News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by coreyp_1 on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:53PM (#36951767)
I thought that this was a great idea, until I read a few of the rules:

In short, you work for them, for free. You don't win unless you check all of the beaurocratic checkboxes. If you make something good, you might win $20k, $10k, or $5k, but good luck with any further monitization, as you give them right to use it forever (not for "commercial" use, but the "educational" catch-all is pretty broad). It's non-exclusive rights, of course, but why would I pay you for it when I can get it from the LOC for free?

The game is required to be in the browser. It's pretty obvious that they plan to put this on their website, or perhaps even create a portal for these types of games to point teachers to.

I also found it interesting that they require a cheat code to allow judges to play all levels.

And, they don't like copyleft licenses, either. LOL.

"If you win, in consideration of and by accepting the prize, you hereby grant to the Library the worldwide, nonexclusive, transferable, perpetual, irrevocable, fully paid-up/royalty-free right to use the entry that I (or my team, as applicable) has submitted to the Challenge, consisting of the game itself and the description thereof (“Entry”), for noncommercial purposes in connection with the Challenge and otherwise in furtherance of the mission of the Library of Congress, including, without limitation, associated promotional and educational purposes. This right includes the right to reproduce, prepare derivative works from, distribute, perform, display, or otherwise make use of the Entry, in any form, media, or technology, now known or later developed, including television, radio, satellite, cable, and the Internet (including, without limitation, streaming, podcasting, and on websites with user-generated content, such as Facebook and YouTube). You must also allow us to use your name, brief biography, and likeness, or if you are a minor, your first name, last initial, and state, to promote the challenge."

"The game must be accessible to disabled individuals. Many people with different abilities use content and apps from the Library of Congress. We have to make sure everyone, including people with disabilities, can use anything we post."

"Where there is a choice, use the most permissive license (i.e., the one allowing the broadest unconditioned use; please avoid viral licenses such as GPL)."

"i. Be Section 508 compliant.[1] ii. Work with screen readers like Jaws, NVDA, VoiceOver, etc."

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by sublinear on Monday July 31, 2023 @11:06PM (#36951841)
> Work with screen readers like Jaws, NVDA, VoiceOver, etc.

This is the actual dealbreaker from a technical standpoint. Good luck with that shit. One does not simply "et cetera" the screen readers, especially since games are likely to use canvas (rasterized text).

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by coreyp_1 on Monday July 31, 2023 @11:20PM (#36951915)
The flip side it that it may eliminate a lot of competition. I still won't be participating (for reasons that I give in another thread), but it's worth remembering that these types of technical difficulties can be a gold mine in the real world.
Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by sublinear on Monday July 31, 2023 @11:28PM (#36951948)
> these types of technical difficulties can be a gold mine in the real world.

It is. A11y is hot in web dev right now, but the Library of Congress isn't paying out anything close to that for this and normal web pages are much simpler to make accessible than games.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @01:20PM (#36959135)
A “game” doesn’t have to use canvas and rasterization (in fact, its pretty clear that they don’t assume that games will, since “can I use graphics” – the answer is yes – is a FAQ, not just something that goes without saying.)
Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by marcellus23 on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:59PM (#36951800)
> In short, you work for them, for free. You don't win unless you check all of the beaurocratic checkboxes

> you give them right to use it forever

It's a contest. They don't pay you just for entering. And of course they have rights to distribute for free forever... you're making a game _for them_. How else would it possibly work?

If you want to make a game that teaches civics and want to make money off it, then just build one and don't enter the contest with it.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by coreyp_1 on Monday July 31, 2023 @11:19PM (#36951905)
I would expect it from a private corporation. I would not expect it from a government agency.

Usually, a government agency is more interested in getting people to create things. The motivation is that by offering a prize, they encourage people to create things. Acquiring the thing is not the point. Of course, they need the right to depict the product, but they do not usually want to use it for anything and everything that they want, in perpetuity, including the right to make derivative works (without your permission, I might add).

The way that this is designed, I would not want to encourage anybody that I know to participate in it. You may disagree, but we probably have different thresholds for what we deem to be acceptable risk.

