News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by tptacek on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:45PM (#37094443)
What's there to believe? Standards follow implementations. The W3C aren't the browser police; they just standardize the interoperable things browsers do.

It's not W3C's (or WhatWG's) role to "oppose" random things browser vendors decide to do.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by wackget on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:02PM (#37094612)
> It's not W3C's (or WhatWG's) role to "oppose" random things browser vendors decide to do.

Then why are they making standards in the first place?

They're already deeply involved in the operation of browsers; they are practically morally obliged to object to things which could harm the Web.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by shadowgovt on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:15PM (#37094722)
For the same reason people write dictionaries.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by 9dev on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:37PM (#37094889)
Im not sure whether that example supports your point. The Oxford dictionary is essentially an authority on spelling, and their editors and councils definitely have weight in debates on the proper spelling of things.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by hangonhn on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:49PM (#37094993)
Wait. No. The OED is descriptive of English (UK only?) but is not prescriptive. They don't tell people what to spell or what they need to mean. They describe the spelling and meaning as it is being done. This is why there are new words that get added every year. It's not as if OED sit around and think of new words.

I'm not arguing if the OP is right or not but I don't think the OED example is correct.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by umanwizard on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:55PM (#37095065)
The OED is definitely not UK only.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by jonathankoren on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:49PM (#37094999)
It’s just a bad example. The Oxford Dictionary is just a publication of Oxford University Press. A popular one perhaps, but fundamentally no different than a Webster’s, or even say a Random House. Even giving it authority as a speller is suspect, since as an American, I can say with confidence that Oxford doesn’t know how to spell.

A better example would be a language academy, however English has never had a language academy, unlike French or Spanish, resulting in it being a stubbornly descriptivist, rather than prescriptivist phenomenon.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by seabass-labrax on Friday August 11, 2023 @07:02PM (#37095113)
> Even giving it authority as a speller is suspect, since as an American, I can say with confidence that Oxford doesn’t know how to spell.

I had to give a chuckle at that, but seriously, the way in which words are spelt (ahem) in the OED is genuinely interesting! They use both -ize and -ise, for instance, choosing one or the other based on each individual word's etymology.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by jonathankoren on Friday August 11, 2023 @07:17PM (#37095194)
I recently saw an author on social media remarking that their editor complained that they were mixing American and British spellings, and they should just pick one. The author was confused by the statement, because they didn’t there was anything unusual going on. Then the penny dropped. They’re Canadian.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by dragonwriter on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:52PM (#37095030)
> Even giving it authority as a speller is suspect, since as an American, I can say with confidence that Oxford doesn’t know how to spell.

The OED, in my experience, covers the varieties of English spelling quite well, and if you want no distractions as an American but can deal with less extravagantly complete coveraged, you can always use the OAD.

Oxford seems to know how to spell quite well.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by andrewjl on Sunday August 13, 2023 @01:55PM (#37112305)
OAD is no longer in print and has been superseded by the New Oxford American Dictionary (NOAD).
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by umanwizard on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:37PM (#37096441)
> I can say with confidence that Oxford doesn’t know how to spell

The OED includes American spellings for all of its entries.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by umanwizard on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:53PM (#37095038)
That’s not really true. The OED is a historical/scientific work. Its goal is to describe the English language, not to influence it. Things are not described as proper or improper in the OED, though they may of course be described as colloquially, nonstandard, regional, etc., which are not value judgments. A lot of words, especially the ones that have been around for a while, have absolutely tons of variant spellings listed, most of which a normal literate modern person has never heard of.

Source: I have an OED subscription and look at it regularly.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by karaterobot on Friday August 11, 2023 @07:13PM (#37095173)
> Then why are they making standards in the first place?

For one thing, membership in W3C is loaded with representatives from those browser vendors. Which is a good thing, since W3C would be absolutely useless if browser vendors weren't there.

