News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by briantakita on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:10PM (#36896749)
The climate always changes. Always has & always will. No political movement, economic paradigm, or technology will make the climate static. The geomagnetic field fluctuations, Sun, the solar system's current cosmological coordinates, cosmological effects are too big of a driver of the climate.

Geologically speaking, we have just left a mini-ice age. Our efforts are better invested in adjusting to these inevitable changes.

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by ajkjk on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:11PM (#36896773)
Who cares? if everyone dies and you say "well it always changes" the answer is still "...and we could have done something about it and we didn't do enough."

It has no bearing if it changed in the past if we can do something about it not killing most (non-rich) people in the future.

Well it was one bearing if it was like this in the past: it gives people a convenient argument for dismissing it now. So if your goal is "definitely let's make sure we don't handle this well", then at least, if you're right, you can justify that. Pretty pointless, though, unless your goal is destruction.

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by europeanNyan on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:30PM (#36897152)
That wasn't their point at all.

The question always is if we can even do something about the climate now or if we should spend the energy and resources into preparing for a potentially inevitable future.

Humans have always been champions of handling change. Why should this be different?

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by ajkjk on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:41PM (#36897349)
All evidence points to it not being inevitable on the timescales it is happening on. On some timescale, obviously the planet melts from the sun. Doesn't mean we want it to melt soon.
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by Timon3 on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:37PM (#36897285)
> The question always is if we can even do something about the climate now or if we should spend the energy and resources into preparing for a potentially inevitable future.

It's usually easier to stop doing something than to deal with the consequences of doing something.

> Humans have always been champions of handling change. Why should this be different?

Humans have never faced this kind of change. It will be different because it's not just a different temperatures, it's the collapse of the ecosystem which we rely on for food.

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by t0bia_s on Thursday July 27, 2023 @06:32PM (#36901022)
How do you know that?
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by Timon3 on Friday July 28, 2023 @01:25AM (#36903354)
How do I know what? The earlier, the latter, both?
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by t0bia_s on Friday July 28, 2023 @02:58AM (#36903787)
That humans never faced this before and it's collapse of whole ecosystem.
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by Timon3 on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:33AM (#36903979)
> That humans never faced this before

Can you point to any time during the existence of our species with a similar kind of change?

> and it's collapse of whole ecosystem.

That's mostly based on scientific studies, existing examples of rapid changes in ecosystems, and previous mass extinction events. Do you have any evidence counter to this idea?

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by t0bia_s on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:07AM (#36904184)
That's not evidence for your worlds or answer for my question.
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by Timon3 on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:54AM (#36904422)
It is an answer, even if you don't like it.

You didn't ask for "evidence for my worlds".

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by t0bia_s on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:49AM (#36904752)
You should have background for your worlds. If you claim something, it doesn't mean that it is a fact until other proves the opposite.
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by Timon3 on Friday July 28, 2023 @08:10AM (#36905704)
I do! I even told you the background. You just don't like it.
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by t0bia_s on Saturday July 29, 2023 @12:30PM (#36921836)
Be more specific. Give me a source of idea that you claim.
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by briantakita on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:30PM (#36897142)
> Who cares? if everyone dies and you say "well it always changes" the answer is still "...and we could have done something about it and we didn't do enough."

I don't take a nihlist approach. I take a realistic approach. The changes will occur. What will we do about it? Go into a delusion that we can stop the change or take steps to prepare?

> Well it was one bearing if it was like this in the past: it gives people a convenient argument for dismissing it now

I'm not dismissing it. I'm saying it IS HAPPENING & nothing we do will stop it. So what are we going to do? Sacrifice to the gods to stop the inevitable? Good luck with that...

I would prefer to mitigate these changes by hardening our infrastructure, utilize tech & social systems to improve quality of life, and address pollution like the toxic sludge byproduct to mine materials for your "renewable" equipment.

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by ajkjk on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:39PM (#36897321)
No, you argued that it has happened before, which does not imply that the fact that it is happening now is not anthropogenic this time -- which it obviously is.

If you can do work now to make "the planet getting very hot and messed up everyone's lives" take thousands of extra years, in which it is more livable, why would you not? Obviously you would balance this against other economic and policy concerns, which everyone is, and it comes out way ahead because warming is very bad for everyone.

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by dbingham on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:40PM (#36897331)
The rate of change is what matters here. We are causing the climate to change at a staggering rate. Faster than anything ever seen in nature except during cataclysmic events (massive volcanic eruptions, meteor impacts, etc).

