News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by readingnews on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:29PM (#36856138)
I was promoted to one of those "mod" type people who reviews new answers, first posts, etc, a few years back.

I can tell you that I quit in the last 6 months. All new answers are answers on questions from first time posters, answering questions that have good solid answers from 8+ years ago (mostly 10 years), and it is pretty obvious, they are just doing it to get points. The question/answer is not something that has changed in the last 8+ years, they are just doing it to get reputation or whatever.

Most good solid questions...I just do not see too many today. I am not saying this is the reason for the decline, but there is a deluge of posts answering very old questions with a slight modification of an old answer. I quit putting effort into it, as it was just non-productive.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by kibwen on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:39PM (#36856244)
I recall that about ten years ago there were reports that edits to Wikipedia were slowing precipitously. People wondered if this meant the imminent death of Wikipedia. With the benefit of hindsight, it seems more plausible that Wikipedia had merely shifted from its adolescent phase to its mature phase, and that all the low-hanging fruit had simply been harvested. If we look at the stats, Wikipedia's edit velocity maxed out in early 2007 (37 days per 10M edits), then fell to half that in late 2014 (73 days per 10M edits), and has actually increased a fair bit since then: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Time_Between_Edits

It's entirely possible that the same is happening to SO.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by robomartin on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:42PM (#36856269)
I wonder if this might be partly because they have not made an effort to make their software be more intelligent about surfacing answers to questions as well as evaluating answers. I would think that, at some point, it isn't necessarily the fault of the question authors or those responding.

One of the things I say with some frequency is that all failures are engineering problems. Blaming the users/customers, in the end, fails to take advantage of an opportunity to improve the product, learn from mistakes and improve process.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by smashed on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:44PM (#36856289)
Thanks for your work as a mod.

While I understand it's a lot of work, and some (most?) might be posting low quality answers, my main problem with stack overflow has been exactly that over time, the top answer becomes stale.

The question is still relevant, but the best practice or library, platform whatever changed... That is a problem the stack overflow model has a hard time adapting too.. and it just gets worst over time..

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by readingnews on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:59PM (#36856414)
From my purview, and again I am a tiny data point of one, the new answers to old questions are really:

Original accepted upvoted to +20 answer: "Take Y and drive it into X, grep output for Z and place in AZ for processing with the -kombucha switch"

Answer posted yesterday by "NewUserXX123", a first post: "Take A and drive it into B, grep output for C and place it in DD for processing with the -kombucha switch"

It gets pretty tiring responding with a custom comment and downvoting, only to have "NewUserXX123" then cuss you out in a DM about how you are a total @!#$%()&!@$%.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by technion on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:22PM (#36856622)
That's going to depend on your domain, because most fronted d questions I come across end in "there is a jquery plugin for that" which don't help modern sites without jquery.
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by smeagull on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:46PM (#36856308)
> answering questions that have good solid answers from 8+ years ago (mostly 10 years),

I hit upon those useless answers all the time. I have no need to know about solutions that might have worked a decade ago and are obsolete. Stack Overflow is useless now.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by ourmandave on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:22PM (#36856620)
Yeah, except for those of us working on old software that still runs the business.
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by DangitBobby on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:34PM (#36857546)
I find Stack Overflow answers don't usually indicate which versions of software the solution was good for. Is that not your experience?
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by brodouevencode on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:04PM (#36856452)
> and it is pretty obvious, they are just doing it to get points

Gamifying reputation was one of the worst things we've done. I was part of this in previous positions and after a while it became apparent that it brought out the worst in people. There are better ways of incentivizing usage rather than stupid internet points.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by woleium on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:11PM (#36856513)
I'm not sure if up voting this comment is appropriate, but I wholeheartedly agree
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by brodouevencode on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:53PM (#36857269)
Please don’t
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by glaucon on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:57PM (#36856907)
>Gamifying reputation was one of the worst things

Agreed and I don't know this for sure but the points lust, it seems to me, is not limited to questioners and answers, some of the behaviour I've seen from mods seems to be driven by that too.

Just to repeat, I don't know that because I don't know what gets you points but the behaviour is hard to understand otherwise.

I had a question where I had finished with a one word sentence "Thanks." . A mod had removed that part of the question, when I looked at their record they had an awful lot of edits which consisted of similar, tiny, non-substantive changes. It did make me wonder about their motivation.

Anyway, yes, imho gamification not a good idea.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by jodrellblank on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:11PM (#36857013)
> "I had a question where I had finished with a one word sentence "Thanks." . A mod had removed that part of the question, when I looked at their record they had an awful lot of edits which consisted of similar, tiny, non-substantive changes. It did make me wonder about their motivation."

https://stackoverflow.com/help/behavior

"Do not use signature, taglines, greetings, thanks, or other chitchat.

"Every post you make is already “signed” with your standard user card, which links directly back to your user page. Your user page belongs to you, so fill it with information about your interests, links to stuff you’ve worked on, or whatever else you like!"

"Thanks and other statements of appreciation are unnecessary, and, like other chitchat, should not be included."

"If you use signatures, taglines, greetings, thanks, or other chitchat, they will be removed to reduce noise in the questions and answers."

----

Removing it doesn't get the editor any points, they are spending their time cleaning up your question to site standards for no reward at all.

https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/260776/should-i-rem...