For another, standards aren't the place for rants about who sucks shit and who doesn't. It would be a fun read, but a bad standard. A standard is for saying what you must do, not for saying who sucks shit.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by flangola7 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:47AM (#37097683)
Your statement about standards is not truthful.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by karaterobot on Saturday August 12, 2023 @09:29AM (#37099956)
Thanks for your comment
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by colordrops on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:52PM (#37094514)
Maybe it should be their role. Arguably, things like browser standards are as important to society as electrical or network standards.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by PaulHoule on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:59PM (#37094567)
I wrote postal letters to the FTC, the president, my senators and congressman telling them to investigate WEI as another monopoly move on the part of Google and highlighted that the FBI says you should use an ad blocker.

You should too.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by tptacek on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:01PM (#37094594)
The letter to the FTC might do something, in a statistical sense, if they're already tracking the correspondence they're getting because this issue is in their purview. The other letters are a waste of paper and ink.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by PaulHoule on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:22PM (#37094781)
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by tptacek on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:59PM (#37094569)
It can't be their role. Standard organizations enjoy no de jure authority at all. The most they could possibly do is certify all the other "complying" browsers as "W3C-approved", and nobody cares who doesn't already care about the particulars here.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by bawolff on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:40PM (#37094918)
shudders in xhtml
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by TheAceOfHearts on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:34PM (#37094865)
The W3C had their chance in the early 2000s and they hyperfixated on XML nonsense while browser and web evolution stagnated. I'm not saying that the status quo is perfect, but if we want W3C to try again then we should make sure we don't run into the same issues 20 years ago.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by Qwertious on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:51PM (#37096857)
And here I thought web evolution stagnated in the early 2000s due to IE6. It's vital we don't get locked into a single dominant browser that ignores open standards whenever it's convenient to them.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by TheAceOfHearts on Saturday August 12, 2023 @01:56AM (#37097421)
The web's stagnation was not monocausal. IE6 was bad, but W3C wasn't doing anything to help beyond fixating on XML work that never went anywhere.

I agree we shouldn't let a single web browser dominate. I'm just saying that the W3C doesn't have any power to do so nor have they shown themselves capable of pulling it off.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by Analemma_ on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:00PM (#37094585)
Maybe, but it's a moot point, because there's no way to get from here to there. If the browser vendors want to add a standard, they will; and if they don't, they won't. On one or two prior occasions the W3C has proposed something that the browser makers didn't like, they unanimously told the W3C to go pound sand, and that was the end of it.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by wnevets on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:02PM (#37094609)
> Maybe it should be their role.

Who would grant them such a authority and how would it be enforced?

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by tedunangst on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:43PM (#37094937)
Can't wait for the FBI to bash in my door for running curl because it fails to meet established legal criteria for browser operation.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by Semaphor on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:01PM (#37094593)
But then you’d also need a world police who enforces that.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by colordrops on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:37PM (#37094887)
Who enforces electrical and network standards? Those don't require world police.
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by KRAKRISMOTT on Friday August 11, 2023 @07:51PM (#37095436)
> Who enforces electrical and network standards? Those don't require world police.

Most blocs have their own standards. Commonwealth countries follow one standard, EU countries another, North American engineering standards are not the same as Japanese ones.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by btown on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:49PM (#37094994)
The W3C's draft vision statement [0] clearly states:

> Aim to reduce centralization in Web architecture, minimizing single points of failure and single points of control.

IMO it is entirely in scope for, and part of the responsibility of, the W3C to introduce a specification that explicitly forbids user agents from implementing Web Environment Integrity or any similar system as currently drafted.

One might say that the members' conflicts of interest make it likely that they will abdicate this responsibility, but that doesn't make it any less their role!

[0] https://www.w3.org/TR/w3c-vision/#principles

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by toast0 on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:16PM (#37096316)
They don't have power to enforce specificiations, so what's the point of a negative specification?
Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by JeremyNT on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:22PM (#37096695)
It's a signal if nothing else.

Maybe Google cares, maybe not, but there's no sense in having a spineless standards body that just turns around and says that the spec is whatever Google implements in Chrome.

Re:Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; underst... by tptacek on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:46AM (#37101346)
The W3C has no ability to "forbid" anything. You're going to find professional organizations resistant to undertakings that beclown themselves. W3C's statute and importance is improved when they publish things that the industry implements. That is the only mechanism they have to find impact. They are not the Internet police. I know this is fuzzy-seeming because of all the "MUST NOT"'s in standards language, but it's not really fuzzy at all.