Let me put it another way. If I were to pour my heart and soul into this project, the absolute maximum value that I could extract is $20k, which is ~$13.7k after taxes. That is the ceiling. That is it. Why would I do something that would take so much time for so little potential? I would rather risk my time on something that has no ceiling. I would give the same advice to anyone. Never settle for anything when there is an artificially-imposed cap on the earning potential.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by jamescostian on Monday July 31, 2023 @11:45PM (#36952041)
This isn't designed for anyone to pour their heart and soul into it. Contestants are to make a "lightweight" (their word) game. They added a ceiling (to varying degrees) not just to the payout, but also to the submissions
Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by coreyp_1 on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @01:11AM (#36952570)
The rules are designed so that there will be absolutely no encumberance to them using your submission in any way that they want (if you win 1st, 2nd, or 3rd place). From limiting datasets to stipulating the license to a requirement of patent unencumberance and broad IP permissions.

The section 508 requirment is also very telling. Whatever wins, they plan to copy-and-paste it into their own website at the very least.

If I were to do this, then I would pour everything I had into it, because that's the way that I do things. And so, I read all the rules, and decided that I didn't like the terms.

The only reason that I commented here in the first place is because the terms were so eggregious (in my opinion) that I felt that others should be warned about the danger and the extent to which they must sacrifice their IP in order to win the contest.

This contest could have been so much better. Sadly, it sounds like the terms were written by some greedy corporation looking to find a cheap way to mass-producde games. ($35k for 3 games is a bargain, but only if you're the buyer!)

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by HWR_14 on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @02:59AM (#36953186)
> Whatever wins, they plan to copy-and-paste it into their own website at the very least.

That's not a subtle "gotcha". That's the stated goal of the project.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @01:13PM (#36959017)
> The rules are designed so that there will be absolutely no encumberance to them using your submission in any way that they want (if you win 1st, 2nd, or 3rd place). From limiting datasets to stipulating the license to a requirement of patent unencumberance and broad IP permissions.

The rules not only do that for them, but for anyone else (the direct grant of rights would be sufficient for them, asking for the most permissive license available where there is a choice establishes that for other people.) This is consistent with this being a public interest project.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by galaxyLogic on Monday July 31, 2023 @11:50PM (#36952065)
I agree the rules seem a bit too much.

But, if you win I assume you would still keep the right to produce "derivative works" yourself which Government has no rights to. So you could start maintaining and improving the game and sell the improved version.

I'm not a lawyer so do your own investigation into whether that is possible or not.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by coreyp_1 on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @12:57AM (#36952493)
You are correct, and that was actually my first thought. If you win (1st, 2nd, or 3rd place), they have rights to your game and the right to make their own derivative works. And you have rights to make derivative works. But then I thought of how this could play out.

So you make "UltraCiv" for the competition and win. You decide that it was a good idea and decide to expand on it. You make "UltraCiv: Election Paradox". Now you have something successful. They make "UltraCiv: City Manager". You can't stop them, because you already gave them permanent rights. They claim that they only use it for "educational use", which is 100% true, since it is an educational game. So was Oregon Trail. In this case, however, your franchise is tainted.

It's just poisioning your own well and IP.

Again, someone will win $20k, but that someone won't be me. I'll put my efforts elsewhere.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by galaxyLogic on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @12:43PM (#36958526)
The reason government is trying to get outside developers creating this game is that they don't have the talent for that, nor are they in the business of creating games in general. They would probably not have a program for continued improvement of games provided by 3rd parties.

Whoever wins the competition however is a talented creative developer. If government wanted to develop the game further they would probably be happy to contract with the original developer if they have further budget for that. But if not, you the creative developer could create your own follow-up game which government could not copy without your permission.

I think the winner will be somebody who is already developing games. They have the process and tools in place already. It won't be me (either).

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by beej71 on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:31AM (#36953374)
> Why would I do something that would take so much time for so little potential?

