News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle in Progress by wonderwonder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:16PM (#36871974)
I have no insight into Seattle. This is a genuine honest question. Why is Seattle growing? The news appears to illustrate it as a drug infested homeless encampment. The Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone and the related killings did not help that narrative. So honest question, what's really going on there?
Re:Seattle in Progress by panarky on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:25PM (#36872025)
When you find that your news sources don't match what's actually happening in the real world, it's time to check on the agenda of those news sources.

It's also a good idea to look at macro trends and not get distracted by anecdotes with high emotional or political payloads.

My experience:

A desirable place to live. Mild climate, beautiful scenery, a wide variety of cultural and recreational activities, top-ranked universities.

A growing job market. The job market in Seattle is growing rapidly, with a number of new businesses and industries opening up in the area. This has created a lot of new job opportunities, which has attracted people from all over the country and the world.

A strong transportation system. Seattle has a well-developed transportation system, which makes it easy for people to get around the city without a car. The city has a light rail system, a bus system, and an extensive network of bike paths and trails.

A vibrant arts and culture scene. Seattle has a vibrant arts and culture scene, with a number of museums, theaters, and concert halls. The city also hosts a number of festivals and events throughout the year.

Seattle culture is welcoming and accepting, attracting people from all over the world. This diversity creates a rich cultural tapestry that can be found in the city's restaurants, shops, and neighborhoods.

Re:Seattle in Progress by wonderwonder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:29PM (#36872059)
I mean Capitol Hill really was seized and people were killed and stores were looted. Crime really is escalating along with the homeless population. Plus there is a drug issue. So the news I am consuming is not the issue. Thus the answer is that in spite of these things the city is growing, hence my question.

No need to lob insults in some sort of misguided political crusade. Thanks!

Re:Seattle in Progress by dghlsakjg on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:40PM (#36872131)
You keep citing a protest from more than three years ago and a trend of rising crime and homelessness that is affecting Seattle, as well as almost every major city in America.

It seems like you aren’t actually curious why people move to Seattle, and just want to believe what you already think you know.

Re:Seattle in Progress by wonderwonder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:45PM (#36872160)
If you look at the comment I was responding to, they posted in an attacking manner. I was responding to that. I agree it was 3 years ago, but all those people likely still live there and it was a pretty damn big deal. Several city blocks were seized and lawless. So again I clearly communicated that this is what the news I saw was conveying and then asked for the reasons it was growing as this is all the info I have. No idea why everyone is incredibly insulted that I asked a question.
Re:Seattle in Progress by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:04PM (#36872282)
> but all those people likely still live there and it was a pretty damn big deal

You aren't going to get much sympathy for your position from those people who lives in Capitol Hill, they tend to be very young and very left in their ideology. Yes, FoxNews showed that picture of the teleporting guy with the gun (before they started marking such pictures as illustration), and yes, the homicide rate was slightly above average during the CHAZ. Most of us who live in Seattle never actually experienced it (I didn't), and when I finally got around to visiting Capitol Hill during the pandemic, it was long over and a perfectly normal place (albeit with slightly more restaurants closed).

Re:Seattle in Progress by wonderwonder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:34PM (#36872464)
Fair enough, thank you.
Re:Seattle in Progress by sedev on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:45PM (#36872158)
You are factually wrong and also your news sources are factually wrong. If you find that insulting, that's a you problem.
Re:Seattle in Progress by wonderwonder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:48PM (#36872180)
cool cool, what part am I factually wrong about? The growing homeless population? The drug problem? The growth in violent crime? The Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone and the related killings?
Re:Seattle in Progress by c22 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:19PM (#36872359)
I lived on the hill during the protests. I walked through the 'capitol hill autonomous zone' with my children numerous times and never felt unsafe. 15-20 years ago I used to catch a late-night bus at Pike and 3rd which was considerably sketchier than anything that's ever happened on Capitol Hill and even that was tame compared to other large cities I've visited.
Re:Seattle in Progress by wonderwonder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:27PM (#36872409)
Friend, respectfully... 5 people were not shot over a few days on the late night bus. I'm glad you felt safe and that you were able to walk your kids through it but lets not down play what really happened to the people that were shot and killed in that small area during that short window of time.
Re:Seattle in Progress by c22 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:41PM (#36872513)
I don't watch a lot of news so I can't really speak to the facts you're citing, but I've also spent some time living southeast of Capitol Hill in the Central District where people actually routinely get shot and where I've been mugged at gunpoint so it's possible my 'safety tolerance' is just different from yours. By comparison, nothing I saw on the hill during the 'CHAZ' even came close, it was mostly drum circles and graffiti-art.

