News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by alexfromapex on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:39AM (#37089189)
The strangest part of modern physics to me is how inaccessible the concepts are. The terminology and ontology are extremely complex and it seems no one has a grasp of the fundamentals like what actually is a photon and what medium is present in a vacuum that allows things like gravity to propagate?
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by tines on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:48AM (#37089280)
The medium for gravity is spacetime, as gravity is not a force but instead just a deformation of spacetime. A photon is an excitation of the EM field.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by RajT88 on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:47AM (#37090044)
This was what I was taught in high school.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by svachalek on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:18PM (#37090438)
This is the definition in relativity. They haven't been able to make that idea work in quantum physics, despite it explaining practically everything else, so one theory or the other needs an adjustment.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by contravariant on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:01PM (#37090961)
My hot take is that they haven't quite been able to make it work for quantum physics either, they just got lucky that their makeshift solution works provided things don't couple together too tightly.

Also quantum field theory seems be just plain bad at explaining classical phenomena, which dominate general relativity. To me at least it seems quite difficult to describe a basic electromagnetic from the QFT, other than pointing at the Lagrangian in the path integral and saying something about how contributions outside its extremum will cancel out. Though perhaps I'm simply missing some trick here.

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by tux3 on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:48AM (#37089287)
>what actually is a photon

It depends what answer you're looking for! We can tell you how photons behave, how to recognize them, and how to predict what they do. For hard philosophy questions, that's more under sections 100-119 of the Dewey Decimal than something physics aims to answer

>what medium is present in a vacuum that allows things like gravity to propagate

That's a little like asking who is in charge of pushing the sun around the Earth. There's a presupposition in that question, you should first ask why you expect there to be a medium, besides nondescript vacuum

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by lacy_tinpot on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:17AM (#37089649)
Isn't a "medium" necessary to establish some kind of causality? Medium just means the means by which objects interact with each other.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by tux3 on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:28AM (#37089798)
There's different ways to interpret what people expect there to be by an extra medium on top of the vacuum.

We can observe and describe stuff interacting. The stuff is positioned in space. We can see that some stuff takes up space, and it can move to take up some other space. What we describe interacting is the stuff itself, the space around it is where it is.

Throw an apple through the air, and you can watch it sail through that medium. Remove the air, put it in vacuum, the apple is still able to move around despite the lack of anything meta or extra besides the apple and where the apple is.

The story is similar with light, gravity, other phenomenon. Things have some particular location in space, and that location can evolve with time.

You can still try to define the word, pick something within that description and call it a medium if you like, but it's not fundamentally necessary. And it won't be something "present in a vacuum that allows things like gravity to propagate". Things propagates on their own, their location within space simply evolves.

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by cheschire on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:11PM (#37090338)
Would spacetime be the medium? Or is spacetime just the language to describe the medium? Again, presupposing there must be a medium.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by lacy_tinpot on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:11PM (#37090340)
I think the confusion here is "in space", maybe you can expand on that. Is space itself not the medium? Localization is precisely what prevents backwards causality and is at the basis of relativity, where spacetime is invariant. And from what I understand that's also the source of conflict in the quantum world where that's not necessarily the case, retrocausality is entirely possible, spooky interactions at a distance are entirely possible.

Like the problem of gravity is described by the curvature of spacetime. Does spacetime "exist"? If not it's just a tool, and not an actual observation that maps onto reality. In other words we don't know how gravity actually "works" and interacts or what "spacetime" is, if it is a thing, regardless of how powerful the description is. The description is just a mathematical tool that is very useful, but that's just about it.

"You can still try to define the word, pick something within that description and call it a medium if you like"

Yes... that's how language works. "Spacetime" is mapped onto something. Language is a medium of communication. Spacetime is a medium of interaction/causality. Whether such things "exist" is an epistemic discussion or a discussion for experimentalists. But any medium is just the means by which something occurs or happens. So what is the means by which gravity "happens", or exerts influence on other bodies if not the curvature of "spacetime", which itself hasn't really been established. Does gravity just magically happen?

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by tux3 on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:57PM (#37090916)
>I think the confusion here is "in space", maybe you can expand on that. Is space itself not the medium?

