Yes, it's just a chemical like Agent Orange is just a chemical
Eg. glyphosate might an option to regain control over weeds versus a systematic plow of the soil that has for consequences to damage its structure and its organisms.
B - Sounds like it would need regulation? Who is making sure farmers are using it in this manner?
It isn't just bumblebee impairment. Entire colonies die. Bumblebees are needed to pollinate a large percentage of our food -> Hence not a "rational decision".
TO say nothing of impact on humans, and the half life in water runoff.
No, obviously not, because we enjoy living. You can't ignore those same tradeoffs when they happen to not be taking place in your back yard.
We can make sensible regulation to minimize our impact but sometimes we need to make an impact to extract resources, just how it is.
As far as I can tell this is not accurate- glyphosate breaks down to AMPA which is not inert.
A) farmers use it as a crop dissicant in large quantities to make their crops cheaper to harvest, outside the spec of the product and
B) when it's used in unsuitable soil, temperature, and humidity conditions.
In the right conditions it has a half life of a few days and will be completely inert in a couple of weeks. This is a relatively small impact for a pretty big benefit. In poorly suited conditions it can persist for months or years.
We should just make it legal for use in situations where it decays quickly and harmlessly and disallow it's use in jurisdictions where the conditions are not appropriate for it's use. It's just a chemical, like any other chemical as long as it's used responsibly it can deliver incredible benefits. In this case cost-effectively feeding the world.
If the price for all that is some impairment to bumblebees for a few weeks maybe we should weigh that against the benefits and make a rational decision.