I remember feeling a similar disconnect between the news cycle and my lived experience during 'Occupy Wallstreet' when I watched a crowd of hundreds of people walking two blocks from in front of Westlake to protest at the Bank of America stop and wait for every pedestrian signal.

Re:Seattle in Progress by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:51PM (#36872575)
I've never heard of anyone getting mugged at gunpoint in Seattle before. I'm not doubting your experience, but usually they try to steal your bike or pirate your packages, crimes that the SPD usually just ignores, pulling a gun on someone is rare, since the SPD doesn't really ignore that. My maternal aunt from Alaska did claim to be mugged by a black guy in Seattle in the 70s, but she was also kind of racist, so I'm not sure if her story was true or not.

An extended family member did get shot outside of an SLU bar a few years ago. I'm not really clear on what was going on, they didn't catch whoever did it, and he wasn't seriously wounded, but it was scary that someone I knew was shot at at all, since this place isn't really know for that (and I worked at Third and Pine McDonalds for a year in the mid-90s, so have seen some crazy sh*t).

Re:Seattle in Progress by c22 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:59PM (#36872610)
If it helps your collection of anecdotes, I gave the mugger my wallet while remarking that I was sorry there was no cash in it but I had $150 on the EBT card and he handed it back and said 'that's all right, have a safe night' and ran away.
Re:Seattle in Progress by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @11:53PM (#36872871)
Oohf, ya, mugging people these days is tough. No one carries cash around anymore.
Re:Seattle in Progress by lazyasciiart on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:17AM (#36873717)
There used to be a protective Pride patrol in Capitol Hill because there were regular physical attacks on LGBTQ people in the street. I moved here in 2009 and I remember multiple incidents where people were mugged at gunpoint on the Hill just that year. Pulling a gun on someone is not frequent, but it's also not a once-a-year headline act.
Re:Seattle in Progress by lazyasciiart on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:14AM (#36873695)
I live in Capitol Hill and no, it wasn't "seized". CHAZ was on the same level of disruption as this weekend's annual music festival, which fenced off several city blocks (and they were blocks filled with stores people wanted to go to, not just the park). The news you are consuming is absolutely the issue, but I get the impression that you consume it because it tells you what you want to hear.
Re:Seattle in Progress by dghlsakjg on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:28PM (#36872046)
The news you are getting is wrong is the simplest explanation.

It has a homeless problem, just like every large city in America, maybe worse than some, definitely better than some.

The CHAZ was a protest 3 years ago. That area is now basically indistinguishable from before, which is to say that it is a counterculture hotspot in the city, but still very safe. There are two colleges within a block of where the CHAZ was that are thriving, and it is a great place for shopping, a night out, seeing a show, etc.

It is a city where housing is much more affordable than many parts of California, but you can still get access to major career opportunities. There are beaches in the city, and skiing, hiking, glaciers, etc within an hour or two. The cultural scene is thriving.

People think that big lefty cities are dangerous without having ever been there.

If I asked you which of the following cities has a higher murder rate than Chicago which would you select: Cleveland, Las Vegas or Kansas City.

The answer is all of them have a murder rate 30% higher than chicago.

The point is that the news likes to pick on certain places, but you should look to more reliable sources.

Re:Seattle in Progress by wonderwonder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:40PM (#36872129)
If the question was "Which city has the most murders", the answer is Chicago... by a lot. So you can use the numbers to paint whatever picture you like.
Re:Seattle in Progress by dghlsakjg on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:46PM (#36872168)
Yes Chicago has the most murders, but in the real world the denominator matters, and we both know that.

You asked your question claiming it was “genuine and honest” but you are hitting talking points in your reply to my comment and others that line up with a very specific agenda. I rather doubt it is coincidence. Please stop trolling.

Re:Seattle in Progress by wonderwonder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:52PM (#36872207)
Friend, I honesty was not trolling. Look at the posts to which I responded. All of them appear emotionally unstable and outraged that I would dare ask a question that mentioned some of the advertised negatives about their city and then asked what positives are clearly out weighing these negatives as the city is growing.