I think using that definition is fine! I tried to talk about things positioned in space directly instead of using a notion of medium because that word comes with a lot of imagery, and it can make discussion difficult, it's easy to talk past each other when we start using words that don't have a very well settled definition

I was originally responding to a formulation where the medium is defined as something "present in a vacuum" that allows propagation of things. This is where imprecise language creates trouble, and why I don't like that word. You can say space is the medium, but you can't say space is a thing present in the vacuum that allows propagation. Vacuum is located in space, there's not a very meaningful sense in which space is a medium found within vacuum that helps things propagate, or at least that definition of the word is not very helpful to my understanding of the world

For gravity, I'm okay with calling spacetime the medium, as long as you're careful to not imagine that there's some more ethereal thing within the vacuum that physics doesn't say anything about

>But any medium is just the means by which something occurs or happens

That's fine. That's not an invalid definition. I just think it's important to separate the concept of a physical medium from more philosophical notions that everything happens in a medium, even if that sometimes means defining the word medium as an immaterial concept whose existence makes people question the definition of the word "exist".

In response to the original post, that definition of a medium inside the vacuum is something that doesn't exist. With your definition of space as the medium for gravity, you can make that work, as long as you can communicate what you really mean to other people when using that particular word!

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by denton-scratch on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:38PM (#37091466)
> For gravity, I'm okay with calling spacetime the medium

I thought spacetime was supposed to be identical with the gravitational field. It can't be gravity's "medium" if that medium is itself gravity.

I find this extremely hard to think about; gravity both generates spacetime, and warps it. It's really hard to escape from the earthman's experience of space as a sort of instantaneous volume; we don't really experience time at all, except in the sense that we have a sense of certain events as being not the present (i.e. the past). We know that time exists in some sense; but all we experience of spacetime is the space bit.

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by Chris2048 on Friday August 11, 2023 @02:07PM (#37091849)
> Things have some particular location in space

but then, according to the Uncertainty principle, it has a less particular momentum..

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by BobbyJo on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:21AM (#37089715)
Not to mention that there is vacuum energy, which to me (total layman) would indicate that not only is there a medium, but it also has its own influences on the objects within it (like generating Hawking radiation from black hole horizons).
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by godojo on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:31AM (#37089823)
String Theory tries to say that.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by roywiggins on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:13PM (#37090371)
In quantum field theory, space is just full of various fields that mediate interactions.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by joquarky on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:13PM (#37090380)
Sabine Hossenfelder has a video which may be helpful [0].

She discusses nine levels of what we could call "nothing" as in "there is nothing present in this container". It may be useful since she discusses the various substrates that are still present even in what we might normally think of as a "vacuum"

[0]: What is "Nothing"? https://youtu.be/PhfqdBk8qxk

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by layer8 on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:42PM (#37090742)
There is no causality in the fundamental ontology of physics. There are only physical laws (which incidentally are time-reversible), and what they imply logically. Causality is an emergent phenomenon, or an interpretation we apply at a higher level.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by CuriouslyC on Friday August 11, 2023 @10:53AM (#37089347)
This is because physicists have mathematical models, then try to generate conceptual models based on those which is like trying to describe language to someone by describing the architecture and weights of a LLM.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by piyh on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:00AM (#37089454)
Except for Hawking
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by wongarsu on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:39PM (#37091486)
Not sure if Hawking's method was so different, but he indeed was a great science communicator, on top of being a great scientist.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by unsupp0rted on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:08AM (#37089554)
The ideas of dark matter and dark energy seems obviously made-up. If a junior dev came to you with that sort of theory for a weird effect they encountered in a system, you'd tell them to look harder instead of making up new fundamental interactions.

They may turn out to be right, but you have to admit they sound arbitrarily made-up for lack of a better understanding.

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by SAI_Peregrinus on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:36AM (#37089900)
"Dark Matter" and "Dark Energy" are both names for observed effects. They're not specific theories. E.g. MOND is a theory to explain dark matter without needing a new particle or field. It doesn't explain as much as λCDM, but what it does explain it does without new fields. That's aesthetically pleasing to some people.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by post-it on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:36AM (#37089899)
> The ideas of dark matter and dark energy seems obviously made-up. If a junior dev came to you with that sort of theory for a weird effect they encountered in a system, you'd tell them to look harder instead of making up new fundamental interactions.

Well, yeah. Dark matter and dark energy are the bug ticket names, so to speak. Thousands of physicists are coming up with ways to "look harder."

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by senttoschool on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:18AM (#37089674)
That's the totally wrong analogy.

Dark matter and dark energy are just placeholder names for something we don't understand and don't know what it is. We didn't make them up. We just observe the effects and conclude that there must be something there that is making the universe behave the way it does.

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by BobbyJo on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:26AM (#37089773)
> Dark matter and dark energy are just placeholder names for something we don't understand and don't know what it is.

