News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by FrustratedMonky on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:09PM (#37155092)
If a human reads something, it goes into their brain, and it becomes an influence on future works they produce.

This doesn't mean that 'copywrite' extends into my brain. A company can't copywrite what I'm thinking about. And what if I do try to paraphrase something from memory, from a few sources, and happen to spit out a very similar sentence from memory. Am I breaking the law?

To go further. Since all knowledge is pretty much fed into a human from hundreds of books, movies, TV, internet, all pumped into a human from birth. Then everything in the brain is a product of something with a copywrite. So anything produced is some amalgamation of copywrites.

Why not use similar argument for AI. It is clear when asking it to do something like "write a screen play for Othello using dialog like Tarantino, but with bit of style like Baz Luhrmann". That what it produces is 'as unique as a human' would be, or just as filled with things that have copywrites.

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by nullindividual on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:13PM (#37155120)
> Am I breaking the law?

The intent of [US] copyright law is to promote new works of art (which can be derivative). So copyright did exactly what it is supposed to do in your analogy. Plus, you're human, which gives you special rights that software doesn't posses.

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by FrustratedMonky on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:24PM (#37155207)
But. I am allowed to at least read the copywritten material, from which it goes into my brain to become mixed up with everything else, and spit out to produce something 'new' or 'newish'.

Some of these lawsuits are trying to prevent the AI from even 'reading' the material. It can't even be used as an influence.

Wouldn't it be better to treat the products of the AI with the same laws as humans. If the new 'product' is 'too close' to something existing, then they get sued. Just like a musician that has a song with a few notes that sound a little too close to someone's song from 30 years ago gets sued. The songwriter was allowed to listen to the music, it went into their brain and became an influence. If that influence becomes too great, then it can be sued.

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by throwaway3618 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:40PM (#37155334)
Seems copyright works in part because of the effort involved in producing something that's similar to something else. You can't just copy and it takes effort to make something different enough, that gives the original a bit of a "moat".

If you take away enough of that effort, the investment in new stuff becomes unviable, perhaps.

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by FrustratedMonky on Thursday August 17, 2023 @12:58PM (#37164701)
Agree. I think the 'effort' reduction is the real difference that makes AI products different from human products.

Though this seems different issue from copywrite .

Like, we see that this can impact society, so we need some new laws to guard this.

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by lokar on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:37PM (#37155318)
Why would that be better? You seems to assume that because these models have some utility to their creators they should be allowed, even when they have negative utility to others who’s work they consume. Why should that be true?
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by nullindividual on Thursday August 17, 2023 @08:54AM (#37160831)
> I am allowed to at least read the copywritten material, from which it goes into my brain to become mixed up with everything else, and spit out to produce something 'new' or 'newish'.

Yes, because you're A) human and B) that is how copyright is supposed to work.

AI doesn't enjoy the rights of people. AI is a "talking book" and copying, storing, then repeating someone else's work from your talking book would (likely) run afoul of [US] copyright law.

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by alickz on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:08AM (#37174534)
I don't think there's been a tool in the history of mankind with such potential for new works of art than AI tools
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by staticman2 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:26PM (#37155225)
"If a human reads something, it goes into their brain"

Humans aren't property. LLM models are. So the comparison is irrelevant and I'll stop you right there.

Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by BudaDude on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:35PM (#37155303)
When you think about it like that, if LLM's are based on the human brain, did we basically reinvent slavery?
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by throwaway3618 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:41PM (#37155348)
Not just for the LLMs
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by BudaDude on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:50PM (#37155424)
True, any neural network. This is a very grey area and rushing to call it "property" ignores what the technology is emulating.
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by nonameiguess on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @07:38PM (#37155320)
> And what if I do try to paraphrase something from memory, from a few sources, and happen to spit out a very similar sentence from memory. Am I breaking the law?

If you're doing this for a commercial purpose, yes. Recording artists have been successfully sued for accidentally reusing a melody they claim to not remember ever hearing, provided it really does sound sufficiently similar to the original.