By the same token, you seem upset that your witty trick question about murder rates is upended by the fact that through sheer weight of numbers, Chicago dominates. No matter how you choose to look at it.

I am responding very forcefully to banal and mindless attacks from people that just don't want to answer my question in the spirit it was intended.

Look through the replies. So far out of a dozen, only one answered unemotionally and logically.

edit: 2 now

Re:Seattle in Progress by gottorf on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:54PM (#36872216)
> People think that big lefty cities are dangerous without having ever been there.

> If I asked you which of the following cities has a higher murder rate than Chicago which would you select: Cleveland, Las Vegas or Kansas City.

For what it's worth, you've listed four "big lefty cities", with all four cities having voted for the Democratic presidential candidate in all of the last six elections, most with big margins. (Though to be fair, it's hard to find any big cities that haven't, considering that the largest political divide in the country is on urban vs. rural lines.)

Chicago should be considered a peer city to NYC and LA, and it does suffer quite a bit in its murder rate compared to those two[0], even though they were all once comparable.

Of the ten most dangerous (highest rates of violent crime) cities in the US[1] of any size, only one, Springfield, IL, voted for the Republican presidential candidate more than half the times of the last six elections. All but two of the remainder were solidly Democratic for all six cycles. So while there may be some truth to your idea that people unfairly believe "big lefty cities" are dangerous, there is also some truth to those people's idea, as well.

[0]: https://www.chicagobusiness.com/crains-forum-safer-chicago/c...

[1]: https://www.populationu.com/gen/most-dangerous-cities-in-the...

Re:Seattle in Progress by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:34PM (#36872459)
Almost all cities are run by Democrats, especially if they are big. I can think of exceptions like Fairbanks AK and Mesa AZ, but those places have their own crime problems. Most of the really bad cities (New Orleans, St. Louis, Jackson Mississippi) are blue cities in red states, but that is more to do about historic poverty, and Jim Crow's legacy, than anything else.
Re:Seattle in Progress by dghlsakjg on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:02PM (#36872274)
Most cities are democrat. Of the top 100, only 24 have republican mayors. So it stands to reason that there will be more democrat run cities with high murder rates. Conversely there will be more democrat cities with low murder rates. I wouldn’t classify any of those cities as decidedly lefty, all three of them are in swing/red states. That’s just my opinion and not really the point, though.

My point was more to the effect that there is a trope, especially in right wing circles, that Chicago in particular is especially dangerous, which isn’t really the case. It was a point to illustrate that talking points like “Chicago is super murder happy” and “Seattle is Dying” keep getting repeated despite their lack of grounding in truth.

Re:Seattle in Progress by gottorf on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:32PM (#36872449)
I understand (and made a similar point regarding most cities being liberal), but parts of Chicago really are especially dangerous, because the violent crime rate is not evenly distributed throughout city limits. For young men, living in certain parts of Chicago (e.g. 60624) was in fact more dangerous to their life than being deployed to Afghanistan[0]. I hesitate to describe that as a trope; more a travesty that needs to be addressed.

Of course, if you're a tourist five miles away at Navy Pier or the Bean, Chicago isn't dangerous at all, and there's all of the rest of Chicago that you quite correctly state brings down the overall murder rate (to only 10th highest in the nation). But it's not like there's a wall separating the less violent parts of Chicago from the more violent parts, and as a tourist who doesn't know the different areas of the city well, the fact that Garfield Park has a higher murder rate than the most violent city in the world might make you shy away from the whole city. So I don't think it's fair to say that there is no ground at all for the claim that Chicago is murder happy.

I'll stop here since I've managed to wander far from the GP's question about Seattle; I just love Chicago and the topic engenders some passion in me.

[0]: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/articlepdf/...

