Like someone else mentioned, if he had been hit by a car you wouldn't be suggesting he force himself to do anything. Clinical depression is your brain being hit by a car. If he had been hit by a car, who cares about whether his coworkers found their work harder as a consequence?
I think it's misguided to think that there aren't many people force themselves to work in that and worse conditions. Why? They need the money.
It's seriously misguided, to think you can have any successful career without being able to force yourself to work. Quitting work everytime there is a hicup will not generally lead to a successful career. Not being able to work at all because the sun is out, your kid is long term sick, your wife had an affair, etc will generally not lead to having a successful career. There are many scenarios on a daily basis where people force themselves to work.
> if he had been hit by a car you wouldn't be suggesting he force himself to do anything
If cleared for work and needed to keep their job, yes I would. Many people do in fact force themselves to work after truamatic events such as being hit by a car or being in a car accident.
And remember, I didn't say in this scenario he should have forced himself to work. In fact, I said I had no problems with him not. But I said it is a skill that is needed for many in life.
And some people end up committing suicide after severe depression, so? "Push yourself harder" isn't usually the answer.
Very few treatment plans haver "quit your job and do nothing" to solve depression. Being unemployed is normally more depressing than having a job. It's a downward spiral.
Since nobody is advocating "doing nothing", I think you have a nice strawman going on there.
In another post you also equate being depressed with "flaking out".
I'm going to guess you know nothing about clinical depression, so spare me the description of what you think the treatment plans are.
This may be unintentional, or I may be misreading you, but this seems to represent a serious misunderstanding of clinical depression.
I did not observe a prior post claiming that there aren't many people who force themselves work, whether for money or any other perceived gain.
Lack of perceived gain is a typical part of clinical depression. A more likely motivator is aversion to perceived worsening; even this can fail to motivate because of tendency to evaluate the likelihood of success of an action as minimal or non-existant. With clinical depression, a frequent observation is that having completed something successfully, or being rewarded for a thing (even as simple as being given or biting into a food yow enjoy) may produce no improvement of mood.
> It's seriously misguided, to think you can have any successful career without being able to force yourself to work. Quitting work everytime there is a hicup will not generally lead to a successful career. Not being able to work at all because the sun is out, your kid is long term sick, your wife had an affair, etc will generally not lead to having a successful career. There are many scenarios on a daily basis where people force themselves to work.
Yes, clinical depression does tend to cause serious misguidance. The likelihood of a successful career, regardless of efforts may seem maximal. The condition does not seem occur in response to a hiccup of circumstance. It tends to result from prolonged exposure to a series of negative events, producing a situation in which the expectation of those events ending, or of those events being replaced by positive ones, does not exist.
Based on what you've written so far, I tentatively hypothesize that you have had a fortunate life[1]. This is generally good, though tends to lead people to conclude that depressed people just need to try more, or are just in a temporary phase, or just need decide to cheer up, do something useful, knuckle through it…
Getting out of clinical depression usually requires external changes. Some people are lucky enough to experience periods of partial remission sufficient to perceive the benefit of seeking help or changing their circumstances, which can lead to full remission.
[1] While acknowledging that getting through some manner of adversity does not automatic'ly require that one has had depression during that period.
And work through two additional weeks without the strength to even brush their teeth? Doesn't seem realistic to me.
And yes, I've been there. Burnt out, depressed, you name it. It's always possible to muster up the energy to do the right thing.
Your comment reads like a form of victim-blaming, "they should have never gotten into a situation that left them severely depressed".
What!?!?
This not true. It is possible to have no more reserves. It is possible to argue that ideally you should be able to predict your imminent collapse, but not everybody is afforded this luxury.
But I did point out that sometimes in life we need to force ourselves to work. Why? Because we need an income. Some people live a life where they don't need to work but most of us don't. Plenty of us had to go to work in scenarios where we didn't want to. Other half is long-term sick, kid is on school holiday, it's sunny outside, etc.
