News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by pmlnr on Monday August 07, 2023 @02:02AM (#37030711)
> However, it's quite an old product and if you went for a Hive system from 2016

These things are part of the house, like an appliance. 7 years is nothing in terms of a building, it's ridiculous to disable products in such a short time.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by Reason077 on Monday August 07, 2023 @03:51AM (#37031558)
Exactly. This is something that should be protected in consumer law. There should be a minimum (10 years? more?) period in which companies are required to support smart home devices and keep the cloud services that support them operational.

There is an e-waste issue here as well as a consumer rights one. The old analog boiler control/timer box and thermostat in my house look they were installed in the 1980s. A bit yellowed and beat up but they still work just fine!

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by robertlagrant on Monday August 07, 2023 @04:23AM (#37031806)
Or have the products clearly labelled to say that the service is not guaranteed to keep working after a certain date.
Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by shaoonb on Monday August 07, 2023 @04:35AM (#37031882)
It's probably there in the fine print somewhere. Maybe if it was required to be very clearly marked on the packaging like cigarette warning labels.
Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by robertlagrant on Monday August 07, 2023 @05:19AM (#37032169)
Yes - exactly. Big old sticker on every device saying it, that sort of thing.
Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by bombcar on Monday August 07, 2023 @08:59AM (#37033810)
If you did it right you could make it a marketing sell point - list the number of guaranteed days left in the UI and then start telling you how much you “beat” the system once that’s past.
Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by rjmunro on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:02AM (#37032428)
In the UK this is protected by consumer law under the terms of the The Consumer Rights Act 2015. Anyone who bought their devices direct from British Gas should write to them saying that they want repair, replacement with equivalent devices that will work, or a full refund.

There is no time limit, only "reasonable", which for something that is fixed into your house, 20 years seems reasonable to me. You could settle for prorating the 20 year life, so if you've had it 5 years then they will refund 75% or something.

British Gas is easily big enough to absorb the losses, and has a lot of bad press at the moment because of the profit it has been making. It would set a good example for future cases.

https://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/regulation/consumer-...

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by mattlondon on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:29AM (#37032603)
Ah but to play devil's advocate, consumer rights only kicks in when you "take ownership" of something. I am sure that in the hive contract somewhere it says that you do not own it and just have a limited-use license so you are not technically a "consumer" of their service but some sort of licensed "service installation" or some other legal bullshit or sleight of hand that means they have zero obligations.
Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by bloak on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:37AM (#37032660)
> "take ownership"

Where's that quoted from? Legislation? How do you think that consumer rights apply to electricity supply and phone contracts, for example?

I have no knowledge of whether consumer rights apply to Hive but I don't understand this "take ownership" principle that you're proposing here.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by mattlondon on Monday August 07, 2023 @02:07PM (#37038232)
From the linked article:

> KEY INFORMATION > > Taking ownership > The clock starts ticking from the date you take ownership of the goods

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by megapolitics on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:43AM (#37032704)
>consumer rights only kicks in when you "take ownership" of something

No they don’t. Consumer rights law in the UK applies to services too.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by bombcar on Monday August 07, 2023 @08:57AM (#37033786)
Best Buy gave up on a bunch of their IoT switches, etc, and sent me Best Buy gift cards for the full purchase price.

Amusingly, because they’re HomeKit compatible, they continue to work because Apple required HomeKit to work without some weird manufacturer cloud system.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by rwmj on Monday August 07, 2023 @07:54AM (#37033231)
> The old analog boiler control/timer box and thermostat in my house look they were installed in the 1980s

And more importantly you can easily buy wire-compatible replacement controllers to this day.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by tzs on Monday August 07, 2023 @10:23AM (#37034865)
> There should be a minimum (10 years? more?) period in which companies are required to support smart home devices and keep the cloud services that support them operational

10 years (or whatever) from time the product comes to market or from the time they stop selling it?

If it from the time they stop selling it that would probably lead to a lot of things not being sold for long. Manufacturers will want to get the clock started as soon as possible to minimize the amount of time they end up having to back port security fixes to libraries that upstream has stopped supporting.

This could result in manufacturers discontinuing things a year to two after introducing them, replacing them with newer products that do most of what the old did but probably also incorporate newer features.

That would be annoying for consumers. Say I buy some internet connected home control and security system, but don't buy all the accessories it works with. Then 5 years later I want to add say a camera. But the cameras designed for my system were discontinued 4 years earlier, and the cameras the company now sells are 3 generations ahead of that and require features or interfaces in the base system that aren't in mine.