Re:Seattle in Progress by tptacek on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @06:10PM (#36885884)
You could synthesize a contiguous area of Chicago that would lead the nation in per capita homicides (an easy thing to do here would be to just take Englewood, with its 48 homicides and 29,000 population). But of course, you'd be comparing Englewood to all of (say) St. Louis, which is also quite a livable city overall.
Re:Seattle in Progress by wonderwonder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:12PM (#36872327)
Chicago is especially dangerous. It leads the nation in murders. You can argue that per capita wise it does not but its still one of the higher rates for large cities.
Re:Seattle in Progress by tptacek on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @06:05PM (#36885818)
No, it doesn't. There are a lot of murders in Chicago in large part because it's a huge city. Per capita, we don't even make the top 10.
Re:Seattle in Progress by sedev on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:26PM (#36872031)
The news is wrong. Especially about the CHAZ. Source: live here.
Re:Seattle in Progress by seattleman on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:25PM (#36872020)
It's a beautiful city with a temperate climate, nearby mountains and ocean, thriving arts and music scenes, good schools, sports, unique and walkable neighborhoods, and a bunch of other things that people look for when they decide where they want to put down roots. Yes, there is a drug problem, and parts of the city are quite bad, but if you walked around Capitol Hill today you'd probably enjoy yourself and feel quite safe!
Re:Seattle in Progress by jshmrsn on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:22PM (#36871999)
Amazon is based in Seattle, Microsoft is based nearby. Google, Apple, Facebook, etc. all setup offices there as a result. There’s a concentration of wealth, talent, and offspring startups.
Re:Seattle in Progress by wonderwonder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:46PM (#36872169)
Thank you for an unemotional, factual response, much appreciated.
Re:Seattle in Progress by coding123 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:25PM (#36872019)
That is exactly what I saw when I drove through.
Re:Seattle in Progress by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:59PM (#36872250)
As a Seattle resident, I'm all for bad news discouraging growth. Unfortunately, I can't convince out-of-towners that it rains 400 days a year here and that all the sidewalks are filled with fentanyl tents.

Seriously though, Seattle has its problems. We really should fully staff the police department, throw more people into jail (before they kill someone), and just enforce laws on shoplifting and such. That being said, it is still a very nice place to live, and in spite of its problems is still a top tier city compared to other cities in the USA (but you never heard that from me, read the first paragraph).

Re:Seattle in Progress by wonderwonder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:03PM (#36872279)
lol, I did forget about the rain. I've always though Seattle must have great suburbs with the wealth and climate.

Is crime something you see a lot of down town, or if you are not looking you really dont notice?

Re:Seattle in Progress by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:11PM (#36872321)
Seattle has an above average property crime rate and a below average violent crime rate. This is always how it has been, since my parents met in the city in 1960s, at least.

First, Capitol Hill isn't really downtown, it is off to the side I rarely go there unless I have to go to a hospital or something (and even then, that is more first hill). So when you mention Capitol Hill, you aren't really talking about downtown. As for Downtown, it has a lot of unhoused neighbors (think Skid Row in LA), but that was true in the mid-90s when I worked at 3rd and Pine McDonalds (aka Crack-donalds, residents will know the place). They don't do anything, you are more likely to experience property crime in Ballard or Capitol Hill then anything in downtown (well, that isn't completely true, a lot of unhoused people are victims in crime to other unhoused people in downtown, but other people are mostly unaffected). Downtown is also full of cruise ship tourists these days, and the market, which again, you won't notice much crime if you ever need to go there at all (which you don't need to go there, since there isn't much there for residents anymore). You do see people shoplifting at Target a lot though, the security guards will just watch them as they walk out with a bunch of stuff (Downtown is a bit better on this now, but I saw someone walk out with stuff at the Ballard Target the other day, Ballard being nowhere near downtown).

Re:Seattle in Progress by carabiner on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @10:49PM (#36872561)
I don't notice crime anywhere in Seattle besides the occasional homeless in any city. I got some Korean food in cap hill a few weeks ago, it was pretty good. Most of my time outside around town is spent going on runs around lake union or riding my bike in the green lake area. Just yesterday I was in downtown near pike place to do some clothes shopping. I got lunch at a Filipino place. I did not notice any thefts, murders, or trespassing.

Your line of questioning sounds weird though, like "have you stopped beating your wife?" Please note that CHAZ was a few blocks out of a city of 700k people and hundreds of blocks that was in existence for a few weeks 3 years ago. Nobody cares about it.

Re:Seattle in Progress by lazyasciiart on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @02:23AM (#36873758)
I live in Capitol Hill and walk around there and Downtown and no, unless you count graffiti or looking visibly homeless, there isn't much visible crime. The actual worst impact of crime on us is that our car, parked on the street every night, has now been broken into twice in five years, and the local QFC and Safeway have both closed their secondary entrance and have more stuff locked away when you go shopping.