds or thousands of years?

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by kiba on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:34PM (#37179190)
The probability of death is correlated to your chronological age. The older you are, the more likely you are to die.

Eliminating or reducing the probability of death means our average lifespan is likely to be thousand of years, but not unlimited since we will die to other causes, likely involving accidents and natural disaster.

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by thatfrenchguy on Friday August 18, 2023 @11:33AM (#37177034)
Better medical technology means people die older. Older people already own most of the capital, having them live longer isn’t going to get us to a healthier society that’s not as biased towards existing capital versus innovation and income.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by kiba on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:43PM (#37179343)
And older people passing their wealth to a newer generation isn't going to fix things either. All that changes is who will be ossifying society. At least, with medical technologies, people can't run away from the problem by dying of old age.

That's a separate problem to the population crisis. People thinks population's going to decline. I am not so sure. Things can change a lot in a few decade.

All we can say that at this current time, the trend is toward population decline.

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by cma on Friday August 18, 2023 @11:06AM (#37176692)
Growing at a fixed percentage each year can never go on without growing faster than can fit in our light cone.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by kaashif on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:00AM (#37175025)
But smaller developed countries can turn on the immigration taps a bit and continue population growth even as world population drastically shrinks.

This won't work forever, but it may buy a century or so.

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by throwaway03626 on Friday August 18, 2023 @11:45AM (#37177249)
In my opinion it could be solved by simply making it more attractive to have children, but it would require more equality and redistribution of wealth to cover the costs. There would still be billionaires, but the number of ultra-rich may be reduced.

Women wants careers and equal opportunities. That means they wait longer and longer before they get children because they want to make sure they have a career to go back to. That is the single most important problem that we need to solve.

1. Provide a decent parental leave (1 year minimum) with full pay.

2. Women often end up as the primary care giver who has to take care of the child when it is sick or attend parental meetings. This often hurts their career. We should incentivise men to take an equal part in raising a child, so that this is more accepted in work situations.

3. Provide free child care and health care. Many simply can't afford the additional financial burden of a child.

4. Provide free education including University. (see point 3)

5. Reduce the financial risk by creating a good safety net. If one or both of the parents are not able to cover their part, the government needs to provide enough support.

Simply put, the choice of having a child should not hurt families financially, or hurt their careers. Humans are "programmed" to want to reproduce, so if we remove the financial barriers

Yes, this will be expensive but it will be less expensive than a future without enough young people to take care of the old.

You are free to ask "Why should my money go to others", but then you don't get to complain when you are 90 years old and only get to shower once a month because they don't have enough people to help you.

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by vidarh on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:46PM (#37182584)
Norway is close to providing all of what you describe and still seeing well below replacement fertility rates. It maybe be a start, and it produces a far more pleasant society, but it's not enough.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by throwaway03626 on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:57PM (#37184271)
There are other concerns as well related to cost of living.

Even though we would like people to live outside the cities, cities attract a lot of potential parents. They end up in a situation where they have a long education and start their careers late and don't have the financial capability to get a decent family friendly apartment in the city. Many wait until it's almost too late, and having more than 1 or 2 is definitely not something most wants

The average age of first-time mothers is over 30 years old. A single child may be something the family can handle, but more than 1 or 2 forces the families to move outside the cities to be able to afford a house in addition to hurting the mother's career.

Tldr:

- Cost of living in the cities are too high

- If a second (or third) child forces them to move out of the city, many increasingly choose the cities

- Having more than one child after 30 will have a negative impact on the career as they simply can't work as many hours and has to spend long periods away from work

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by vidarh on Saturday August 19, 2023 @02:38AM (#37186175)
I think you can simplify that: Standards rise as living standards rise. People want more both for themselves and their children when they see that as realistic, and opting for fewer children is a way to make that happen.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by throwaway03626 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @03:41AM (#37186477)
Yes, I think that covers everything in a concise way.

If we want to go back to a sustainable birth rate, we need a wide range of actions. Some may require to reduce the financial risks, while others require encouraging cultural changes.