On the other hand if it is from the time the product comes to market that will also probably discourage manufactures from keeping a product available for a long time. Consumers might be reluctant to buy something that has been for sale several years knowing that it only has a few years of mandatory support left.

Probably what you need are two limits, one requiring a certain number of years from the time the product is introduced, and the other requiring a certain smaller number of years after the product is discontinued.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by Reason077 on Monday August 07, 2023 @10:34AM (#37035002)
> "10 years (or whatever) from time the product comes to market or from the time they stop selling it?"

Consumer law is typically based on the date of purchase. So, 10 years from the date of purchase, for example.

Although, as pointed out by another commenter, UK consumers effectively have these rights already, as they have the right to return (to the retailer) a product that is no longer functioning after a reasonable amount of time for repair, replacement, or refund.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by notahacker on Monday August 07, 2023 @04:36AM (#37031893)
Don't see why being fixed in place in a house means that a £60 control chip should be required to last longer than a £1000 smartphone, especially since the latter doesn't offer you a discounted replacement when the OEM kills most of your functionality with incompatible OS updates locking you out of appstores and then the non-removable battery swells up and kills it.
Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by benj111 on Monday August 07, 2023 @04:45AM (#37031952)
do the same with phones then. unlock them when they stop being supported so you can run your own software.

id accept the same for hive if there was an open ecosystem to move it to.

point is, if companies want to retain control of something they actually need to maintain it. if they dont want to maintain it, they need to give up control. they cant have it both ways.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by pmlnr on Monday August 07, 2023 @05:10AM (#37032110)
> Don't see why being fixed in place in a house means that a £60 control chip should be required to last longer than a £1000 smartphone

Huh? You're joking, right?

You want to go around and replace all switches, dimmers, etc every other year in a home?

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by notahacker on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:52AM (#37032773)
No, which is why I wouldn't have every single switch and dimmer in my house controlled by individual computer with custom Internet connected firmware.

We're talking about a single inexpensive thermostat that's being replaced at half price after 5-7 years, I'm definitely not joking when I'm suggesting that this might actually have less impact on consumer wallets or ewaste pile than very expensive consumer devices whose OEMs' business model revolves around being replaced biannually

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by pmlnr on Monday August 07, 2023 @08:24AM (#37033456)
> with custom Internet connected firmware

smart != internet connected. KNX, Zigbee, Z-Wave falls into this category as well, and those are local to the house, unless there's a gateway.

Anyway... as others said it before, a non-smart switch lasts decades. Smart ones should as well.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by hot_gril on Monday August 07, 2023 @12:59PM (#37037198)
If you did things reasonably and only had a smart thermostat, 7 years wouldn't be awful, but I'd still consider switching. It'd really bite if you went all-in on smart home stuff, but why would you do that.
Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by hot_gril on Monday August 07, 2023 @01:09PM (#37037360)
> Huh? You're joking, right?

This isn't necessary.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by rjmunro on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:09AM (#37032476)
The price is irrelevant. What matters is how long that kind of device can be reasonably expected to last. Dumb wall sockets cost about £5 and last >20 years. Smart sockets should last a comparable time, or come with a warning.

Because cellphones are traditionally something you replace every 3-4 years it's expected that they only last that long, and you are fully aware of that when you are buying it.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by notahacker on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:53AM (#37032783)
Dumbphones lasted >20 years too.
Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by dredmorbius on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:33AM (#37049578)
I'll note that people have been conditioned to think that phones need replacing every 3--4 years. Used to be that a wired-in landline would last a quarter-century or more, and even wireless phonesets could be expected to last a decade.

With smartphones, the principle drivers of technical obsolescence are ultimately communications standards (e.g., phase-out of 3G communications), chip speeds, and the ever-increasing resource requirements of connected services (apps or websites).

Tools for dealing with phone & SMS spam and fraud would be another principle concern.

But really, there's no reason otherwise that a handset from a decade or two ago couldn't work, and there are many who look on classic Nokia handsets with fondness and/or mourning.

Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by lostmsu on Monday August 07, 2023 @09:53AM (#37034480)
The phones don't stop to function.
Re:British gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices fo... by danaris on Monday August 07, 2023 @10:15AM (#37034743)
If you're manufacturing something that's going to go in a house...

...and that means it should be expected to last 20 years...

...then maybe just don't use the cheapest part you can, and instead actually engineer it to last 20 years?

You're talking about it like the manufacturer has no choice but to make it as cheap as possible and hey, if it fails, it fails—but that's not true at all. If there were a requirement for something to be more durable, then the manufacturer would be both able and obligated to follow it. Unfortunately, I don't believe there is such a requirement as things stand.