It’s like telling a tennis player to keep playing a few more matches after breaking an arm in an accident. Tough up kid! It’s a hard world out there.
No pro tennis player hasn't played a game injured. No professional athlete has gone through their career without playing injured. Every off-season we hear the list of injuries players have been playing through.
To be successful you must force yourself to do things you don't want to do. And not telling someone who just flaked out of their first job that is a diservice.
Well, you did reply to someone claiming severe depression and burnout, so the specifics matter.
If you meant to post about hard work and doing stuff that might not be enjoyable in pursue of a paycheck, that's fine, but do you think it's warranted in reply to this specific case?
It'd be like going into generalities about how one can push oneself harder to run a 100 meters sprint when talking to someone without legs or arms. I mean, yes, sure, but isn't it a touch insensitive?
I did say that it's a skill they should learn not that they should have done it in this case. So if we're saying specifics matter, the entire context of specifics matter.
> If you meant to post about hard work and doing stuff that might not be enjoyable in pursue of a paycheck, that's fine, but do you think it's warranted in reply to this specific case?
Yes, the person flaked out of their first job after seemingly a few months and literally asked if they should have forced themselves to work their 2 week notice period.
Telling them everything is ok is not the nice thing to do. It's an easy thing to do. It seems compassionate. But it's not. It shows no feeling or concern for their future. As pointed out with multiple examples, there are plenty of times people need to force themselves to work. It is an important skill to have to succeed.
They flaked out of their first job and flaked out so hard they didn't even manage to give 2 weeks notice. That is the hard reality here. And they specifically asked if they should have given the notice. To not advise them that forcing yourself to work is an important skillset is in my opinion a disservice and uncaring action.
So you gave unrelated advice to someone telling you about a bout of depression? Hm.
> Telling them everything is ok is not the nice thing to do. It's an easy thing to do.
I think you'll find your "easy way" is not the way to treat severe depression. It's a long, hard road.
You think being depressed is "flaking out"? Shame on you.
At which point would you say it's ok to admit you were wrong and that you misread the post? Is this really the hill you want to die on?
They literally asked if they were being unprofessional and if they should have forced themselves to work. Telling them that being able to force themselves to work is a useful skillset if they want to keep a job is not unrelated.
> You think being depressed is "flaking out"? Shame on you.
No, the fact you need to come up with just an absurd statement really shows what you're all about.
They didn't give the industry standard notice period, they as far as we can tell, just said "I'm not coming back". That is flaking out. If you did it because you were depressed or because it's sunny outside doesn't really change the fact it's flaking out.
> At which point would you say it's ok to admit you were wrong and that you misread the post? Is this really the hill you want to die on?
Misread what? You need to misrepresent my position.
In another comment you said I have no experience of depression.
I've been on sucide watches so extreme, they took away my clothes, gave me untearable clothes, only gave me fingerfood, left me in an empty room with just a mattress and an untearable blanket, and had someone sit there and watch me nonstop. The reason I know that mental hospitals will force you to be active is I was there and they annoyed the shit out of me with it. I was diganosed with depression at the age of 9. One professional said that I had been depressed for so long that I basically considered it normal. I almost certainly have more experience with it than many others.
You also implied a strawman argument because I think someone who says they struggled to brush their teeth because they were so depressed would have been sitting around doing nothing because well they couldn't even brush their teeth. That's just extrapolating. Very simple logic.
This was your first and only job. (Therapy is still on going and a month ago you asked what is happening and got some feedback about someone else quitting.) Which is why you don't understand the 2 weeks notice isn't just for you to be productive but to help hand things over.
Realistically, your former colleagues probably had to figure out what you had done and not done. This will leave a nasty after taste.
My understanding is that 2 weeks notice is more of a being nice and not actually required. Most companies won't give you any more notice than they're legally required to. Therefore, I have no problem with people giving them the legally minimum notice.
But overall, you'll find there are many times where you just need to force yourself to work. This is probably a skill you should learn if you need a job to survive.