Mostly, but they have a lot of behaviors attached to them at this point due to various measurements and accompanying assumptions. Not to mention that labeling the sets of interactions each exhibit with a single name creates the appearance to the public that they are created by a single source. Dark Matter could be several different things interacting, likewise for Dark Energy.

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by wongarsu on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:43PM (#37091546)
The names also suggest that Dark Matter is matter, and Dark Energy, while there are still scientists that try to find other ways to explain the data (tweaking gravity etc).

But you have to name them something to talk about them. There probably would have been better names, but physicists are no better at naming than programmers

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:54PM (#37091664)
Maybe the public shouldn't expect to understand something that takes 8 years of rigorous study to work with, just by reading a news article from someone who also doesn't have 8 years of the necessary math study, and was explained by someone who spends all their time working with these concepts mathematically, and might not have a concrete interpretation at all.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by BobbyJo on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:44PM (#37094435)
My intent was less "we should name things better" and more "using common words a common way is fine, even if they don't reflect the exact semantics of the word at its inception".
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by psychphysic on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:36AM (#37089894)
Lol dummy the photon is an irreducible representation in the SU(2)×U(1) symmetry group when you rotate it by about 30°.

Hope I cleared that all up. Don't ask any follow up questions.

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by parasti on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:16PM (#37090405)
This, to me, describes most Wikipedia articles.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by wjessup on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:08PM (#37091062)
You forgot jumping right into the derivation first without any context of why it matters.
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by mrguyorama on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:49PM (#37091608)
What else could it possibly be? 90% of particle and high energy and quantum physics just doesn't have a real meaning beyond the extremely rigorous math. This isn't classical physics where you can talk about pendulums to twelve year olds, because physics in those domains simply works in more complicated manners. The tools we needed to develop to query that domain simply require more advanced math.

IMO, this desire to "simplify" something that cannot really be simplified is why so much pop sci around quantum stuff is just nonsense. Even normal words mean entirely different things in the realm of quantum physics. The layman doesn't understand what quantum computing does because the layman doesn't even have a knowledge of calculus, and all the intuition about the behavior of mathematical systems that comes with it, let alone the kind of linear algebra, discrete math, and higher level math like fields.

People need to stop pretending that the most advanced mathematical constructs humankind has conceived, standing on ten thousand years of the smartest minds we have ever birthed, is something that John Q Public can expect to understand.

It's no different than me being unable to discuss influences on Picaso's work because I have never taken an art history class. Sure, I could parrot some dumbed down thought someone else feeds me, but I emphatically do not have the context and surrounding knowledge to extract any meaning from that.

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by kitd on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:01PM (#37090207)
That's partly because we're doing it using a brain evolved to hunt prey, track herds or understand seasons, not the subatomic world.

The way to deal with that is to use mathematics. Once you yield to its power and give up trying to "understand" particle physics, things are a lot simpler (for certain values of "simple" ofc!)

Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by gsuuon on Friday August 11, 2023 @12:22PM (#37090491)
I imagine a photon as being like a glider in the game of life, except the relevant rules are electromagnetism. https://conwaylife.com/wiki/Glider
Re:Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result by superposeur on Friday August 11, 2023 @05:58PM (#37094561)
Actually, the terminology and ontology are astonishingly simple. Electromagnetic waves are ripples in the electromagnetic field, which is a collection of 4 real numbers attached to every point in space and time (the four components of the "4-vector potential"). Gravity waves are ripples in the metric tensor field, which is a collection of 10 real numbers attached to every point in space and time (the independent components of a symmetric 4x4 matrix). The laws of gravity and electromagnetism are a differential equation satisfied by these components governing how they fluctuate from place to place and time to time.

Photons are merely quantized ripples in the electromagnetic field (according to quantum mechanics, the momentum and energy in these ripples come in discrete chunks).

It's instructive to wonder what could possibly be a simpler ontology. Perhaps one imagines a "medium" like that of sound, consisting of little atoms of some sort spread throughout spacetime. But then immediately this would beg way more questions: what are the atoms themselves made out of? When neighboring "atoms" are displaced why and how do they affect a given "atom" in order to propagate disturbances? What other properties might these atoms have and what would such a word as "properties" even mean since they are supposed to be the elemental constituents of light/gravity itself?

According to modern physics, none of this: just 4 + 10 = 14 numbers, no substructure whatsoever.

(Of course, there are other fields too, like matter fields and gluon fields and one a necessary part of the whole story is a declaration of what these numbers look like according to different observers, but these features are just elaborations on the basic picture of a collection of numbers attached to events.)