Q: Is Orion open-source?
A: We’re working on it!...[0]
Q: Is Orion truly safe if it’s not open-source?
A: The idea that "open-source = trustworthy" only goes so far...[1]
Don’t think it’s much different to use a closed source application than it is to use an open source app that somebody else compiled and put into your systems package repository.
Orion and Kagi (subscription search engine) are both great products, been using them for over a year, though I main FF.
What about the fact that in the case of the open source application, there are people not directly motivated to not mention problems for the good of the company, with the ability to look at the source code?
[12] yes, yes, yes, it is possible to run that proprietary tool through Ghidra (et al) to look for nasties as well but this is far harder, you don't just run a diff between two binaries.
Dealing with opensource project is way easy tbh.
lot of businesses live or die on the trust of their customers. don't they? arc's product is aimed at power users. surely if they were collecting telemetry and then trying to hide the fact they were transmitting it would be a critical blow when discovered.
so while i totally agree that they _could_ operate like that, in most cases there is very little to be gained and a lot to be lost by being intentionally deceptive.
so this will kind of diverge on what we consider as "proof", but i don't think that the software would need to be permanently monitored for a reasonable assurance.
the bar for proof would certainly vary though.
You save a password to the keychain in safari, and then you go to the “passwords” system preferences panel and you see those passwords. Or the other way around—creating a password from system preferences makes it accessible in browser. It appears on the surface to just be a password app, not a safari bucket.
It also works this way if you use the iCloud passwords app from windows. All of your saved passwords show up there as well, despite the absence of safari.
I’m pretty sure the new Chrome extension also shares your existing passwords.
I think it’s a reasonable assumption that when an app claims to use the keychain that you will have access to all your previously saved passwords.
When you view passwords in Orion, you are also viewing passwords saved on Keychain, just in this case Orion's bucket.
There are various system API's that allow apps to read from each other's bucket (obviously all Apple apps have access to Apple's keychain bucket). This is how you can autofill passwords from different keychains in Orion (for example Apple's - which I call Safari's because this is how typically passwords land in it).
Orion Browser by Kagi: Very fast. Zero telemetry.
Lightweight, natively built with WebKit, made for you and your Mac. Industry-leading battery life, privacy respecting by design and native support for web extensions.
Orion supports Firefox and Chrome browser extensions natively. Whether you prefer getting them from the Chrome Web Store or Firefox Add-Ons... as well as bringing support for as many as we can to iOS…
https://browser.kagi.com/