You can go to a library to borrow a book, but you can't go to the library and copy all the books for your own use.
It's just impractical to photocopy every page of every book in a library.
Otherwise, intellectual property laws can perhaps apply.
It'd be a hard push to claim it's fair use, a wholesale copying of other's works.
Why? What's stopping me from doing that? The only limitation is time.
You can actually copy all the book but the things is you can't publish it as your own book after you copied. Because obviously it is not your work.
Things get interesting at corporate scale. There are fat VC funds, executives, board of directors and what not - making far more and far more comfortable than an individual trying to get better at their craft to put food on the table. And on top of that, you don't give me access to the product that was refined on my input.
It is like someone learning photography from my website but later taking a really masterpiece shot but asking me for money each time I want to view the photo in their studio.
There are no easy answers, I concur.
Thanks for your comment though, really. :)
> do I owe you 1% of what my clients pay me?
I would still derive some immaterial gain or satisfaction from you reading my website specifically and using what you learnt to improve yourself. As I expect most people would so it's still a give and take relationship. LLMs sever that link.
I doubt many people will be as willing to continue "putting stuff out into the world" if they know that they are only contributing to some sort of (arguably semi-dystopian) hive-mind.
IMHO whether what they are doing or not is justifiable from the legalistic perspective is tangential and not that relevant is we're talking about free/non-commercial content.
Do they though? I mean, do you personally have a link to the people that are consuming the content you post publicly?
I find all the vitriol around LLMs being trained on public data to be a bit weird. If you don't want that data being used then don't publish it for the world to see? Why get mad when you are the one freely publishing the data in the first place? That's like posting your content on a bulleting board in the dorm common room and telling the trust-fund kids they can't read it because they are rich and you don't want them learning anything from you that might make them richer. Maybe a bad analogy, but I feel like it's a fair approximation of the vitriol I see.
Far in the future - if ever - where we have biological grade artificial beings which you can't program, control and limit in the classical software development sense, this could be rethought.
Until then, we don't need to humanize machines.
If I watch a youtube video my browser is also in a way scraping youtube and storing a (temporary) copy of the video. Does it make sense to protect the protect the owner's right's at this point? Absolutely not. Instead we wait to see if I share that downloaded video or content from it again, or somehow reuse it in my own products. Only then does the law step in.
But you don't get any of that from an LLM.
The reason copyright law exists in the first place is due to the difference of scale between copying books by hand and using a machine to do it, so I think "it's different because a machine is doing it" is a completely rational stance to take.
I believe no. Most people would make a distinction between “normal” and “rich”. They would give normal people free access, but the rich should pay for it.
It’s like a billionaire asking for a free hot dog. It’s like “come on, you can easily pay $100, which could even sponsor it for the next 100 people”.
Here it’s not the AI itself that’s exploiting you. It’s the rich people that make the AI that get even richer - partly thanks to your free work.
AI training is basically only extractive and has the potential to severely disrupt the actual field that made the AI systems possible at all. It's a much more mechanical process that the human interaction of studying a master. It doesn't develop any human skills.
Even if the processes were the same (and I don't think they are, as someone who has actually done computational psychology research), I would still think the AI companies are doing something they know is harmful to actual creative people that generate real value.
If I read your hobby website about photography and use it to take 1% better pictures, do I owe you 1% of what my clients pay me?
I think that probably most people would say no, assuming you could even determine that 1% in a way that both parties agreed was fair. I think generally, we have an understanding that some stuff is put out into the world for other humans to learn from and use to make themselves better, and that they don’t owe the original authors anything other than the price of admission.
I guess it comes down to this: do we think that training a model is:
- like storing and later reproducing a version of some collected data, or
- like learning from collected data, and synthesizing new info?
Is there even a meaningful distinction, for a computer?
(Is there even a meaningful distinction for a human…?)