The biosphere will not be able to keep up with these changes and we already know that we are causing a mass extinction event and destabilization of the biosphere. Our food system depends on the biosphere.

Our society also depends on the conditions that have been relatively stable for the last several millennia. Sure, there was a mini ice age, but we're talking about a smaller change in climate and far more gradual in that ice age, than what we are currently experiencing and causing. And that mini ice age was enough to cause mass disruption to human societies in areas most impacted by it.

Our current human caused climate change - if allowed to continue unabated - is likely to cause disruption on scales that lead to the death of billions of humans and the likely collapse of societies. We cannot ignore the cause of it (us) and simply adapt to the new reality. The way we adapt to this is by changing the behaviors that created it in the first place: We stop burning fossil fuels. That way it stops getting worse, then we work to return the climate to what it was previously, or we work to adapt to our new (now, hopefully, stabilized) reality.

We're quickly losing the window to even do that, however, because we're triggering feedback mechanisms that make this change self-replicating. So we likely need to go heavily into carbon removal and fast as well.

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by sebmellen on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:24PM (#36897017)
What if it’s all a hoax, and we create a better world for nothing?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joel_Pett#/media/File%3AWhat...

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by HideousKojima on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:28PM (#36897100)
Or what if we destroy the world economy and personal freedom/autonomy in the process?
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by sebmellen on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:33PM (#36897201)
If you think protecting the climate will destroy the economy and personal freedom, you’re mistaken.

The biggest threat to a thriving world economy with high degrees of personal freedom is climate change.

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by listenallyall on Thursday July 27, 2023 @02:04PM (#36897751)
> The biggest threat to a thriving world economy with high degrees of personal freedom

I would suggest it is lack of low-cost, easily-accessible energy. Energy has been the driving force behind virtually every technological and economic advance in the past century.

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by myshpa on Thursday July 27, 2023 @02:36PM (#36898199)
Agree.

But extinction of pollinators or key species, extreme temperatures causing mass crop failures, extreme droughts, several meter sea rise or a cascade of tipping points could certainly make some serious damage too.

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday July 27, 2023 @03:14PM (#36898678)
Solar PV became the "cheapest source of energy in history" levels 3 years ago in places with low cost of capital, prices have continued to fall and are forecast to keep dropping as we get more experience.

https://www.carbonbrief.org/solar-is-now-cheapest-electricit...

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by zosima on Thursday July 27, 2023 @02:23PM (#36898035)
You got to explain to me how wrecking our electricity grid and living with threat of exploding electricity prices (so much so, that there has been many reports of poor people not being able to afford heating in the winter) is making the world a better place.
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by sebmellen on Thursday July 27, 2023 @08:31PM (#36901899)
The Texas grid that broke down was all natural gas [0]. Coal kills millions a year, not even through warming, but through pollution [1]. There is no equivalence.

[0]: https://www.eenews.net/articles/investigation-texas-failed-t...

[1]: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/feb/09/fossil-f...

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by bryanlarsen on Friday July 28, 2023 @12:21PM (#36909213)
Wrecking the electricity grid? No, saving the electricity grid. Record high demand, normal summer prices.

https://electrek.co/2023/07/26/thanks-to-wind-and-solar-texa...

Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by blacksmith_tb on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:14PM (#36896836)
That can be 100% true, and humans can still be contributing to the current change? So not only would it be possible and desirable for us to stop contributing, but to try and influence the direction of change in a way that's more beneficial for more of us (which could be reforesting or olivine weathering or something crazy like solar shielding or sulfur dioxide cannons, depending on who you ask).
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by flatline on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:14PM (#36896834)
Yes but it is changing in very specific and problematic ways with well understood causes that are at least partly under our control. We do not understand it perfectly but we don’t need to.
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by bryanrasmussen on Thursday July 27, 2023 @01:14PM (#36896823)
people always die, nothing we can do to stop it. That's why complaining about me shooting all these people is sort of not very useful, everybody should leave me alone to continue on my murder spree because people always die!
Re:This month is the planet’s hottest on record by far – and... by piva00 on Thursday July 27, 2023 @03:53PM (#36899211)
> Our efforts are better invested in adjusting to these inevitable changes.

Of course. If those changes would happen in a timeframe spanning hundreds of centuries we could dedicate some effort to progressively adapt to them, when it looms to violently happen upon us in the next 50-100 years and it's known it could've been partially avoided I don't think we can just magically wave it away to "it will eventually be solved technologically". It might as well not be, that's the scary part.