Re:Is technical analysis just stock market astrology?
by stouset on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:51PM
(#36865344)
By the time you have this information and are reasonably act on it, it has already been priced in by participants with deeper pockets, better access, and rapid processing of relevant information sources.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Is technical analysis just stock market astrology?
by 99_00 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:03PM
(#36865567)
The prediction of a crop failure isn't a binary event and money isn't deployed in a binary strategy. It becomes more or less likely over time.
Also, the situation is very dynamic with an unknown and very large number of variables, even with something as seemingly simple as a crop failure. Such as such as a countries deciding to ban exports to secure food security, lack of access to fertilizer due to sanctions against major fertilizer producers in wheat producing countries, the politics of national and local water rights.
All these factors have parties with inside information acting on them (see members of congress trading stocks) which no player with big pockets will have access to but is all reflected in the price.
Re:Is technical analysis just stock market astrology?
by stouset on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @05:10PM
(#36869625)
Nobody is saying these things are binary events. But betting that you're going to more accurately guess the odds of these events than dedicated players with enormous sums of money behind them and who are supported by professional research teams is⦠maybe not a strategy with positive expected value.