News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by monkeycantype on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @06:39PM (#37056434)
* * *
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by codybontecou on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @07:45PM (#37056972)
This is fascinating. I always joke to friends that earth is alive, just slow moving.

"Is a rock that gets stuck in your shoe just trying to travel?"

Does this theory have a name or a place I can ready more about it?

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by haswell on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @08:12PM (#37057167)
I think it was Alan Watts who described what earth might look like to an observer with a different perspective. “Look at that; this planet is peopling”. His point being that we are all emerging phenomena intrinsically linked to the unfolding processes of earth and the cosmos more broadly, and that our existence is a manifestation of the universe unfolding. For whatever progress science makes, there’s this underlying primordial quality that often gets lost in the academic conceptual descriptions and labels assigned to this phenomena.

I think it’s fair to say earth is alive with a completely straight face, and it’s probably even important for more people to start seeing it this way.

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by wddkcs on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @09:17PM (#37057623)
I love this perspective but think it needs to be taken all the way. Are you comfortable saying corporations are alive? Stars? The universe? Once that floodgate of 'aliveness' is open, I don't see that it stops flowing, up and down. And it's and even smaller step to 'everything is conscious'...
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by firecall on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @09:24PM (#37057671)
Indeed, and Alan Watts’ further point was that we come out of this world, not into it.

In modern western societies we learn that we born into this world, and that our mind, body and soul are seperate entities.

Whereas other cultures and philosophies consider that we are part of the world, that we are born out of it but still connected.

The speeches for Watts are really about the increasingly unhealthy abstraction from this planet that is shaping our thinking.

Ideas that we can and should live on Mars or grow and eat artificial meat are just bonkers really. I’m all for science and advancement, but being restoring our connection to this planet is the answer. :-)

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by jschveibinz on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @09:45PM (#37057795)
You had me until that last paragraph went off the rails.

…live on Mars or grow and eat artificial meat…

Not sure what your train of thought was there.

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by firecall on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:17AM (#37058629)
LOL - no, a bit random.

I was typing on my phone and running out of time.

Broadly, it was a half baked thought that our Western culture heavily promotes ideas that are anti-Earth in a way.

Ideas for instance where Elon Musk is talking about saving humanity by getting to Mars, or creating artificial meat as a solution to our food crises.

These ideas suggest that the solution is to engineer our way out of a problem of our own making. The problem rhetoric being that Earth cannot support us.

This runs counter to the thinking that we are bound to this Earth because we are part of it. We are one and the same. So we should respect it and work with it.

Watts talks about seeing the Californian hills in the 60s, being carved up and houses being wedged in to the landscape in an artificial way. Where no consideration is given to working with the land, instead we try to dominate and shape it.

Like I say, it's a half baked idea that I'm not really expressing very well I don't think! :-)

I'd love others to straighten me out, or put me on the right path! :-)

I did laugh a while back when in one of Watts' talks he mentioned Plastics being the solution to Deforestation and Paper Wastage...

Engineering a solution to deforestation using plastics didn't work out so well for us.

Fast forward 50 years and it turns out that Humans just began using more of everything!

Like building roads to reduce traffic and you end up just promoting more car usage! :-)

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by TedDoesntTalk on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @03:06AM (#37059542)
Thank you for writing this.
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by jschveibinz on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:53AM (#37063625)
Thanks for the follow up. I enjoy a lot of what Alan Watts said. Not all, but a lot. Cheers.
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by haswell on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @11:13PM (#37058301)
These are such great speeches, and this thread is reminding me that I need to go back and listen to them again.

They’re highly entertaining, and also deeply thought provoking. I know they helped shift how I see myself relative to the world quite a bit.

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by ycombinete on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:34AM (#37058746)
* * *
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by lelanthran on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:06AM (#37073354)
> In modern western societies we learn that we born into this world, and that our mind, body and soul are seperate entities.

> Whereas other cultures and philosophies consider that we are part of the world, that we are born out of it but still connected.

> The speeches for Watts are really about the increasingly unhealthy abstraction from this planet that is shaping our thinking.

What makes you call one of those abstractions unhealthy, and the other (presumably) healthy?

IOW, why do you feel one is more valid than the other? To me, they are either both equally valid or equally invalid.

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by alanbernstein on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:19AM (#37058639)
I like to think of us (life) as a thin film of goo that happens to grow on a tiny speck that happens to float around a star
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by jvm___ on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:42AM (#37058779)
Gym shower drain algae. We're tiny dots that populate the water/land areas around the world. Globally we're microscopic.

Just a pale blue dot, a mote of dust, suspended in a sunbeam.