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by DangitBobby on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:24PM (#36857488)
Seems like a non-issue not warranting an edit practically ever. Very irritating policy.
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by thackerhacker on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:44PM (#36857607)
I asked about this 10 years ago and look at the sarcasm I received in response.

https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/142703

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by jodrellblank on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @08:32AM (#36861299)
What would you think if you clicked on a Wikipedia article about Mozart and instead of the current introduction which says:

> Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart[a][b] (27 January 1756 – 5 December 1791) was a prolific and influential composer of the Classical period. Despite his short life, his rapid pace of composition resulted in more than 800 works of virtually every genre of his time.

it opened with:

> Hello everyone, I studied classical music in college but have been out of the scene for a while and now I'm getting back in, I was wondering about the history of Mozart and I remember that his middle name was Allen or Almond or something? Can anyone help? Thanks for any information. || Hi, I learned about him in middle school and we all joked that his middle name was Armadillo but I think that's wrong, haha. || Greets all, it's in Olivier Hallengrunsch's Classical Composers as 'Amadeus', and that's well regarded. It also says he lived (27 January 1756 – 5 December 1791). I think we can all agree he was prolific, right? Thanks and regards, Jason [xxKiller; AMD Ryzen2 32GB RAM 2TB Western Digital SSD; BMW 330 2l aircooled] || Why's nobody mentioning how short that life was, smh || Good evening all and sundry, m'lady (tips hat), forsooth would anyone speak to how many works he is believed to have composed, all considered? Methinks such knowledge would be a most hearty addition to this esteemed gentleman's biography - Martin, [Fort Lauderdale TX Ren. Faire organiser 1997-1997] || etc.

StackOverflow isn't a forum, it's a collaborative reference work. Meta-chat would be edited out of a wikipedia page and goes on a separate 'talk' page (equivalent: meta stackexchanges or the stackexchange chat). What if you then went to the Wikipedia talk page and said "Is overzealous moderation of questions ruining Wikipedia? I want to be able to edit questions and greetings into pages but there are hoards of awful literal-minded jobsworths cruising the site just looking for the slightest reason to edit a spelling or grammar mistake or revert my changes. It just leaves me feeling unwelcome"?

Why would you expect to feel welcome when you're spoiling what others are trying to build up and insulting them for caring??

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by metabagel on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @11:17AM (#36863573)
At least Wikipedia has a facility for meta chat.
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by jodrellblank on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:43PM (#36865208)
Stackoverflow has https://meta.stackoverflow.com/ and https://chat.stackoverflow.com/ (you see it when the comments on a question or answer go on too long, there's an automatic "comments are not for extended discussion, take it to chat" reply, or you can invite people to a chatroom about a question).
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by svieira on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:46PM (#36857618)
What are the best ways of externally incentivizing usage that aren't numeric that you know of or think would be worth looking into?
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by ourmandave on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:27PM (#36856657)
At least they let you sort by most recent answer date now.

Some really old questions (circa 2009) have the answer to the latest version, that required scrolling through multiple pages.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by agosta on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:01PM (#36856936)
I hear your point and thank you for your service as one. That said, how much do we think this is more attributed to the existence of coding AIs like Co-pilot or ChatGPT. I hardly use stack overflow anymore thanks to OpenAI
Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by qqtt on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:49PM (#36857237)
Why was there such a heavy handed approach to moderation in the first place though? Why not let the community ask the same question over and over again, and let the answers naturally shift with the time?

I'm just not sure what value there was to have a team of people volunteer their time to making sure there were absolutely zero duplicated questions/answers? What problem is that solving? If anything, it is adding problems by not letting the content naturally evolve in time.

If people want to assess the quality of answers, it's better to have multiple data points, and SO could have invested those resources in algorithmically linking similar questions and making it easy to navigate by both answer reputation and time.

Along similarly lines, it seems best to tackle the people trying to game the system algorithmically as well - if content is word for word duplicate, that's a problem which can be solved by computers instead of people (similar text is a solved problem).

It seems the only use case for moderators on SO is for removing truly inappropriate content - it's wild to me that moderators were spending significant amounts of time actually removing technical questions and answers.

It reminds me a bit of reddit moderation, where reddit communities enforce these non-sensical rules and by extension require hugely heavy handed moderation to 'curate' their communities. Like, the headphones subreddit disallows pictures of headphones in boxes. Why? If the community is interested in headphones, what's the difference if it's a box or not? It's not like if you take it out of the box the headphones look different than any picture you can find on the internet.

Seems like many of the problems of moderation are artificial rules endlessly being enforced by real people which ends up just being pseudo 'make busy' work.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by Spooky23 on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:42PM (#36857589)
They talked about it in the Stack Exchange podcast years ago.

IIRC, the vision of the perfect question was one with a canonical answer. They didn’t want to be Quora. I think that concept made and makes a lot of sense, but doesn’t capture the “meta” issues surrounding how you litigate the form of the question, especially as questions get more nuanced.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by appplication on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:22PM (#36857478)
When it comes to software, it’s even less sensical to have one archival correct answer, given that software evolves over time, and what was an acceptable or necessary workaround 5-10 years ago could be a complete anti pattern today.

It would more sense to establish lineage. Lock older questions from more answers after some point in time, and instead of closing and linking to original, do it the other way. Keep new questions open and link to past variations. Then in the old threads indicate newer guidance may exist and link forward.

Re:The Fall of Stack Overflow by throwawaaarrgh on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:03AM (#36858120)
I couldn't figure out how to gain any points other than answering my own question, but I needed points to contribute in any way. It's like SO is set up to be difficult to use. I can't imagine why anyone keeps using it.