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by ido on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:06AM (#37174031)
Because birth rates are going down worldwide and at some point the people who wanted to move away from the countryside/poor countries to the big global cities would have already moved (those left behind are older than the ones leaving, so such places will have even lower birth rates).

The major global cities will still grow in the next 200 years compared to now, just not as much as they have the previous 200 years.

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by smugma on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:36AM (#37176231)
Inner London population peaked over 100 years ago.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by snapplebobapple on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:00PM (#37177556)
You see thus in most of paris as well. Population in 1860 was 4 to 5 times what it is today in the same area.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by ido on Saturday August 19, 2023 @01:21AM (#37185777)
But the "suburbs" (some of them would not be considered suburbs but simply outer parts of the city in a lot of other places in the world) are immensely more populous than 100 years ago.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by Cullinet on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:35AM (#37174285)
I was shocked the other day by seeing a physical travelcard ticket for Zones 1-9 and having to confirm from a Tube station map that a Zone 9 actually exists. This is four more than I could remember.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by illwrks on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:42AM (#37174340)
To be fair I didn't know that either... For some reason I thought 7 was the last zone... 13 years here (almost to the day) and I've learned something new !
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by Symbiote on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:49AM (#37174393)
Long ago when I moved to London, it was zones 1-6 then A-D for stations outside Greater London. I think changing A-D to 7, 8 & 9 made it simpler; most people aren't interested in what the local government is when they buy a ticket.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by darrenf on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:26AM (#37175302)
Zone 5 was split into two back in 1991.

Zones beyond 6 have existed since at least the late 90s. My vague recollection is that A-C basically meant "the top end of the Metropolitan line" - certainly how it seemed for me as an SW Londoner. Then at some point the letters were changed to numbers and more stations were brought inside over in Essex, Kent, etc. The Wikipedia page for stations in zones 7-9 has a changelog of sorts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_stations_in_London_far...

Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by mprovost on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:36AM (#37175431)
This post really highlights how much of the development in London is infill into already existing Victorian (or earlier) neighbourhoods and how the city is growing without sprawling outwards. The Victorians built the Metropolitan line out almost all the way to Aylesbury anticipating that the city would follow but it really hasn't. When you take the tube to zone 9 you start to go past horses and cows in fields. There are some really nice walks in the Chiltern hills starting from Chesham and Amersham and you don't feel like you're in London at all. We always wonder if people living there even consider themselves as Londoners.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by briansm on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:18PM (#37178915)
Atlantis.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by Cullinet on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:33AM (#37174270)
As far as I can recall the population of the UK has hovered around 55 million since the early 80s at least, but this number doesn't seem to make sense to me. I'm reminded of a March 2020 London Evening Standard headline saying that half of the adult population of the UK had been vaccinated and the headline gave 55 million people as the total for that number, which gave me pause for thought.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by leoedin on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:20AM (#37174643)
The UK population is 67 million today - and has been growing consistently year on year since the early 00's. It did hover around 55-58 million between 1970 and 2000 though.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by flangola7 on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:58PM (#37182019)
There are no wolves in England at all?
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by leoedin on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:03AM (#37175065)
The number of houses built in the 1870-1900 period is mad - basically a 3 mile wide ring around London. It's really impressive - especially considering all building materials had to be brought in by railway and then horse and cart.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by southernplaces7 on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:29AM (#37176143)
Interesting to note how London's population peaked in 1939, before falling steadily after that right up to the 1980's, when it finally started to rise again into the present day. A similar thing also happened to New York City in roughly the same time frame.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by dylan604 on Friday August 18, 2023 @11:48AM (#37177312)
I mean, nothing really happened shortly after 1939 that made people flee London, right?
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by southernplaces7 on Sunday August 20, 2023 @06:51PM (#37203692)
Sure, the war, the Blitz, etc. but those weren't the main causes. The regrowth in population took decades even after the war ended. NYC never got bombed, but it went through nearly the same thing during the same time frame.
Re:London Then and Now: Aerial Shots Show City Grow over Pas... by n1c on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:53AM (#37176501)
Wow, 1 million people lived in London in the 1800s!

Are there any good books / content on what day to day life was like for people in those times in London specifically?