My ex-wife was a US air traffic controller, and the training they go through is stunning. They're tested continuously for years, with something like an 80% wash-out rate.
During testing, they get 1-2 tests per week, working a shift just like a controller would, with fake pilots on the radio, and real computer systems. If they let airplanes get even remotely close to each other, they fail. If it happens twice, they're out of the FAA, immediately, permanently. One of the instructors told me, "It's my job to make sure your wife has the worst week of her career, every week, during training - so that when she's actually on the job, every week will seem easy no matter what she's facing."
Even just in training, you could see the stress take its toll on the candidates over the years.
Hmm.. Are there incidents that were caused by Controller's error? (most common seem to be equipment failures, pilot errors, bad weather and bad luck with bird strikes etc.)
There is a nice wikipedia list here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Aviation_accidents_an...
Of course I don't think it is correct to say that an incident were caused by controller error. It makes it sound like a single controller error was the only thing which went wrong. It is probably more correct to say that controller error contributed to the outcome of some incident.
Like many others (I am sure) I read the comments first and read article later (if I read).
I was responding to the informative comment about the rigorousness of Controller training. As a nervous flier myself, that made me feel a bit better.
It's actually probably not as amazing as it seems. I was just on a high ropes course, and it's similar to ATC in that if things go pear-shaped, there is just nothing that you can do. So when I saw something going wrong [1], the instinct I had to immediately run and try to help was suppressed, and instead I (and everybody else) was essentially in the same calm-and-collected mood.
[1] Admittedly, this is wrong in the "abnormal operation" sense, not "immediate risk to life" sense.
You drill for emergency situations during training, and you should drill repeatedly afterwards. Any ATP rated pilots do so regularly whether in actual flight or in simulators.
But one flight very early, before I had my pilot's license, flying on a student's permit.. I ran out of fuel during cruise flight.. It was dumb, it was a case of me being a poor just-out-of-college student, and trying to do some very risky calculus with the flight planning and fuel required. There were extenuating factors including the (small) plane's fuel gauges malfunctioning sporadically .. having to 'stick the tank' on the ground (measure the fuel in the plane's wings by using a ruler and chart for how many inches equaled gallons).
.. excuses aside. I ran out of gas at 8000 feet above Columbus Georgia ..
What I remember happening is the engine abruptly lurching, then stopping, sending a massive amount of adrenaline through me.
But almost immediately I started looking for a runway to land at. I knew I had at least 1, maybe 2 airports in range of a glide, and one was relatively in front of me, so I decided on it, and called ATC in Atlanta who were following my flight at that time & declared a 'pan-pan' (step below a mayday .. meaning you have a serious situation on board & require priority attention if available, but you are still in control of the aircraft). They confirmed the vector to the (abandoned, but still in decent condition) airport a few miles in front of me.
Now.. Your original question is probably answered at this point... Basically as long as you can continue to have things to do .. As long as you can envision and work toward a goal (landing the f'n plane safely) .. The stress of the situation tends to just fuel the focus on getting to that goal.
I can't say its going to be the same for every pilot, and maybe it isn't . I did grow up obsessed with flying (after being absolutely horrified by it as a child), and so I had kind of gone over in my mind and in training over and over again this potential type of situation occurring and I wasn't about to let the moment get to big.
This kind of thing does worry me a little bit with our recent explosive need for pilots as commercial aviation expands rapidly. A lot of pilots are going through "0 to ATP" courses to get a good paying job, rather than because they're actually obsessed with flying itself.. Because in those cases, I'm not sure what is going to happen psychologically for those pilots. Again though, this is why you are constantly drilled and trained on these situations, so that you have almost muscle-memory of things to be doing in an emergency situation so that there is no time for you to sit passively and become a victim of circumstance.
Are those "0 to ATP" graduates landing quality jobs? Has pay at the smaller regionals actually moved up into "good paying" ranges (used to be $20-$40k/year starting, and that's usually after $50k+ in tuition/fees to get first set of pilot credentials)?
Last time I checked (10+ years ago), landing a job at a major airline still required years of experience at a regional OR some special combination of degree/networking/military service. And the regionals didn't pay well and had pretty crap working conditions (getting better post-Colgan Air crash, but still not great).
I see United has an in-house "0 to ATP" program now, but it's still more than $70k and a few years to graduate, and then the pilot still spends time at a regional United-affiliate before having the chance to move to United itself.
Really just curious what conditions are like for new pilots today (vs roughly the Colgan Air disaster era). And what the pipeline looks like post-COVID.
- "not an emergency" https://www.youtube.com/shorts/bugknVx5NZ0
- "delta 1943, cancel takeoff clearance" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mIiPt1YVkP8&t=581s
disclaimer: I might be talking out my ass
It really seems that crisis response is bimodal. Either you almost completely panic, or you're almost completely focused. Complete focus makes for very clear, focused communication. (Extensive training on procedures, communication, and not panicking certainly helps as well.)
A few things that always stand out to me... - the calm demeanor shown by both ATC and pilots. Even in situations that make me cringe sitting at my laptop, everybody involved is steady. I know it's their job, but it still amazes me.
- the complexity of airport operations at a major international is mind-boggling. Hand-offs from ground to tower to departure... and then back again if something goes wrong. And doing that for dozens of planes at a time. Some crewed by pilots with thick accents or static-y radios.
- that air travel is the safest form of transit given the complexity of engineering and human processes involved is truly astounding. I know today's successes are the result of all previous tragedies; it's still something else.
I live under the main international approach to IAD. Watching the heavies fly in makes me smile. Especially the A380. It's a shame the A380 didn't find a long-term market - looking up, it shouldn't be able to fly, but there it is.