Is the rancher emitting or the hamburger consumer. Is the plane passenger emitting, or a shareholder. Ect
> cattle ranchers
The fact that you think these two things go together really highlights how blinded by ideology you are.
apologies if you are joking too
> In time, the term has come to be identified as any deliberate distortion of scientific facts or theories for purposes that are deemed politically or socially desirable.
There are two ways to account for emissions and this study uses the wrong one. The first, the one that is produces the quote about how a few companies produce all the emissions, attributes emissions to the producer. The second attributes them to the consumer because they consume the energy.
The CO2 from gallon of gas isn't made by Exxon (excluding all the production) but from burning it in my car. The CO2 for electricity is produced at the plant but it is being used in my AC.
However, if you read Dr. Starr's self-description I suspect there's a specific narrative he's looking for:
"My research analyzes how economic inequality – particularly at the very top of the income distribution – shapes the distribution of environmental benefits and harms through the global economy." (https://www.jaredstarr.com/about)
I'm not saying you can't criticize the 1% for being massively wasteful consumers, it's entirely legitimate to criticize them. But as most consumption is by the 99%, the companies owned by the 1% mainly serve the consumption of the masses, not of the 1%.
Starr and his colleagues analyzed income data across U.S. households from 1990 to 2019 and linked it to emissions generated directly and indirectly from that income. They included income tied to emissions related to the operation of a business, such as from a coal-fired power plant. But they also included income, such as from investments, that supported services or products from those industries.
“As you move up the income ladder, an increasing share of emissions is associated with investments,” said Starr
So this reads almost like an implicit tautology, if I can phrase it like that. Basically, investments are tied to climate emissions -> wealthier people have more of these (because wealth is defined this way, hence tautology) -> wealthy are tied to carbon emissions.
Not useful. I was hoping to read about air travel or large homes or such.