News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by ta8645 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:42AM (#37077641)
Why would Ivy schools pass your children over?
Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by tristor on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:51AM (#37077737)
Nobody ever openly talks about it, but the East Coast Ivies are still heavily WASPy, and it's largely due to things like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Register

Basically, if your family name isn't in that list, you have a massive reduction in your probability of being accepted, regardless of merit. If your name is in that list, then you likely will be accepted regardless of merit.

Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by amluto on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:22PM (#37078192)
Do you have a source? I’ve never heard of this, and I would be quite surprised if anyone I know or knew well at any elite school was on this list.
Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by ghaff on Thursday August 10, 2023 @01:37PM (#37079167)
I'd be very skeptical. I know a ton of people who went to East Coast Ivies. Many are not from the East Coast. Many are not literally WASPy and I can't imagine most of them being in a Social Register--and it's not like I especially have known an out of the mainstream crowd.
Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by rayiner on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:49PM (#37078552)
People don’t talk about it because they don’t have the vocabulary to talk about it. We act like the descendants of English/Dutch north-easterners, who profiteered from slavery (https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2022/04/slavery-probe...) are in the same group as German immigrants who came to the Midwest as indentured servants or Italian immigrants who came here in the 20th century. The false concept of “white people” totally obscures the fact that there are different groups, with different histories, origins, and cultures, who are very differently situated.
Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by onetimeusename on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:07PM (#37082391)
>but the East Coast Ivies are still heavily WASPy,

>and it's largely due to things like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Register

These are very likely not true especially the second part but since specific ethnicity is not tracked it's much harder to disprove. But I would wager this is is not true at all.

Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by epcoa on Thursday August 17, 2023 @11:09PM (#37171023)
This is utter shite nonsense dude. I know literally hundreds of ivy alums. Pretty sure none of them are in the register. Social register is barely relevant for many years and of no consequence to Ivy league admissions.
Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by camel_Snake on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:35PM (#37078359)
Because higher education is objectively not a meritocracy. The mere existence of legacy admissions proves this.

Of course those with degrees from Ivys and other selective schools don't want to acknowledge this - it devalues their degree. Same for those who aspire to attend these schools - whether they have an 'unfair' advantage or not.

Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by okaram on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:00PM (#37077883)
Ivies have about a 5% admission rate, and they probably have a much higher percentage of valedictorians than the general population.

They probably reject way more than 50% of the valedictorian/800 SAT applicants they have.

Unless you are super-special, you need to be at that level and be lucky

Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by ghaff on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:09PM (#37078004)
This is why I wrote in another comment that making it about Harvard somewhat muddies the discussion because Harvard probably is more likely to admit at least a slice of students that are far more about pedigree than anything else.

But as you say, you need to not only have the credentials, something else that sets you apart, and even then the Teela Brown luck gene. When you're being that selective, there's no way that you're realistically finding strong signals in all but the most exceptional circumstances to admit specific individuals.

(And things have only gotten more competitive. I would be shocked if I would get into my undergrad school today.)

Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by Tactician_mark on Thursday August 10, 2023 @12:45PM (#37078501)
There's a great Veritasium video about this. The idea is that if there are far more applicants than positions, then even if luck plays a small role - say, 5% of the outcome - successful applicants are overwhelmingly likely to be extremely lucky as well as highly qualified. Since so many people are close to that 95% competence factor, only the luckiest - by whatever metric of "luck" you like - can succeed.
Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by r00fus on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:17PM (#37082476)
Sounds like the hiring policy of one of my VPs from a job long ago (during a recession)

(As he dumps half of the hundreds of résumés into the recycle bin)

“Unlucky people don’t work here”

Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by phpisthebest on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:50AM (#37077734)
Follow the Recent Lawsuit against havard admissions for a clue ;)
Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by ethanbond on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:59AM (#37077862)
Because there are far more children who check all those boxes than there are slots at the Ivies?
Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by jgeada on Thursday August 10, 2023 @01:17PM (#37078895)
That's simple: Ivy schools are mostly for $$$ to schmooze with other $$$, with a thin veneer of actually talented kids that had to pass insurmountable odds to get in. The talented kids are there to make the $$$ think they're also talented and had to pass the same rigorous criteria. Smoke and mirrors all of it.
Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by bboylen on Thursday August 10, 2023 @01:24PM (#37078982)
People parrot this point a lot but it doesn't make any sense. The average SAT/ACT at the Ivy's are near perfect, the number of mediocre rich kids paying their way in is a small fraction of the student body.

And yes test scores aren't the best metric for "talent" but it is one of the better signals you get in a college application.

Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by mildconcern on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:39PM (#37081459)
Yeah, but the money paid by that small fraction of the student body is colossal.

They're not numerous enough to change any GPA/SAT averages, but they likely pay many times more in tuition & donations than the rest of their class put together. That's why they're the main focus of these places, even if their numbers are small.

Re:Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists by HDThoreaun on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:01PM (#37082342)
All the schools lie about their average test scores to boost their rankings(source, president of northwestern when I took his econ class). We have no idea what the ivies averages are.