It makes zero economic sense to do this, but some people are driven by things that aren't economic.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by boomboomsubban on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:40AM (#36955227)
They dissuade most of them from participating by saying it can't be partisan and must get an E rating.
Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by komali2 on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:45AM (#36955262)
Making a game about civics that's "non-partisan" seems completely impossible to me, at least to do honestly.
Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by boomboomsubban on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:10AM (#36956992)
Their ideal game seems to be flappy bird with links to the Library of Congress website on completing some kind of level.
Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by burnished on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @02:26AM (#36967655)
I feel like you are doing the legal equivalent of reading the side effect warnings of an over the counter drug and freaking out.

Those rules that are freaking you out? Literally just the same expectations you would have around a gift, except made strange and unfamiliar by specificity.

You also seem to be reading the language around use as indicative of a plan to resell your software which is utterly bizarre.

I'm also not seeing anything that would indicate a cap on profits. You seem to have decided that if people can see the source that means you can't sell it? That does not make any sense. Let alone the ability to make improvements and sell that as a closed source offering.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by parentheses on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @01:12AM (#36952581)
It's easy to poke holes in government program and claim it's not friendly to a commercial mindset. The goal is to build compelling educational content for free use.

I see this as a net positive and a good first attempt to do this. I'm hoping future iterations do a better job of incentivizing creators to make games for public education.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by Kapura on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @10:51AM (#36956697)
If people were motivated to build compelling education content for free, congress would not need to incentivize it with a contest, no?

Incentives aren't there. As somebody who has judged indie games festival entries, I can tell you that even there it's rare to get a game that feels like it's complete, and even rarer to find one that feels like it's actually executing a gameplay idea. I don't know many folks who would bend over backwards to make a game for the government.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by conductr on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:37AM (#36957423)
> I see this as a net positive and a good first attempt to do this. I'm hoping future iterations do a better job of incentivizing creators to make games for public education.

My take is that a good first attempt would cast a larger net through proper incentives and/or less restrictions. Then as they iterate they can decide where to tighten up things. As is, this seems to be completely lacking any inspiration and actually demotivational

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by boomboomsubban on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:33AM (#36953395)
>the one allowing the broadest unconditioned use; please avoid viral licenses such as GPL)."

The rest of their requirements seemed extreme, but somewhat understandable from their position. This one's just bullshit. I hope every entry has an AGPL license attached.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by lostfiddler on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:40AM (#36953438)
OP being sneaky, trying to discourage ppl from entering, thin out the competition.
Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by qwery on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @07:46AM (#36954829)
I expect most games available for sale don't ever see $5k, but I'm not sure if that's an argument for or against participating in such a "challenge".
Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by moffkalast on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:40AM (#36955223)
> You must also allow us to use your name, brief biography, and likeness, or if you are a minor, your first name, last initial, and state, to promote the challenge.

NSA approved.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by komali2 on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:43AM (#36955251)
> please avoid viral licenses such as GPL

Is this a "please" or a requirement? Because the easiest answer to the issue is just... release the game under GPL3 and have done with it. Essentially transferring your copyright to the US government seems silly, would rather just make it available to everyone.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @01:50PM (#36959652)
> Is this a “please” or a requirement?

It is a “please” but is part of a parenthetical attached to “Where there is a choice, use the most permissive license “ which is not a “please”.

So, yeah, if you are dependent on GPL3 dependency, GPLv3 is the most permissive license available, there is no choice.

OTOH, that may be a factor weighed against your submission.

Re:Help the Library of Congress Create Games That Improve Pu... by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @01:09PM (#36958938)
> In short, you work for them, for free.

No, if that was the case the permissions would be exclusive but sublicensable, not non-exclusive.

> It’s pretty obvious that they plan to put this on their website,

Yes, and?

> I also found it interesting that they require a cheat code to allow judges to play all levels.

Seems to be a sensible way to make evaluation possible when a game might naturally have a longer gameplay with progressive enabling of content. What do you find interesting about it?

> And, they don’t like copyleft licenses, either.

Copyleft licenses limit the utility of the code as a starting point for others looking to consume LOC resources; serving as that seems to be a secondary goal behind the primary civics education goal of the project.