Re:eGPU: A 750 MHz Class Soft GPGPU for FPGA
by ZiiS on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @05:16PM
(#36963089)
10 year old entry level GPUs have 100 750Mhz cores
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:eGPU: A 750 MHz Class Soft GPGPU for FPGA
by monocasa on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @05:20PM
(#36963145)
'Cores' are really overstated in GPUs. CUDA cores are really SIMD lanes and if you counted it the same way as a CPU does, you'd get somewhere in the dozens of cores range even for modern GPUs.
Re:eGPU: A 750 MHz Class Soft GPGPU for FPGA
by xigency on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:37PM
(#36964212)
That seems backwards to me. Sure, a GPU core is less general, but in terms of concurrent execution, memory bandwidth, and FLOPS I would expect hundreds to thousands of cores for all new GPU offerings. Apple’s double-digit GPU core counts for instance sound extremely understated.
Re:eGPU: A 750 MHz Class Soft GPGPU for FPGA
by monocasa on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:54PM
(#36964392)
It's not. The best comparison is the SM count for Nvidia hardware, or the wavefront count for AMD hardware. So a 4070 has 46 cores as you'd count them on a CPU.
Re:eGPU: A 750 MHz Class Soft GPGPU for FPGA
by imtringued on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @03:43AM
(#36968121)
If you have a truck that can carry 64 boxes, then according to Nvidia marketing each box would be considered its own core even though the boxes all go the same way.
Meanwhile if you had 64 passengers cars, then each of them would be able to drive a different route at the same time and if you counted the seats you would actually end up with 320 "Nvidia cores".
Re:eGPU: A 750 MHz Class Soft GPGPU for FPGA
by codedokode on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:50PM
(#36964359)
A proper method is counting ALUs instead of vague "cores".
Re:eGPU: A 750 MHz Class Soft GPGPU for FPGA
by deaddodo on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @04:15AM
(#36968337)
If you want to count "cores" in a GPU, the best equivalency is streaming multiprocessors.
While it's true that they're in the dozens, strictly speaking, we've got GPUs with well over 100 now (the RTX 4090, for instance) and 64+ is a pretty common configuration.