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by Cyphase on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:01AM (#37061363)
This reminds me of this quote from Jill Tarter of SETI:

“Might it be the discovery of a distant civilization and our common cosmic origins that finally drives home the message of the bond among all humans? Whether we’re born in San Francisco or Sudan or close to the heart of the Milky Way Galaxy, we are the products of a billion-year lineage of wandering stardust. We, all of us, are what happens when a primordial mixture of hydrogen and helium evolves for so long that it begins to ask where it came from.”

source: https://www.ted.com/talks/jill_tarter_join_the_seti_search (@ 3:02)

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @08:30PM (#37057306)
Hylozoism [0] and panpsychism [1] might be fun rabbit holes for that kind of thinking.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hylozoism

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panpsychism

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by mreid on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @09:21PM (#37057657)
"It is well known that stone can think, because the whole of electronics is based on that fact, but in some universes men spend ages looking for other intelligences in the sky without once looking under their feet. That is because they've got the time-span all wrong. From stone's point of view the universe is hardly created and mountain ranges are bouncing up and down like organ-stops while continents zip backward and forward in general high spirits, crashing into each other from the sheer joy of momentum and getting their rocks off. It is going to be quite some time before stone notices its disfiguring little skin disease and starts to scratch, which is just as well."

-- Terry Pratchett, "Equal Rites"

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by jareklupinski on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:35PM (#37070315)
going in the other direction... wonder what life would look like to one of the purple sparks formed @7:54 https://youtu.be/dqNQ6KS0mjg?t=476
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by yojo on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:43PM (#37058132)
Maybe not exactly what you’re looking for, but the Gaia hypothesis is the theory that the inorganic and organic parts of the Earth influence each other such that you might describe the convoluted system as “alive.”

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaia_hypothesis

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by Jedd on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @07:49PM (#37057003)
If you haven't already read it, then I can highly recommend Nick Lane's 'Transformer - The Deep Chemistry of Life and Death', which goes into deep detail on this hypothesis.

He's touched on this in a couple of his earlier books, I think The Vital Question and one other, but in general all his works are relatively easy to read, and worth the effort.

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by monkeycantype on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @08:17PM (#37057214)
i haven't read it, but soon will thank you. (thumbs up emoji)
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by Insanity on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:02PM (#37057904)
Haven't read "Transfomer..", but I did read "the vital question" earlier this year. I thought it was a good book and it does indeed touch on this, plus it was relatively easy to read for someone without too much context like me.
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by 725686 on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @11:35PM (#37058422)
Nick Lane's Power Sex & Suicide, and The Vital Question are excellent and relatively easy for anyone. Transformer is much more difficult and dense. There are also some excellent talks in yt.
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by HPsquared on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:00AM (#37060935)
Thanks for the reference, I didn't know he had a more thorough book on this. I remember reading "Life Ascending" and being amazed at the descriptions of the hydrothermal vents.
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by intimidated on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @01:51AM (#37059127)
Great, insightful reply. Thank you.

> But free loader molecules that could infiltrate a metabolism and contribute nothing, but use it only for their own self-replication would also thrive.

Could you please explain the "mechanical" distinction between molecules that contribute to self-replication and molecules that contribute nothing during replication?

What does it mean to contribute?

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by monkeycantype on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @11:46PM (#37071702)
somewhere on the internet are some videos in which an italian scientist describes what he means by a system. I think that's probably enough to google. So if you're willing to accept that sometimes we are able to recognise a phenomenon that fits our definition of a category, even though we are not capable of explicitly defining that category, then we could say that a cell fits out intuitive definition of a system, even though I think despite being employed as system achitect, I'm not sure I could tell you what a system is. I like the attempts at definitions of living systems that discuss phenomenon that enable the persistence of information that are robust against the entropy.

Anywhy on to my attempt at answering your question:

If we could identify a set of molecules in the pores of vent rock back in the early pre-biotic earth, each with a distinct catalytic function, that were the using energy available, perhaps as electric charge, perhaps chemical energy and interacting to replicate that same set of molecules in neighbouring pores, then we could look at the actions of each molecule, and determine how each molecule participates in the chemical processes that result in the replication of the whole set of molecules. If a molecule is mutually dependent on on other molecules in the set for their mutual replication, I think we can call them a contributing part of the system. If a molecule depends on the other molecules to be replicated, but the replication of no other molecule is improved from its presence in the set, then it is not a contributing part of the system, but a freeloader.

I think this sets up two maximal strategies:

A system is most efficient if it has no freeloaders.

A molecule is most efficient if it can freeload.

Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by mjan22640 on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @02:33AM (#37059366)
Life on Earth is essentially pumping electric charges to create a potential and then discharging it to drive its processes. The outside of the cell is charged positively with hydrogen ions, the inside is negative. The membrane is an insulator. The chemistry of the vents on early Earth where life emerged acted like a battery and had an electric gradient on which the life fed. A membrane has competitive advantages like storing more charge for immediate disposal than what is naturally available, ability to charge to a higher potential difference than what is naturally available and drive processes that would not be possible without it, and crucially an ability to survive outside of the vent.
Re:Life Has Been Found Beneath Hydrothermal Vents for the Fi... by androidbishop on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:28PM (#37070267)
Read "The Romance of Reality" by Bobby Azarian. It starts there and expands to cosmic levels.