https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/are-the-laws-of-physic...
I wonder if this is the case at the “bounds” of the universe or why there are so many inverse or at least non-linear relationships between various forces. My thought is that you can’t get outside the universe, because space becomes warped in the sense that a short distance is extraordinarily “long”.
The problem with any discussion about these kinds of things is that there is zero information actually being exchanged. Our brains have several assumptions built in, like a concept of time. "Going outside the universe" is not something that can rigorously be discussed because "outside" probably isn't even something defineable """outside""" our """universe""". Hell, even the concept of "defining" something is entirely a starting assumption.
It's like asking "what happened before the big bang?", well, "happened" is not something that even can be defined "before" the big bang. None of our definitions of ANYTHING can EVER make sense outside of our reality, or one that is nearly identical to it. Even "reality" is a definition that presupposes itself.
Essentially, it's a malformed question, like "What time is blue?", there's no way to turn such a question into a meaningful evaluation.
In other words, the outside universe has moved on 200 billion years from the point of history that our "diorama" re-creates.
Earth is one of hundreds of "ancient cores" that proved significant in the eventual development of a cosmic civilization, and in honor of our legacy, we are semi-faithfully (plenty of creative license!) re-created in an artificial bubble complete with its own legacy physics (because of course physics evolves over time as well!).
So we're one of many "attractions" in a vast "theme park" that is mostly used for historical scholarship, sightseeing and alien tourism. Yay!
And how can we really know what's going on out there from so far away?
Why did we need to invent the 'darknesses', and reschedule the big bang, if it's really just the same as here, and we understand it so well?
They are. One parameter, for instance, is the strength of the electromagnetic field at your location. Another is the sum force of gravity acting on you. Another parameter is your current acceleration.
The point being: that doesn't help you actually explain anything. Okay, great, that's why far off galaxies are moving too fast; they have different parameters that are making them do that. Can we actually figure out what that parameter is? Let's come up with a name for it so we can actually discuss the same thing. Let's call it, oh, I don't know, "dark energy".
Sure, the speed of light, or the permittivity of vacuum, could totally be different somewhere else. We have no evidence for that and it doesn't really help us explain anything, but if it did, then great: we figure out how that new parameter behaves and varies, which will inevitably involve something else that is constant, and then that constant becomes part of our new theory. And then someone on Hacker News comes along and says "why are we just assuming that that constant is the same everywhere? Maybe other corners of the universe have different physics! Checkmate physicists!"
It reminds me of the creationists who endlessly argue about "missing links" in evolution despite us filling in Earth's evolutionary history more and more every year. There's no insight here, you're just moving the goalposts around.
> We don't even have words for those meta-forces and meta-meta-forces, (maybe like, derivatives of derivatives).
It's called "jounce", actually.
Our corner of the universe has particular physics, but other places have other physics.
That's why far off galaxies are moving too fast, and why there seems to be not enough matter and energy to explain distant gravitational effects.
There could be multiple layers of parameterization before "what we know as physics" falls out. The stuff behind what we know as physics? We don't even have words for those meta-forces and meta-meta-forces, (maybe like, derivatives of derivatives).
And what if it's not just a "linear scale" where other places have the same forces, but with different "strengths", but other places in our universe have a completely different set of forces and laws.
What if aliens just found a way to "bring a bubble of their own physics" into our little corner? That's why it seems so inexplicable to us, because it's literally alien physics.